News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by realusername on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:00AM (#49374688)
That was 100% obvious that would happen, the law will only be followed by good actors and bad actors now have an additional advantage
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by teroshan on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:12AM (#49374841)
Good news, the end goal that is being pushed by corporate lobbyists is still in sight.

Give it a few years (months if you're an optimist?) and you will have to use your Google/Apple hardware device to formally tie your real identity with your digital identity for every site that has even the slim possibility of being a small danger to hypothetical children.

I'm sure Facebook and Mark Zuckerberg will gladly join this effort to reduce harm to children as well, I'm sure that's high on their priority list. They may even already have the infrastructure in place to handle that digital ID, what an amazing coincidence.

Everything will be fine!

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by alansaber on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:17AM (#49374899)
Snooper's charter ring a bell? This is the work of the UK govt, not corporate lobbyists.
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by ivanbakel on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:24AM (#49375007)
> This is the work of the UK govt, not corporate lobbyists.

This is not an exclusive or. Corporate lobbyists from social media have a real incentive for pushing age verification and attestation. They benefit from public outcry and popular movements for age restrictions online, while also presenting age verification as the only solutions to the problems causing that outcry (which is to say, largely moderation problems on their own websites).

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by somenameforme on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:08AM (#49375727)
Age verification will be a significant loss for social media companies. It's going to push plenty of people away, and it provides no information that they don't already know to a reasonably high degree of certainty.

And I think the problems with social media for children have little to do with moderation. It's more about the typical ails that even 'good' social media would entail: FOMO, image crafting, amplification/streamlining all typical stuff that happens at all schools - bullying, rumor milling, and so on. To say nothing of the general effect of people becoming zombies to their phones rather than actually interacting in person as much.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by ivanbakel on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:55AM (#49376387)
The media buzz around the ills of social media are certainly tied to moderation, as well as other problems with the governance of those sites: people are really worried about the kind of offensive content that is easily accessible to, and recommended to, children. There is some recognition that the harmful suggestion algorithms are at fault, but the fact that such content is hosted at all is also a moderation problem.

>Age verification will be a significant loss for social media companies. It's going to push plenty of people away, and it provides no information that they don't already know to a reasonably high degree of certainty.

It may push some people away (though with the centralisation of the internet, I think this is easy to overstate), but the social media companies probably aren't that worried. Their bigger threat is actual legislation and punishment. Age-gating prevents the government from coming down on them for bad moderation, since they can just block users from accessing anything that might need to be moderated otherwise.

The possibility that age verification will actually give them more data or let them track you more easily is a nice little plus, but this is more stick than carrot.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by somenameforme on Thursday August 20, 2026 @12:06PM (#49376539)
'Harmful content' is one small aspect of it. Overwhelming majorities are concerned about addiction, bullying, mental health, academic focus, real life interactions, and so on. None of those are fixed by moderation or by any sort of regulatory constraints that can be reasonably imposed on social media.
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by teroshan on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:37AM (#49375226)
Officially I'm sure. It gets revived in the 2023 Online Safety Act and is followed by strong EU push for Identity Verification, Chat Control, etc. at the same time. I don't think it's wrong to look at them from the same lens.

It's not necessarily nefarious though: the same ideas/fears permeate all society so it makes sense they pop up together. The work may have already been done by some legislators, ready to be used by others.

But the corporate lobbying for weakening online anonymity and encryption is not something new either, and the benefits are clear. It wouldn't be the first issue large-scale lobbying has taken place in their interests, and for something as critical as identify verification I genuinely cannot imagine it isn't one of the most important issue in surveillance capitalism.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by close04 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:21AM (#49374967)
A strategy old as time. Implement a weak "foot in the door" measure that pushes people towards incompliance, use the incompliance to justify implementing the strong "break the door and your nose along with it" measure.

Companies can benefit from it but this type of control in some form or another has been the go-to for the state since forever. It just recently became feasible to do it so comprehensively otherwise they would have done it ages ago.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by formerly_proven on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:31AM (#49375124)
> Good news, the end goal that is being pushed by corporate lobbyists is still in sight.

It's less bigtech corporate lobbying and more evangelical lobbying (exodus cry etc.). This outcome plays along their plans. Create restrictions, which kill off the legal market/actors (good!) and push people into incompliance (excellent!) then push for harsher measures (see what a rampant problem illegal porn sites are). Their main goal is to go full prohibition on adult content.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by teroshan on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:41AM (#49375289)
I'm (unironically) sure it's a multi-faceted issue with a lot of actors having genuinely good motivations to push for this.

That being said I'm also sure those groups are especially vulnerable to fear-mongering [0] and it would not be particularly hard to rile up these bases to work towards the same end goal.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by forinti on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:08AM (#49374773)
Which site would you qualify as a "good" actor?

It's an honest question. Is there such a thing as ethical porn or are there only sites that pay taxes and those that don't?

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by dgellow on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:21AM (#49374976)
OnlyFan is as ethical as porn can get
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by jakkos on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:25AM (#49375014)
There are definitely more ethical porn sites, e.g. ones that will take down revenge porn vs ones that won't.
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by shakow on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:18AM (#49374922)
“Good” actor does not refer to ethical, but to lawful.

> ethical porn

Define “ethical porn”? Problem with ethics is that it varies from person to person; at least lawful has the taste of varying only from country to country.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by realusername on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:16AM (#49374891)
I'd call the ones which have a process for verifying actors and following local laws to be good actors
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by pessimizer on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:11AM (#49374821)
It's not an honest question. A good actor is one that is not trying to show porn to children and follows the law.
Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by bcjdjsndon on Thursday August 20, 2026 @11:00AM (#49375607)
> A good actor is one that is not trying to show porn to children and follows the law.

It's been happening since the 1800s non stop.... I know it's wrong to show kids porn etc but what's the actual damage it does?

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by forinti on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:14AM (#49374872)
That's one (very serious issue) but there are many others.

Pornhub is a company, has an address, pays taxes, and has a history of problems.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by pessimizer on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:46AM (#49375378)
What's a good commenter? I'm sure you eat meat and use fossil fuels.

The discussion is about actors under a regime of universal age checks, not your personal problems. If it helps, change it to be about sites that write about birth control when information about birth control has been ordered to be restricted to married males over 30, and "good actors" complying with this ends up resulting in both unmarried females and married Catholic males over 30 who don't want to identify themselves visiting sites that also contain information about full communism and Zoroastrianism, which have been decreed illegal for anyone to discuss.

Re:UK internet age checks have boosted rogue adult sites, sa... by iso1631 on Thursday August 20, 2026 @10:10AM (#49374804)
There are sites which follow laws and those that don't.