Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by edgyquant on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:14PM
(#49469809)
Are brains responsible for consciousness? Or are brains a tool that our consciousness uses to understand the world?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by Dylan16807 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:32PM
(#49470050)
They seem to be. But that argument doesn't matter much because you can simulate the whole body. (If you want to argue consciousness is outside the body, I could get into the physics argument but instead I'll just claim that consciousness will attach to the computer too and if you have a reason it wouldn't it's your burden to say why.)
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by edgyquant on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:36PM
(#49470097)
I don’t know where consciousness is but I think if we accept that you can simulate a brain exactly that doesn’t prove consciousness of a model as consciousness is a metaphysical concept really
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by mannykannot on Thursday August 27, 2026 @04:07PM
(#49470501)
Consciousness appears to be a biological phenomenon, but so too are metabolism, reproduction and evolution. Are these also metaphysical concepts?
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by edgyquant on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:42PM
(#49472673)
Consciousness does not appear to be biological, that is an opinion and a highly debated one
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by mannykannot on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:36PM
(#49473386)
Where does it appear outside of biology?
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by edgyquant on Friday August 28, 2026 @10:24AM
(#49478950)
Where does consciousness appear in biology? It’s a philosophical/metaphysical concept so far as I can tell
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by mannykannot on Saturday August 29, 2026 @08:43AM
(#49489467)
The one thing that I think all philosophers agree on is that the only confirmed cases of consciousness discovered so far are biological. They are divided over whether there is anything fundamentally more metaphysical about it than other biological phenomena (with Dennett having been the best-known dissenter, though he has many successors), and the debate has been going on without resolution for centuries, if not millennia.
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by Dylan16807 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:42PM
(#49470162)
This seems like a different topic from whether consciousness "uses" the brain?
But I will point out we don't have a way to prove anything is conscious, not even a human.
Re:Humanity has the debate about AI consciousness backwards
by teravor on Friday August 28, 2026 @12:10AM
(#49474265)
you might as well call consciousness a soul at this point.
something I once wondered about is what a soul can be and what implications it would have. the conclusions I drew is that the entire concept was incoherent. if a soul is so intrinsically linked to the brain (experience) such that it always goes along for the ride even into the abyss (eg. dementia) then it by itself wouldn't have any value even if it existed.