My point exactly. The amount of 'order' in the original image, compared to the distorted ones, must be detectable with a simple algorithm, right? Especially because when the slider goes through the 'correct' position, the transition changes direction, which I expect to show up different image-wide stats/parameters.
Re:Typing Free Captcha
by aaronbasssett on Monday December 17, 2012 @08:55AM
(#4932226)
It actually looks easier than this. There appears to be only 30 possible values for the slider. Send a random number between 0-29 and you have a 1 in 30 chance of being right.
In reality you can probably remove the extreme values as it is unlikely to be 0-2 or 27-29, so you have a 1 in 24 chance. Those are pretty decent odds if you compare them to a regular 6 letter CAPTCHA where a random guess would have a 1 in 26^6 chance of being correct.
It looks like it allows a bit of leeway too - you can submit two stops either side of the 'correct' value and still be allowed through. So that's a 1 in 6 (5 in 30) chance of a random guess being allowed.
This could be fixed by applying a similar blur operation to the original, but I'm pretty sure something else could be found. The only advantage (security-wise) this would have over the OCR-CAPTCHA approach is its relative novelty - should this approach become popular, many new ways to beat it would come up, and we would be in an arms-race like with standard CAPTCHAs.