News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by ElProlactin on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @06:53PM (#49279679)
> For one, the industry never did professionalize to begin with, certainly not in the way accountants, lawyers etc did.

"Professionalize" is an interesting way to frame this. As Milton Friedman argued, occupational licensure is almost always pursued by the practitioners rather than consumers. The licensing boards are mostly run by practicing lawyers and CPAs, so you have practicing lawyers and CPAs determining who can compete with them. So what you get are cartel-like bodies.

Most people don't know the histories of how these professions came to be what they are today in the US. If you take 15 minutes to read up on it, it leaves little doubt what the intentions are and how much consumers have been screwed.

> We never had any real body that could certify proficiency, which is what contributed to companies having to resort to leetcode and other such styles of interviewing.

Except that basically everyone in the industry knows that leetcode doesn't test real-world proficiency. It's equally dubious to believe that some sort of body (ostensibly run by practicing software developers) would be able to come up with a means to certify proficiency.

Incidentally, many of the outfits "looking to cash in on students looking to get a 6-figure job" placed a heavy emphasis on teaching their students how to interview, not how to be proficient.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by sgarland on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @09:39PM (#49280873)
I, for one, am extremely happy that electricians and plumbers have to be licensed.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by hattmall on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:28PM (#49281460)
Sure, but are you happy about the requirements of that licensing? Requirements that have continually expanded to require more "experience" over the years. I know in my state it was originally 1 year of experience or completion of a tech diploma and then you had to take the licensing exam. Now it is 5 years of experience and a diploma can count for one of those years. Which of course has pushed prices to insane levels.

Are you happy that the license is much less a license to do the work and much more of a license to hire unlicensed people to do all the work.

And lastly are you happy that private equity can "hire" the licensed professional to hire 100s more unlicensed people to run a huge company with a catchy slogan?

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Thursday August 13, 2026 @07:55AM (#49284643)
These are valid things to be unhappy about and should be corrected. But if the implication is 'licensing has issues so we'd be better off without' then I'm not on board. It reads like one of those 'if we can't have a 100% perfect solution, then we should do nothing' arguments. Licensing does have merits and I think currently they outweigh the drawbacks. If we can make licensing better by fixing some issues, then absolutely let's do that.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by tedd4u on Wednesday August 19, 2026 @09:46AM (#49361546)
What would you propose as an alternative? Some concerns I have are: 1) my house not burning down due to electrical fire and 2) not exploding due to natural gas leak.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by breezybottom on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @10:13PM (#49281077)
Milton Friedman was a libertarian crank. I'm a consumer and I'm quite happy that doctors and lawyers are licensed.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by ElProlactin on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:11AM (#49281719)
You can have a regime that regulates who can practice medicine and law without having it run through private organizations that function like a cartel.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by Terr_ on Thursday August 13, 2026 @02:26AM (#49282391)
It's a little more-complicated in that one of the major bottlenecks comes not from the private organizations per se, but from Congress--though I wouldn't want to underestimate the effect of lobbying.

> In the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, Congress capped the number of residency positions that Medicare would fund at each teaching hospital at 1996 levels.

https://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/5550556-residency-cap...

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by ElProlactin on Thursday August 13, 2026 @11:40AM (#49287687)
Yes, and the AMA, along with other associations, supported the cap, issuing a statement that claimed "compelling evidence that the United States is on the verge of a serious oversupply of physicians."
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by wyclif on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:12PM (#49281377)
Au contraire, mon frere. Milton Friedman looks prophetic in 2026, especially his book "Free to Choose."
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by win311fwg on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @10:22PM (#49281125)
What advantage do you, the consumer, see to licensing over certification?
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by fauchletenerum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:35PM (#49281511)
Liability for the professional that knows if they botch a job in horrendous fashion that they could lose the ability to continue practicing their profession.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by win311fwg on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:52PM (#49281613)
What's the practical difference between that and certificate revocation? Maybe you can still technically do the job, but who is going to work with you when you are not certified?

But it's not certain you would even be able to continue to do the job if you botched things in a horrendous fashion. There is precedent for individuals being barred from working in certain industries if it is considered necessary to protect the public, even when those industries are unlicensed. Granted, it is rare and a lot more complicated than where licenses are found, but if you've botched things in a horrendous fashion anything is possible.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by roenxi on Thursday August 13, 2026 @05:44AM (#49283629)
You can also buy from companies that hire licensed software engineers if you want to? The main thing that would stop people patronising licensed individuals is if there was no obvious skill gap between a licensed and unlicensed practitioner that justifies the price gap.

People don't need a government body to tell them to check for credentials. If people care they can ask (I had to give a copy of my degree certificate thingo to my employer a job or two ago, they cared that I was qualified). The whole and only point of mandating licensing is to raise prices for consumers.

EDIT

Just while I'm thinking about it, the law is expected to be easy enough for everyone to follow while simultaneously there is is an absurd legal fiction that only a licensed professional can talk sensibly about the law. It is internally inconsistent that lawyers would require a license.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by breezybottom on Thursday August 13, 2026 @09:43AM (#49285830)
That's the absurd libertarian logic. I'm supposed to be able to assess the credibility of whatever credentials I'm shown? Despite having no expertise in the field?
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by roenxi on Thursday August 13, 2026 @05:37PM (#49292178)
The government can sponsor a credential if that helps you? The libertarian position isn't that the government can't have a position on what the standard should be, just that people who think there is a more cost-effective standard should be allowed to use them.

Much like how you can hire a programmer based on that you think their work is good or they made a lot of money programming, rather than just limiting yourself to the people who went to some fancy university. If you don't feel competent at assessing programmer quality then you can exclusively hire ex-Google or MIT programmers or what have you and pay an absurd premium for the most credentialed US developers. But most people don't need to do that.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by jjmarr on Thursday August 13, 2026 @11:22AM (#49287385)
I'm getting work experience to become a licensed software engineer, which is possible in my jurisdiction (Ontario).

Rarely does anybody care. I heard it's useful for safety-critical stuff but have never met anyone who has made use of the designation.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by groundzeros2015 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:49PM (#49316727)
> Milton Friedman was a libertarian crank.

That's not an argument.

> I'm quite happy that doctors and lawyers are licensed.

But you're not happy that you have to pay for 10 years of medical or law school for a broken bone or employment contract.

The government could license a gradient of qualifications to better match skills with services. (as they reluctantly started to do in medicine due to pressure to economize MDs.)

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by joshdavham on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:57PM (#49281645)
> It's equally dubious to believe that some sort of body (ostensibly run by practicing software developers) would be able to come up with a means to certify proficiency.

I very much mostly agree with you, but I did take the Google Cloud Associate exam a year and a half ago and honestly it felt like a pretty rigorous exam. I definitely could not have passed that exam if I was incompetent in my knowledge of cloud and IT. Exams like these, I think, might become more mainstream in certifying developers in my opinion. (Though whether this is desirable is another question.)

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by ElProlactin on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:09AM (#49281714)
The question is whether you then want there to be a legal licensing requirement that requires an individual to hold certification to work as a software developer.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by dijit on Thursday August 13, 2026 @07:32AM (#49284446)
Maybe treat it like other professions and have a specific title be protected?
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by blu3pr1n7 on Thursday August 13, 2026 @08:11AM (#49284781)
Is it really possible to do that? I think if we were to go down this avenue we would need to consider titles other than software engineer.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by dijit on Thursday August 13, 2026 @09:33AM (#49285682)
yes, it's possible. That's why there's no Software "Engineers" without degrees in Quebec.
Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by blu3pr1n7 on Friday August 14, 2026 @05:54AM (#49296616)
Maybe I wasn’t clear enough. The engineering requirements to be a competent software engineer in HFT a Genomics vary wildly. If completing a computer science degree and maybe a Msc in computer science is the answer fair enough, but I don’t think those credentials are enough to label someone a competent Software Engineer.

What could be a generic framework? Do you have any reference to standards?

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by dijit on Sunday August 16, 2026 @06:10PM (#49324244)
the requirements to be a dentist are vastly different than that of a brain surgeon.

Yet, both have to have medical degrees in order to be called doctors.

That you specialise after the fact doesn't really mean what you imply, not everyone who becomes a doctor can do brain surgery.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by ElProlactin on Thursday August 13, 2026 @11:57AM (#49287922)
But in this case the title is irrelevant. The purpose of licensing is to define who is allowed to offer their services and actually practice.

If I can build you a web application as a "web developer" but not "software engineer", you haven't accomplished anything by restricting a title. It's basically certification, similar to the Project Management Professional (PMP) title, which you can only use if you've achieved PMB certification. But people without this certification can still work in project management roles.

Re:AI is removing the middle class of software engineering by sleepycat801 on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:28PM (#49294141)
Companies don't care about proficiency, the only qualities which matter are ambition, presentation, flexibility, and marketability. Customers and investors buy a good story, not a functional product.