Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners
by untog on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @04:49PM
(#4939789)
The important thing is that security must be balanced against the other things I mentioned
Which is exactly what wouldn't happen. The security theatre is persuasive to a great many people.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners
by pdonis on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @04:38PM
(#4939733)
how many items have been stolen by TSA agents from luggage
As far as I know, the amount of theft due to TSA is negligible; virtually all of it is due to airline employees.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners
by jessaustin on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @04:57PM
(#4939823)
I suggest googling for "tsa theft"; if they're firing hundreds of people a year every year it isn't a negligible problem. But even if more is stolen by airline employees than by TSA agents, that isn't a defense of the TSA. We couldn't fly without the airlines; we flew for decades without the TSA.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners
by pdonis on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @05:08PM
(#4939867)
if they're firing hundreds of people a year every year it isn't a negligible problem
From what I can see from a Google search, "hundreds" is the total number of TSA people who have ever been fired for theft, not the number per year.
Re:TSA to Commission Independent Study of X-Ray Body Scanners
by jlgreco on Tuesday December 18, 2012 @05:36PM
(#4940015)
Given the the low end of "hundreds" and the time the TSA has been in existence, that is still not negligible.
Particularly if they suck at catching/firing people as much as they do at any other sort of screening.
Really I think you could use any measure of security, even one picked out by TSA personnel, and the TSA as currently constituted would do worse than a private contractor reporting to the airlines. (Even if I'm wrong, wouldn't we want to know?) The important thing is that security must be balanced against the other things I mentioned: cost of the security program, indirect costs borne by airports and airlines, and passenger experience. From a societal perspective, we also have to weigh the costs associated with encouraging travelers to drive rather than fly.