News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by Walf on Tuesday August 11, 2026 @11:51PM (#49267648)
It's not that simple. If you were in public, going about your business, but someone followed you around perpetually, noting down everything you did, you should feel stalked and harassed. That is exactly what these machines are doing. Being in public means that you're not hiding any one part of your behaviour, but nor are you telling everyone where you've been and where you're going, etc.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by aqme28 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:24AM (#49267793)
In some places, like Germany, that reasonable expectation of privacy standard extends into public. You’re not allowed to just film strangers that have nothing to do with you. In some ways, I feel like this is a better system for our future.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:38AM (#49267857)
Regardless of their laws, Germany has plenty of CCTV style cameras outdoors just like NYC and other major cities worldwide.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by wfvr on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:16AM (#49269275)
CCTV cameras that are recording on a rolling tape that only keeps a few days of footage that is looked at by no one unless something happens can't be compared to internet connected systems that centralize all the camera feeds and uses AI to track vehicles and people.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @09:09AM (#49271861)
> CCTV… is looked at by no one unless something happens

Exactly as these new more efficient systems should be used.

> … uses AI to track vehicles and people

Why would wasting a team of people’s time manually reviewing hours of footage be preferable to a computer doing it? If an Amber Alert goes out, why would we not want to use all technology possible to locate the suspect vehicle? The argument seems to have switched to cameras are fine, just not if they are efficient.

You can set up all kinds of horror scenarios with CCTV cameras, AirTags, cell phones, gps trackers, etc. There is, without a doubt, far less excuse for AirTags to exist than cameras in public spaces when comparing benefits to potential harm.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:26AM (#49267801)
Why should I feel stalked and harassed by the cameras though? I didn’t feel bothered at all by cameras in NYC. I didn’t feel bothered in Singapore. I drove about 12 hours over the last couple of days and didn’t feel bothered by the numerous cameras along the interstate. I would certainly feel different if followed by an actual human for sure, but cameras give me no reaction honestly.

Is it the AI? If so, why does it matter if it’s AI vs paying a team to manually track your movements on these cameras? Seems hugely inefficient.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by Walf on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:36AM (#49267849)
Perhaps you'll feel differently if you, or someone you care about, happen to be one of the lucky future misidentifications.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:43AM (#49267880)
Certainly would be upset, just like if I were misidentified by a human reading the plate number? Of course, I don’t see how it’s relevant though. I would expect at least some human review at some level, for sure!

On the other hand, I have experienced a violent mugging on my street where neither my camera, nor any of my neighbors cameras, worked well enough in low light to identify the plates at all. Car pulled up, passenger jumped out and attacked two older ladies. There are plenty of cases just like this, where video evidence is lacking and would make all of the difference, that I personally feel vastly outweigh potential plate reading issues.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by Walf on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:06AM (#49268015)
I think that's conflation. Having high visibility of an area so that cameras can be consulted for evidence can be, as you attest, a good thing. Being tracked over an indeterminate length of time, profiled, and maybe one day punished for thoughtcrime, is a very different beast.

And if you think thoughtcrime is far-fetched or paranoid, you aren't paying attention. Governments around the world are moving to crush dissent by limiting gatherings for protest, labelling/charging people as terrorists without having committed any terrorist acts, etc. What makes you think anyone will ever be able to organise against oppression, even if the cause is just, when one is treated as guilty without committing any crime?

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:21AM (#49268095)
Absolutely against using any sort of law enforcement powers for those purposes. I am against thought crime and support all sorts of wide ranging freedoms. We just disagree on if the possibility for misuse outweighs very real and powerful uses.
Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by unclebucknasty on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:14AM (#49268061)
>I would certainly feel different if followed by an actual human

Why would this bother you? Because of the prospect of physical harm, or the idea that they are watching you/invading your privacy?

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:36AM (#49268174)
Mostly due to the antisocial behavior described. I would not feel at all worried if someone walking on the same sidewalk as me was recording their child with me in the frame. Someone following me and jotting down notes is very strange behavior, at least for someone like me without celebrity.

Stripping this down a bit: would I be fine with a very friendly camera crew documenting everything I do outside in public? No, I wouldn’t like that for privacy reasons. I also wouldn’t like government cameras publicly searchable, and wouldn’t like my phone location publicly searchable, but do not mind law enforcement having access when necessary. It’s a good thought experiment though, and maybe exposes hypocrisy in my view? Not entirely sure.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by King-Aaron on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:55AM (#49268316)
You are intentionally trying to argue that your feeling of personal safety outweighs the privacy violations that are being discussed. There is the classic quote, "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."

But to frame it in analogies as you are doing, it is not "a person following you". It is every person following you, at all times. A police officer, your local shop manager who is setting the prices of your groceries, your car insurer, your home insurer, your health insurer. The IRS (etc) agent assigned to you. Me, too. I'm following you, your wife, your children. You don't know me but here I am anyway taking pictures and then selling them to the user above you. Also my bank who sold me a credit card is now also following you. As well as the criminals that want to steal that credit card. Also that criminals kid, who's just curious. There's also a large man in a hat following you. As well as the person who is going to sell you your next car, they're following you too.

All these entities, and more, are following you. Carving you up as a product to sell and exploit.

And to you, you don't mind because you aren't aware. In the same way that a cow in a pen doesn't mind and isn't aware that an enormous system of industry is raising it to be carved up as a product to sell and exploit.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:58AM (#49271723)
It’s a nice dystopian fantasy but completely unrelated to cameras of public spaces in our current world. It sounds like you are more against the internet than cameras in public spaces, way better tracking data there!

There is zero liberty being given up here. There are already tons of cameras, hundreds of millions in the United States alone, recording public spaces. Banning filming in public spaces absolutely would infringe on our freedoms however, which is not something I would support.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by unclebucknasty on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @06:43AM (#49270336)
>maybe exposes hypocrisy

I don't know that hypocrisy is the word, but it does seem that you're going a long way to carve out an exception, where there is no real difference.

That is, it appears that you've simply decided one scenario is okay, even though that scenario itself begs the question. The article on which you're commenting demonstrates one reason that's so—the potential for abuse.

So, seems it all boils down to "out of sight, out of mind" in your framing. As long as you don't see the people invading your privacy, you're okay with believing that no one is. You don't mind that all of the tools of surveillance are in place, because you've defined a scenario wherein it's not possible that they're being used to actually surveil you.

In sum, your thought experiment is essentially, "would this be OK in a world that doesn't exist". But, you're answering "yes" in the world that does.

Maybe that's what you're sensing as "hypocrisy".

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:46AM (#49271557)
Potential for abuse is an issue that should be met with legal constraints, not an abandonment of video evidence. A world without Flock or competitors is still a world with hundreds of millions of cameras recording public spaces at all times. There is zero privacy in public spaces, it’s part of the name. That footage is inefficient to access, but does not require a warrant of any kind. It would not surprise me at all if the compliance rate on law enforcement asking for footage from most homes or businesses is above 90%.

I would much rather have an efficient system with strict rules around access vs an inefficient system where each investigation takes massive amounts of human time.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by unclebucknasty on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:37AM (#49274136)
>There is zero privacy in public spaces

You've agreed that this fact does not preclude uncomfortable scenarios, even for yourself. So, the discussion is about where people fall in their comfort.

I would sum up my response to the rest of your comment by noting the difference between individual citizens recording as they please, and a state-operated, always-on surveillance network, with the capacity to surveil every citizen outside of their homes.

It's worth noting here that the government famously faces stricter constitutional limits than do citizens.

The inefficiency you decry is what others value, as it protects privacy and constrains state power. There's long been a trade-off between efficiency and rights, which much of our legal system seeks to balance—as enshrined in various amendments.

Abuse of the frankly violative sort outlined in this article is but one concern, and likely cannot be properly contained in any case—particularly absent the requirement for warrants. This is precisely the reason warrants exist. We don't merely trust law enforcement to abide by its own "rules".

So, the larger point is that the very existence of state-operated surveillance networks is considered an intrusive form of abuse by many. One that uses previously unimaginable technology to circumvent the spirit of the Fourth Amendment, which consistency tells us would have otherwise explicitly protected us from such abuse.

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by veec_cas_tant on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:58PM (#49275441)
> One that uses previously unimaginable technology to circumvent the spirit of the Fourth Amendment, which consistency tells us would have otherwise explicitly protected us from such abuse

Is it the AI or the number of cameras? It can’t be cameras in general, and I struggle to believe it’s the number of cameras because we have so many cities with tens of thousands of cameras already. So it’s just that it became too efficient and instead, for any investigation, we should pay a team to spend hundreds of man hours collecting and reviewing footage that a computer could have finished immediately?

Re:New Bedford police officer accused of using Flock cameras... by unclebucknasty on Thursday August 13, 2026 @05:06AM (#49283371)
>Is it the AI or the number of cameras?

To be clear, the controversy didn't just arise with AI—it only intensified.

>we should pay a team to spend hundreds of man hours...

Some argue that none of it should be happening, so would say that it should be prohibitively expensive. But, again, the added "efficiency" makes the problem far worse. Inefficiency is the throughline of the Fourth Amendment.

You've made clear that you value efficiency. But, you've not addressed any of the actual arguments against it.