News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet porn: Automatic block rejected (UK) by DanBC on Saturday December 15, 2012 @12:17PM (#4925694)
> Here's what the filtering would mean: sexual health sites would also be blocked

You list the result of bad filtering, and suggest that a national filter would have the same problems.

While I disagree with a national filter it's easy to think it would have been better than the lousy filters already existing.

Does the existing child porn filter prevent access to innocent sites?

Re:Internet porn: Automatic block rejected (UK) by tommorris on Saturday December 15, 2012 @12:31PM (#4925725)
Yeah, but the policy wasn't to have one "national filter". It was to have the government tell ISPs "you must have a filter". How the ISPs implement it would be up to them. Which means they'd go buy the same crap that universities, libraries and corporations are currently using and implement that.

Deciding what counts as "porn" is very difficult. Deciding what is illegal child porn is, with the odd exception, pretty easy. But for legal non-child porn, well, what about a 15-year-old girl writing erotic Harry Potter shags Dracoy Malfoy fan fiction and sharing it in the fanfic community on LiveJournal or whatever. Does that count as "porn" in the same way as commercially produced videos does?

And it is trivially defeatable: one kind finds a stash of porn, puts it on USB sticks and sneakernets it to all the other teenage boys in the neighbourhood. Hell, sexting exists.

Re:Internet porn: Automatic block rejected (UK) by pavel_lishin on Saturday December 15, 2012 @01:16PM (#4925852)
Or e-mails it to them, or uses Dropbox.
Re:Internet porn: Automatic block rejected (UK) by ramblerman on Saturday December 15, 2012 @12:46PM (#4925767)
> it's easy to think it would have been better than the lousy filters already existing.

Why on earth would you assume that? It's a government imposed solution with no competition or incentive to be user friendly. If anything every politician and bureaucrat involved in the project would rather make it more restrictive to be safe than risk their own ass.