News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by croon on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:20AM (#49372673)
> Sorry to say, but this is a skill issue (and not necessarily with using Ai). I've used Ai MANY times to help SIGNIFICANTLY improve things that I've written - from a few sentences to many paragraphs. As I've said in other comments, it'll rapidly and effectively remove all my worst tendencies. And, likewise, sometimes I'll have it write a first draft when I give it appropriate context/guidance that I can't be bothered to fully curate/synthesize. Then, once it gets that draft, I'll take over and tidy it up.

Isn't this contradictory? Why do you need to take over if it's doing such a good job?

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by nchmy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:44AM (#49372839)
Let's fire all editors, consultants, psychologists, sous chefs, grunts, etc!
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by croon on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:52AM (#49372902)
I'm not claiming an LLM writes better than me.
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by nchmy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:25AM (#49373139)
No, you were claiming that no one has ever used Ai to help produce better writing. I was objecting to that, because it is an absurd statement. Ai could have told you that if you asked.
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by croon on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:10AM (#49373516)
> No, you were claiming that no one has ever used Ai to help produce better writing. I was objecting to that, because it is an absurd statement. Ai could have told you that if you asked.

Maybe take your own advice and ask your LLM if I did claim that.

This is what I claimed:

> Yes; if I could wrangle Claude into communicating exactly as I would have, the practical difference is of course not observable. But that's never happened, and I've had an enterprise license at work for years.

This means that if I get Claude/LLM output, I would need to edit it/write myself to make it correct/better/distilled into relevant parts. I do not get LLM output I would want to post as is without numerous roundtrips, at which point vi is faster.

You then reply to claim that as a skill issue, while also later on stating that you iterate over it or take over a draft to edit it, which I then point out is a contradiction.

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by ModernMech on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:48AM (#49372866)
Because it can’t do a great job without frequent expert input, that’s the point.

Expert types prompt into Claude , Claude produces fundamentally flawed but close output. Don’t take that output and give it to anyone — first refine it until it’s not flawed, then pass it on.

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by croon on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:56AM (#49372933)
Correct, I was treating their claim as true for the sake of argument, not accepting it.
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by nchmy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @07:25AM (#49373144)
We're on the same page