News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by lelanthran on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:20AM (#49372670)
> But isn't that "burden" on others always going to be there, whether you or AI wrote it? That's what communicating is...

I think your linked chat demonstrates quite well why you are wrong.

The sender's burden is a few lines of text "Write me $FOO, conclude with $BAR".

The recipients burden is an order of magnitude greater, trying to find your conclusion in hundreds of lines of text.

After all, your initial line:

> But isn't that "burden" on others always going to be there, whether you or AI wrote it? That's what communicating is...

Is concise and clearly understandable in 21 words . I understand your point even if I don't agree with it.

The linked chat has 1424 words. Your point is in there somewhere, but now you want the recipient to play "Where's Waldo" to find your point.

(BTW: I can't believe just how effectively you argued against your own point! I have never seen someone do it as effectively as this in all the time I have been reading HN)

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by nchmy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @06:30AM (#49372735)
There's so much wrong with your comment that I don't know where to start.

You say that my initial line is good, but then that you disagreed with it without saying why/making a counter argument.

As for sending anyone on a where's Waldo adventure, you've fundamentally missed the point, which was completely self-contained in my comment - the postscript link to chatgpt was just, at best, reference material for anyone who cared to look.

As for the fact that chatgpt did a terrible job of it all, that doesn't undermine my point even slightly. Because my point, made very clearly in my post, was that you can't just offload everything to AI. You have to, at the very least, give it context, direction etc. At that point, it can be quite useful. I use it effectively all the time to polish my writing, remove my worst tendencies etc.

If I cared enough, I'd have had it polish this response to make it significantly less aggressive while making the same point. But you don't deserve that, because you didn't put in even the slightest effort to communicate in good faith

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by hobom on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:36AM (#49373781)
OP's point was not that pasting AI output is great. It's rather that it depends on the quality of the output, and that it's on the sender to ensure it is good.
Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by nchmy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:15AM (#49374194)
Indeed. Further, that neither human nor AI output is inherently good or bad. The crucial factor is whether a competent, thoughtful human has been involved in one way or another - to guide, review, steer, etc...

Moreover, that a thoughtful human can know their own tendencies and limitations, and have the AI help mitigate them.

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by lelanthran on Thursday August 20, 2026 @08:41AM (#49373839)
> OP's point was not that pasting AI output is great. It's rather that it depends on the quality of the output, and that it's on the sender to ensure it is good.

And yet, he was unable to do the same (see his link). He demonstrated that he was able to more clearly articulate his point than the LLM he conversed with.

Re:Don't Paste the AI, please by nchmy on Thursday August 20, 2026 @09:14AM (#49374190)
Again, youve missed the point entirely