Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by Gravityloss on Monday December 17, 2012 @08:50AM
(#4932213)
Yes. This doesn't pass the smell test. I first suspected the article produces a garbled version of the research, but the abstract says the same too:
http://arxiv.org/abs/1212.3273
" In particular, for energies of one megaton or larger we find near one impact every three years for Mars, an interesting and concerning result for future Mars explorations. The corresponding calculations for our planet give a probability of one impact per 15 years"
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by debacle on Monday December 17, 2012 @09:05AM
(#4932262)
Perhaps the "1 megaton" nomer is for what encounters our atmosphere, not necessarily what impacts our surface.
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by troels on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:09AM
(#4932518)
That might be the case, but then it's not really something to be worried about, is it? I mean, then they're basically saying that astronauts on Mars will see shooting stars a bit more often than on Earth.
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by debacle on Monday December 17, 2012 @10:33AM
(#4932631)
It is, because on Mars there isn't an atmosphere there to burn up that 1 megaton asteroid into something more innocuous.
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by danielweber on Monday December 17, 2012 @11:23AM
(#4932905)
Just to be clear, Mars does have an atmosphere. It's pretty thin, but it's real enough to provide protection against micrometeorites and some of the radiation.
It ain't gonna stop a school-bus sized meteorite, though.
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by tomrod on Monday December 17, 2012 @08:58AM
(#4932240)
Doesn't pass my smell test either. I suspect perhaps there are some jiggered parameters in the model.
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by pavel_lishin on Monday December 17, 2012 @11:08AM
(#4932826)
It is now, and communication travels quickly now, but what about in the past?
Hell, we've had one in the past century (almost) - the aforementioned Tunguska event. And nobody got around to investigating it for two decades.
Today it would be big news. Last century, it was a mystery. If one had landed in the middle of Africa in 1700, would the Western world even hear about it?
Re:Mars Astronauts Likely to Witness 1 Megaton Asteroid Impacts
by vannevar on Monday December 17, 2012 @11:28PM
(#4936048)
If they're taking an average over the Earth's entire history, and the actual distribution of impacts over time is not uniform (as seems likely), that might explain the discrepancy. Though in that case it seems odd that they would use that average to predict a probability going forward.
Also for the past 50 years or so governments have been very interested in tracking large explosions so even such events occurring over water should have been detected and, I would think, mentioned in the media.