100%
You won’t get my point so I have to lay it bare: That doesn’t matter. Content counts and not the methods to create it.
Skin color of the creator is not important. Even if their ethnic background is visible through the use of one specific word a lot and slang or dialect, it doesn’t matter. Similarly it doesn’t matter whether it was made with an LLM.
Argue with the content, not the methods or risk being boring and uninteresting and generally easy to dismiss
So clearly not all sources are equal, and that applies to LLM too.
If you spend 4h of your time writing an article on something you care about it’s likely to be interesting. If the extent of the effort you are willing to put in the topic is 10 seconds of your time to ask ChatGPT to « write an article about phrack », then just don’t bother. We can all ask our own GPTs to do it for us whenever we want.
In theory someone could iterate for 4h with ChatGPT to get to the exact words they wanted to say without having written a line of it, but unfortunately for those folks, 99% of the content generated in that way will be nice sounding emptiness, and people don’t want to read 100 pieces of BS just to find 1 good one. There is too much content online and not enough time to read it all, we gotta filter somehow, and LLM sounding prose is one of the best filter available today.
That isn't cheating. That's a tool doing what tools do.
There's a certain irony in finding this much prejudice against a genuinely useful technology on a tech site, of all places. But it's your choice. Make the work harder than it needs to be, if that's what you want. Most people will use it regardless.
I should have known I was arguing with a bot all along
Maybe I am using AI to write this comment. Or maybe I only stylize some comments to sound like AI to make a point?
In any case you lose if you think it matters.
I am. It sounds like it was written by an LLM. That's synonymous with uninteresting and derivative.
BTW, likening not wanting to read LLM output to racism is possibly one of the funniest things I've ever seen on this website. Thank you.
Whether black hands typed the words or binary hands. It just doesn’t matter.
We are in year 2030, four years from now. LLM or similar architecture, produces output indistinguishable from a human. It can do this already if you are good at prompting to be honest.
So you read an article and you have no way of knowing whether it is made by an LLM or whether it is made by a human.
Do you cease to read anything released post 2026 out of sheer stubbornness/stupidity or do you keep reading articles?
Because if you keep reading then you have no way of knowing, you already have read hundreds of AI generated articles without realizing. The survivorship bias has presented you with an article that is easy to see how it was made using AI.
Now the plot twist is that it is already the 2030 for simple article generation and anyone can produce short text indistinguishable from 100% manual output. Hell it was possible a year ago no problem.
So you focusing on whether the AI was used or maybe it was generated fully using some smaller local private model probably, is quite moot. It doesn't matter. It is still a bad article.
for example, i would describe this article as grandiose, overdramatic and excessively ornate. ironically those styles show a lack of humanity.
it has vanishingly little substance. take "a poetic snapshot of a subculture forming in the shadows". this is meaningless!
it's generic, everything about the article is stating the mean belief. where is the controversy, where is the drama that would justify these massive sentences?
you can also notice that everything about an llm text has this repulsive corporate optimism, a desperation to deliver a redeeming conclusion.
so this article says, the hero meets the challenge in the journey, "We used opcode charts like musicians used sheet music. We owned the stack." oh no. we reached the bottom. but! watch out! because, we will be redeemed, "That spark is hard to find now, but it still lives in the rarest of places". how about this: no it fucking doesn't, the spark is dead, bled out and buried in a block of concrete. end of article.
i studied humanities but i hope that readers of any subject would react the same way.
I hope one day all of the people will acquire this skill.
For now we will have to do with pointless squabbles about too many em dashes and imperfect metaphors.
May I ask when you've scheduled my execution for?
Perhaps you if you weren't so wrong all the time, you wouldn't have to threaten to kill me when you lose an argument on the facts and evidence, and had nothing better to counter with than a violent death threat. That totally undermines your argument and proves you're wrong, and a psychopath.
What you gonna do anyway weirdo? You are going to cry? Piss your pants maybe?
You think I am afraid of your impotent threats? Of your passive aggressiveness on tech website you have been on for years? Touch the grass dude.
You can kiss my ass Hopkins and you sure know about it. So I advise you to do it and stfu.
Who the fuck do you think you are to threaten me? You are nothing. Take your seat.
You have no context but he replies to my every comment in unrelated threads with some schizophrenic stuff
It’s funny to mess with him a bit