News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Declare the Flickr API a National Historic Landmark by sausman on Saturday December 15, 2012 @07:24PM (#4926822)
> It's a win-win. We get to keep building and Yahoo can say they're the first tech company to have one of its creations declared as an official national treasure.

Typically win-win situations don't involve threatening force (government) to get one side to comply. If Yahoo wants to deprecate the Flickr API, they are doing so because it is not a win for them.

Are developers willing to pay to keep the service running? If not, why should Yahoo be forced to?

Re:Declare the Flickr API a National Historic Landmark by davewiner on Saturday December 15, 2012 @07:37PM (#4926850)
Who said anything about threatening!

What an incredible windfall to have your API declared a historic landmark. What kind of marketing opportunity would that present. Please. Even a marketing idiot could figure that one out. :-)

Re:Declare the Flickr API a National Historic Landmark by knowtheory on Saturday December 15, 2012 @08:20PM (#4926943)
Uh.

Dave, who cares if an API is a historic landmark or not? App developers certainly don't. Most devs view APIs primarily as functional objects (although yes there is an aesthetics to API design).

I think it's super weird for a government to mandate to another entity that it must maintain a piece of technology in perpetuity.

Besides, OSes aren't static anyway... Abandonware apps that depend on a static API are still going to bit-rot as new OS versions are released and fail to retain 100% backwards compatibility.

This just seems like a bad idea. I'm also still not clear on what the heart of the idea is. Is it to preserve the API itself as a work? Or is it to try and preserve the app ecosystem? Or is it to preserve a style of request?

I feel like if you really wanted to do this, the way the Internet deals with this is to come up with a common standard folks can adhere to, and then to lobby orgs to adopt that. Setting the Flickr API as a defacto standard (just for them) seems weird.

Re:Declare the Flickr API a National Historic Landmark by davewiner on Sunday December 16, 2012 @09:31AM (#4928368)
Of course that's why we should break everything -- because it seems "weird" to someone whose name is Know Theory. Right. :-)