News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by ChuckMcM on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:17PM (#49453470)
I think the Bambu case is a good one to litigate the AGPL but perhaps should start in the Court of International Trade. That court has the power to block imports as part of a TRO which would shut down a lot of their revenue from the US at least. Doing something similar in Europe would also help apply pressure. Takes lawyers and money though, of which there is certainly not enough of the latter.

Not to be too glib here, but its one of the paradoxes of "free software" which is there isn't any money generated by the licenses that keep it free. Where as "licensed" software has a revenue stream that is used to enforce the license against people who fail to honor it. The FSF can only do so much with their budget here.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by Aurornis on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:51PM (#49453934)
The article says the SFC had a fundraiser and raised over $250,000 to hire a lawyer.

There's a confusing part of the article where he says that what he believes is a violation is something that a judge isn't going to care about. I don't know if he's implying that the judges aren't capable of interpreting the AGPL properly, or if he's admitting that the legal argument isn't as solid as they thought it was when they started. It's a confusing thing to say next to the broad claims about violations.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by JoshTriplett on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:26PM (#49454495)
I think he's saying the opposite: that "clever" attempts to work around the license aren't things a judge is going to appreciate.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by Aurornis on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:44PM (#49454746)
That would make more sense. Thank you.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by biker142541 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:05PM (#49454156)
That confused me as well. I interpreted as judges not having (much) precedent and potentially unable/unwilling to interpret along lines of the license intent. But that’s what courts in this process are there for IMO. If a well written license and a good case, then you need to start somewhere to set precedent.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by ZiiS on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:10PM (#49454228)
He is saying a judge will not care that they are technically a separate download. They only care if the end result is complying with the spirit of the license.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by pocksuppet on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @09:50PM (#49458481)
GPL licenses are so much interpreted along lines of license intent that a German judge ruled GPLv2 software couldn't be Tivoized.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by john01dav on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:01AM (#49460911)
I would expect this to forcibly unlock the bootloaders of every Android phone sold in Germany (because the Linux kernel, used on all such phones, is GPLv2, and to replace it the bootloader must be unlocked, and tivoization means restriction of the right to replace it), yet as far as I know this is not the case.

So, what am I missing? Which specific German cases are you thinking about?

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by pocksuppet on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:58PM (#49468729)
Steck vs AVM. But the bootloader on your phone is still locked because companies don't have to comply with the law until you sue them. If you live in Germany, you should sue them.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by simiones on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:20AM (#49464495)
Can you share a link?

This would be a vindication of the SFC's position, which holds that what people commonly call "TiVoization" was in fact already not allowed by the GPLv2, and that the GPLv3 makes a slightly more complicated requirement.

Specifically, the SFC generally claims that the GPLv2 doesn't allow you to distribute hardware running GPLv2 software on it and then refuse to allow customers to modify or update this software themselves*.

Instead, they claim that what TiVo actually did that necessitated the creation of the GPLv3 is more complicated: you were perfectly well allowed to modify the Linux system on your TiVo box, BUT the proprietary TiVo software would thereafter refuse to run. Basically, you could either use the TiVo with only official TiVo software, OR you could use it as your own Linux PC, but NOT both.

According to the SFC, this is the only difference between GPLv2 and GPLv3 in this area - if the functionality of the product you received is allowed to be degraded intentionally because of modifications you make under your GPL rights. Linux with its GPLv2 license allows this, but much of the GNU utils, with the GPLv3 license, don't at this time.

* unless the hardware itself is incapable of loading modified software, of course, such as the case where the software is burned into a ROM and no one can update it.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by ChuckMcM on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:33PM (#49454581)
For background, I participated in a "small" action that Sun took against someone who was violating the Java license. The legal fees (in the late 90's) were 8.2 million dollars. $250K is nothing to sneeze at, its a solid 6 weeks of a single lawyer's time, maybe a couple of weeks for a small team. Against a company doing nearly a billion dollars a year in revenue[1] and owning 29% of the printer market? Add in a couple of expert witnesses which are essential to that sort of a case and you'll see that $250K isn't even table stakes. Sad, I know, but it is the way things are these days.

And the saddest thing is that Bambu knows this. They know that people who give away software are not a serious threat to them. And it is especially galling that the value they have extracted out of that software will pay the lawyers that keep you from preventing them from continuing to extract that value and keep it for themselves.

[1] "Media reports have also indicated that Bambu Lab has shipped more than 1.2 million units, claiming a 29% global share." -- https://kr-asia.com/bambu-lab-nears-usd-100-billion-valuatio...

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by bonoboTP on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:37PM (#49455532)
Lawyers earn 250k per 6 weeks? More than 2M per year?
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by ChuckMcM on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:39PM (#49455567)
Yes. Well they certainly bill at that rate, it goes some to the lawyer, some to rent, etc.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by bonoboTP on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:11PM (#49456619)
Outrageous cartel then. For such amounts there would be plenty who would have intellectual chops to do the job, driving the price down. Legal costs are nowhere close to this outside the US.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by LastTrain on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:41PM (#49458914)
IP litigation is absolutely that expensive, outside the US and inside. Didn’t you just come into this conversation unaware of what IP litigators earn?
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by Ancapistani on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:57PM (#49459036)
Can you imagine how litigious we'd be if legal services were cheaper?
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by john01dav on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:09AM (#49460964)
This just means that there's pent up demand for litigation that is currently left unfulfilled because it's too expensive. Or, equivalently, many people think that they have been wronged and must simply take it, due to litigation being the only option to enforce that issue while litigation is too expensive to be affordable to them, or more expensive than the cost of the dispute (so, in effect, scamming people out of small dollar amounts is legal since the cost of enforcing one's legal rights may be in excess of the cost of the dispute).

Imagine what would happen if we made it cheaper, as happens very frequently when some other good or service becomes cheaper? Usually the provision/manufacture has some advancements that make it much more scalable, and often less involved, resulting in a lower cost, and sometimes but not always lower quality. So, for litigation? We'd get lower cost, via some more efficient¹ system², maybe lower quality depending on how we make that system more efficient and this may or may not matter in any particular case, and then those people who think that they've been wronged suddenly have an avenue to address it. Overall, this seems like a strong positive to me.

Now, what if people start enforcing frivolous legal rights? Repeal or reform the law that creates the right if it' s so bad. What about people dragging others into court in bad faith? Well, we just streamlined the bureaucracy and took a buzz-saw to the costs, so is it hard to defend against? Perhaps not. Making that perhaps a certain reality would be a good goal of such reform methods. We already allow people with more money and systemic literacy to bully people in this way, and this is a large part of litigiousness in our society now, so this strategy becoming ineffective may reduce it substantially and thus ironically make litigiousness less intense in at least some cases.

1: one proposal off the top of my head (so it may be terrible): sending written documents to a judge with LLMs helping lay people write and refine them, or a cheaper-than-a-litigation-lawyer expert human review service, perhaps, then the judge rules on their own schedule asynchronously for civil disputes without any heavy procedure to deal with.

2: another proposal is to remove law school/JD requirements to obtain a law license, but keeping a rigorous test in place and maybe some less-intense character/background checks, to lower the pay of lawyers

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by CDRdude on Thursday August 27, 2026 @10:37AM (#49465616)
> 2: another proposal is to remove law school/JD requirements to obtain a law license, but keeping a rigorous test in place […]

This does exist, but has become less common over time instead of more common. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reading_law

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by john01dav on Thursday August 27, 2026 @04:03PM (#49470443)
That is not meaningfully different to my estimation, since it is not test-only. Instead, you need to get accepted to an internship/apprenticeship, and then do that for a number of years, prior to having the law license. For gatekeeping purposes, this is functionally the same as requiring getting accepted into a law school and then doing that for a number of years prior to having the law license.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by dghlsakjg on Sunday August 30, 2026 @07:07PM (#49503725)
There are still states that allow anyone that can pass the bar exam to practice law without any experience or internship.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by Ancapistani on Sunday August 30, 2026 @10:29PM (#49504951)
Name them?

I’m only aware of California and Virginia, both of which I believe have an apprenticeship requirement.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by simiones on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:29AM (#49464626)
Nothing stops anyone from briging a suit and representing themselves.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by gerdesj on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:35PM (#49457876)
Have a look at this: https://ukcalculator.com/barrister-fees-calculator.html

It is for the UK but no doubt m'learned friends in the US can command even higher fees.

Try grabbing a KC for five days, civil/commercial with all the trimmings. That will set you back £105,000.

Obviously the impoverished KC won't pocket all that lolly. There is VAT to pay and staff costs and stuff.

A KC is one of these: https://kcappointments.org/ for obvious reasons they used to known as QCs

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by dghlsakjg on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:39PM (#49457906)
Lawyers fees for a case like that also include expenses, and this would be on the high side.

Court fees, fees for accessing case law, experts, paralegals, etc.

You pay the lawyer and a big portion of that goes towards his costs for additional labour and everything else. A lawyer grossing $2m/year isn't bringing home anything close to that.

That said $250k for a single lawyer for 6 weeks seems high.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by LastTrain on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:31PM (#49458807)
Yes. About 5-10% at a big firm earn that.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by devmor on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:38AM (#49460224)
I've only had to hire a lawyer once, and it was $2,500 to have them file a couple papers and speak to the judge once.

You're paying for their experience, just like an engineer - only it's often much higher stakes than a piece of software or product: your livelihood or freedom.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by bonoboTP on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:22AM (#49463620)
The reason engineers don't cost this much is that lawyers are lawyer brained smooth talking networking types who hold together tightly and have a quid pro quo system and you have to pay protection money to their mafia. Law is based on rubbing elbows in the right places, playing tennis and golf with the right people and in case of jury trials, on acting convincingly and exuding a certain image to manipulate their emotions. Engineers are too autistic to hold together end rent seek this much.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by LastTrain on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:30AM (#49466448)
But some engineers do make that much. I say this as a fellow software engineer: why do so many of my colleagues think every other profession is worthless bullshit? BTW, statistically, SEs and Lawyers earn about the same...
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by bonoboTP on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:18PM (#49469877)
The top of top frontier AI research talent maybe makes 2M and I'd guess you have at most a few hundred such people globally but maybe just a few dozen.

Non "FAANG" (or whatever the new term is) software engineers often make sub-100k even in the US. And regular sw engineers won't break above 500k unless they are managers heading some large team or branch. Getting over 1M is almost superstar level as a sw engineer. If you think it's common, you must be in a tiny SV bubble.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by LastTrain on Thursday August 27, 2026 @06:53PM (#49472322)
I said some, and pointed out that on average SE’s and lawyers get paid about the same. This conversation started on IP litigators, who generally have a BS degree in a related field and often times experience in the industry they practice, so yes they are amongst the best compensated.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by bonoboTP on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:32PM (#49472618)
Aside, but IP is a propaganda term. These laws are not property rights, their purposes are varied and usually have the wider public as the beneficiary in their reasoning for existing, it's not like ensuring right to actual property.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by ChickeNES on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:39PM (#49455580)
I guess I need to buy another printer to fund the other side?
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by sailfast on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:10AM (#49464359)
I would imagine any settlement dollars would be enough of a carrot to get a lawyer involved. Has anyone actually sued over this yet?
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by criddell on Thursday August 27, 2026 @10:38AM (#49465626)
It's really difficult to collect any judgement in China.

https://www.internationaldisputeresolutionlaw.com/2025/06/en...

I can't find the source right now, but I believe punitive damages are excluded. So all you could collect would be actual damages. What are the actual damages Bambu owners have suffered?

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by sailfast on Friday August 28, 2026 @12:27PM (#49480869)
My assumption was that a settlement would be part of the “cost of doing business in the USA” so they’d pay up to keep importing their products legally rather than lose the market - but you know what they say about assumptions…
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by mschuster91 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:21PM (#49454406)
> I think the Bambu case is a good one to litigate the AGPL but perhaps should start in the Court of International Trade.

IMHO that kind of stuff would have to go through the WTO but unfortunately Trump gutted that one already way back in his first term.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by WillPostForFood on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:34PM (#49454596)
Some context on the US/WTO conflict. It started under Obama, blocking reappointment of two judges. Trump in term 1 went all in, stopping all appointments. When Biden was elected he fully maintained and supported the policy of blocking judges. So it has been more of a bipartisan policy than "Trump gutted".

https://www.cato.org/blog/biden-administration-continues-be-...

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by _carbyau_ on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:56PM (#49457548)
The article mentions reverse engineering the code.

But is there anything to stop reverse engineering the physical printer itself, improving on it by 10mm build volume in each direction, and releasing that?

It won't be a copy of the Bambu printer AND it can run the same software, truly freely.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by sgarland on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:06PM (#49457615)
There’s no need to reverse engineer it, just build a Voron 2.4.
Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by simiones on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:34AM (#49464696)
Do you mean physically modifying a printer you bought from Bambu, and selling that on? Potentially as a service, where you buy in bulk and re-sell with this modification? If so, I don't see how that would change anything about the software you're allowed to run on it.

Or do you mean manufacturing your own printer that is a copy of theirs with 10mm extra build volume in each direction, and with your own software? That may be illegal if they have any patents, but otherwise should probably be ok, and would of course not have anything to do with their software - but you still couldn't take the software from one of their printers and running it on yours, most likely.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by _carbyau_ on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:05PM (#49473891)
I was thinking more of a make your own copy of their printer and run free software on it rather than theirs.

It just seems like they don't have that much of a moat which is why they are guarding the software bit as much as they can.

Re:An ongoing 3D-printer AGPL violation by krupan on Thursday August 27, 2026 @09:46AM (#49464862)
As long as nothing in the printer's design is patented or trademarked then yes, you can reverse engineer it and sell your own version of it