News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by locknitpicker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:27AM (#49430228)
> (...) a byproduct of getting unusually good at understanding and building things

A PhD is not about getting good at understanding something, let alone "unusually good". It's about being able to explore an uncharted area with little to no help, and write down your learnings so that those that come after you can build upon your work.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by maleldil on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:19AM (#49431033)
In an ideal world, sure. In reality, a PhD[1] is about publishing papers in the hope that you learn something along the way.

[1] My experience in ML in 2026.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by rfgplk on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:55AM (#49431750)
Which is ironic, because self-publishing then should automatically qualify you for a PhD. In fact, I believe more people should take this approach. As far as I'm aware, there's no law or regulation from declaring yourself a "PhD" backed by autoresearch.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by locknitpicker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:17AM (#49431984)
> Which is ironic, because self-publishing then should automatically qualify you for a PhD.

No. What qualifies you as a researcher is being able to output work that is accepted by your peers. Hence the peer review process is critical. You fail to meet this bar if you publish something in blogspot or even arxiv for that matter.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by tescreal on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:41AM (#49432243)
A key problem is upper-level academia is rife with the same sorts of human-scale power dynamics. Petty squabbles, ideological (and ideological-flavoured) views can and do hold entire fields from time to time. It is only a particular type of tenacity that breaks up the status quo from time to time. (consider the Marvin Minsky era of AI research. A big personality can stifle an entire field). Peers aren't usually the appropriate measuring stick of merit.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by locknitpicker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:28AM (#49432804)
> A key problem is upper-level academia is rife with the same sorts of human-scale power dynamics.

You are trying too hard to come up with excuses. The paper review process is double-blind, and nothing prevents you from publishing the same work in multiple journals. If your goal is to do meaningful contributions to science then "power dynamics" are irrelevant.

You do need to develop a meaningful network in the field if your goal is to collaborate with other researchers, but that's basically what everyone needs to do in any professional field.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by tescreal on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:37AM (#49432946)
Entrenched ideas have momentum. Your lone-warrior attitude is admirable if not lacking in substance. Most fields have had occasional hangups on dead ends, such as the aforementioned Minsky "symbolic > connectivist" debacle. Behaviourism in psychology. String theory. The list goes on.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by ndriscoll on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:25AM (#49433652)
Eh, in theoretical fields we now have good formal verification tools so that someone publishing a code repo on their personal website is more meaningful in pretty much every way than a peer reviewed journal article. The article becomes an archaic formality.

Like I get that the current social norms around "research" might not be there yet, but if they refuse to adapt, I just see that as a reason to defund "research" and start from scratch.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by nathan_compton on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:00PM (#49436296)
I've got a PhD in Physics and I have to say that the quality of most "self published" physics is very low, which probably explains why people would not accept a self-declared PhD.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by bonoboTP on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:10AM (#49431365)
Your role is to publish papers so your PI is able to get grants, and to network, so the lab profile gets better known in the research community, and then as a more senior grad student you can help write grant applications, and you can build a track record of mentoring (e.g. master students). At the end of the day, you want to demonstrate that you can come up with projects and pursue the research up until publication in a top-tier venue, and the ultimate goal (from the point of view of hiring committees) is obtaining prestige and funding for the university.

If you plan to go to industry, your incentives are somewhat misaligned with your PI. In that case you want to pursue multiple internships and getting networked with top companies in your field, and demonstrating practical output, well-released code, demonstrated downstream value for followup projects etc.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:29AM (#49432115)
Yes, take away all the pretense and a Ph.D. is just an apprenticeship to be a researcher.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by maleldil on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:26AM (#49435787)
There's no pretense. That's always been the whole point.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:42AM (#49436027)
That's not my experience -- there's a whole pretense about being experts in a field, which is exactly what the poster above bought into. Having a PhD doesn't make or prove you're an expert about anything. It just proves you know how to do research in a thing, but that doesn't stop us from presenting PhDs in front of juries as if they're the only ones who know what they're talking about.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by watwut on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:38PM (#49438608)
Self made experts with no PhD or formal degrees are testifying in front of juries. They dont even need any science to back them.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by maleldil on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:56PM (#49440513)
I don't see how these are incompatible. The PhD prepares you to be an independent researcher. The way you prove this is by studying the same topics for a few years, and by the time you reach your viva, you'd be expected to know a lot about the topic you chose.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:59PM (#49441264)
It's not incompatible, many people in order to do research have to gain a great expertise in a thing. Others can get a Ph.D. having really no expertise at all, but just the ability to get through a research program. Others still can be experts and unable to navigate a research program due to how capricious and political they are. So the pretense is that the Ph.D. is a marker of expertise. It's correlated with expertise, but the actual thing it signals is you've gotten through a research program.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by locknitpicker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:51AM (#49431710)
> In an ideal world, sure. In reality, a PhD[1] is about publishing papers in the hope that you learn something along the way.

You're being needlessly dismissive of what "publishing papers" mean. Writing down what you learn is what papers are for, and the only papers that count for a PhD are those which are accepted by reference journals, which impose a relatively high bar on what content they accept.

So you still need to explore uncharted areas, and your main output is still writing down what you found for others to build upon. Those are the deliverables. For the person doing the PhD, the primary benefit is developing research skills, such as independente and self-reliance.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by rfgplk on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:58AM (#49431788)
> which impose a relatively high bar on what content they accept.

Nope. In fact they accept utter garbage most of the time. I can't count the numbers of times I've caught pure errors (literal logic errors, code errors, mathematical errors) even in highly respected journals. Journals have a high bar of entry because they've gated their communities, only allowing insiders to publish (ie tenured professors, people associated/employed with university labs or their colleagues). If you don't have an industry connection the odds of you self publishing in these journals is zero. And if you _do_ find a connection, say a professor whose willing to help you out, they'll demand to place their name on your paper (without actually contributing anything). This is how you get papers with 50 authors, because every politicker wanted a piece of the pie.

This is also why you see frontier AI labs self-publishing on their websites rather than in journals.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:35AM (#49432184)
> This is also why you see frontier AI labs self-publishing on their websites rather than in journals.

What they self-publish on their own websites should be regarded as marketing.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by locknitpicker on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:15AM (#49431958)
> Nope. In fact they accept utter garbage most of the time.

Unless you enrolled in a fraudulent, make-believe University of Phoenix style program, no. Any real PhD program only counts publications in a closed allowlist of reputable journals. Those journals are peer reviewed and enforce quality and relevance standards.

> I can't count the numbers of times I've caught pure errors (literal logic errors, code errors, mathematical errors) even in highly respected journals.

That's fine and all, specially if what you actually want to do is take a shot at humble bragging, but back in the subject papers are supposed to be snapshots of your understanding of a topic that can be used by others to inspire or advance their exploration. This means they are not infallible or free from criticism. In fact, it is rather ok brand to publish papers improving upon prior publications by correcting errors, improving methodologies, and even presenting contradictory evidence. That is what it means to be at the bleeding edge.

Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by zipy124 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @04:22PM (#49470683)
The commenter is stating that respectable journals accept a lot of bad papers. This is actually very true.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders by jltsiren on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:03PM (#49442916)
You can't generalize from your personal experience to the rest of academia. There is far too much variation between fields, institutions, and countries as well as over time. ML in particular is an extreme outlier due to amount of money and business interests involved. Your experience would already have been quite different in a less fashionable subfield of CS.