Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders
by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:29AM
(#49432115)
Yes, take away all the pretense and a Ph.D. is just an apprenticeship to be a researcher.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders
by maleldil on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:26AM
(#49435787)
There's no pretense. That's always been the whole point.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders
by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:42AM
(#49436027)
That's not my experience -- there's a whole pretense about being experts in a field, which is exactly what the poster above bought into. Having a PhD doesn't make or prove you're an expert about anything. It just proves you know how to do research in a thing, but that doesn't stop us from presenting PhDs in front of juries as if they're the only ones who know what they're talking about.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders
by watwut on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:38PM
(#49438608)
Self made experts with no PhD or formal degrees are testifying in front of juries. They dont even need any science to back them.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders
by maleldil on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:56PM
(#49440513)
I don't see how these are incompatible. The PhD prepares you to be an independent researcher. The way you prove this is by studying the same topics for a few years, and by the time you reach your viva, you'd be expected to know a lot about the topic you chose.
Re:How Universities Should Prepare Founders
by ModernMech on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:59PM
(#49441264)
It's not incompatible, many people in order to do research have to gain a great expertise in a thing. Others can get a Ph.D. having really no expertise at all, but just the ability to get through a research program. Others still can be experts and unable to navigate a research program due to how capricious and political they are. So the pretense is that the Ph.D. is a marker of expertise. It's correlated with expertise, but the actual thing it signals is you've gotten through a research program.
If you plan to go to industry, your incentives are somewhat misaligned with your PI. In that case you want to pursue multiple internships and getting networked with top companies in your field, and demonstrating practical output, well-released code, demonstrated downstream value for followup projects etc.