News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by chinathrow on Thursday August 20, 2026 @02:53AM (#49371304)
> They need to do it in a reasonable amount of time.

If they did that for years within hours and if we look at the tools available today, I would expect that "reasonable" equates to how they provided it prior: fast.

Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by grapheneos on Thursday August 20, 2026 @02:57AM (#49371323)
They did it for many years with 0 delay because they pushed the tags to AOSP. It was moved to Google Drive with a Google Forms setup to request access with manual fulfillment of the request. It was deliberately done to make it into a hassle. The delays are by design through making it a manual system regardless of how much of a delay was intended as part of this change. They could be automatically handling the requests especially from people who have already been given sources for a product. They're deliberately making it take substantially more work on their end to make it into more of a hassle.
Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by patcon on Thursday August 20, 2026 @04:15AM (#49371821)
I was involved in one of the communities involved in the Block Sidewalk efforts in Toronto Canada, which prevented Sidewalk Labs from moving forward on a multi-billion dollar project to redevelop a chunk of downtown Toronto.

I was at the Data Power 2017 conference in Ottawa where I shared with people (who would become key Block Sidewalk organizers) the clues I had, that Google was about to bid on the as-yet-unknown land development opportunity, closing later that month.

I had previously been in collaboration with secure ROM developers hitting their first adversarial efforts to thwart use of Android by competitors. I know that Google's public story of Android openness (which drove people trusting them to build a city platform) was bullshit, and I made sure many many of the key activists and public servants knew it.

While I can't know exactly how my specific actions affected things, I would guarantee that Google's adversarial positions and failed stewardship have already contributed to them losing real opportunities.

Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by Create on Thursday August 20, 2026 @04:43AM (#49372002)
...hoping a Google Gemma agent can handle those Google Forms and Google Drive for you too!
Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by chinathrow on Thursday August 20, 2026 @05:18AM (#49372249)
I understand - you said that before - I was just interpreting to what the GPL means with "reasonable time".

Maybe a lawsuit would change things?

Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by e12e on Thursday August 20, 2026 @02:44PM (#49378498)
There's no reasonable delay. The source code needs to exist before binary distribution.

When google distribute the compiled code to me, I assume the source is already available.

If distribution means I buy a phone with compiled code, I expect the sources to be readily available.

I distribution means my phone download updated software - I expect the code to be available.

Only lasts until google pushes out gpl in favour of fuchsia or something - so they can finally run away from the community code they built the android system on. Bit until then I fully expect them to actually honor the license...

Re:Google replaced Git tags for certain source code with obt... by account42 on Friday August 21, 2026 @06:49AM (#49386262)
GPL does explicitly allow for only providing source code on request. But of course that doesn't mean you can arbitrarily delay responses to such requests.