News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by augment_me on Sunday August 09, 2026 @02:01AM (#49228819)
I really like the article but I feel like ignoring incentives always costs something. Only people who can afford the cost get to look principled, which turns having money into looking like having character. Everyone he praises in the article has/had a safety net: Sumner was a Harvard-educated senator with inherited standing, the writer himself still had a career after dropping his uni title.

The fish metaphor has the same issue. The people dying on the sidewalk outside his conference have seen worse than he has, they don't lack moral clarity but rather the freedom and capital to rebuild their lives around it. His essay treats seeing the fish and acting on it as a single moment when the acting part requires you to have capital/social safety net.

Re:Incentives Are for Losers by boxed on Sunday August 09, 2026 @02:17AM (#49228884)
I usually go around saying to anyone who will listen "incentives are dangerous". Like... you can't avoid them as people are sneaky bastards and will find what the incentives are even if you didn't design any on purpose, but you should be on the lookout always and be damn careful if you ever get the bad idea to introduce any.
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by hackable_sand on Sunday August 09, 2026 @03:36AM (#49229267)
I can't imagine having that kind of free time/boredom
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by boxed on Sunday August 09, 2026 @08:35AM (#49230850)
You should be saying that at your job imo.
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by antonvs on Sunday August 09, 2026 @05:03AM (#49229704)
> I usually go around saying to anyone who will listen "incentives are dangerous".

Sir, this is a Wendy’s

Re:Incentives Are for Losers by shuwix on Sunday August 09, 2026 @05:15AM (#49229765)
I think author jumps from high horse of only fortunate should survive to high horse of saving 8 billion people with magic wand.

You can't save the heroin addict with incentives. You can't feed & cure all people in Africa with incentives because then in 20 years, the problem will tripple in dimensions.

Incentives in people which enables those people to "repay the debt" to create wealth for incentives to other people works.

Incentives for handicapped enables them to live better life, and decrase burden on their relatives (which enables them to create more).

Incentives in science sectors which don't have immediate "business vector" works.

Incentives are good, if they are supplemental in degree that's necessary ... and addressed precisely. Otherwise they are waste of resources created through higher taxes (penalty for everyone).

Re:Incentives Are for Losers by dchftcs on Sunday August 09, 2026 @07:09AM (#49230364)
This is consistent with his premise. See, the title says it: incentives are for losers.

If you're already a winner you can escape from incentives. No contradiction.

Re:Incentives Are for Losers by seles on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:31AM (#49231795)
It is true that privileged people can sacrifice more to do the right thing simply because they have much more than they need to survive. But most people of all levels of privilege can do better, and it's not a competition where you are only a success if you do the most good. Good is good even in small quantities regardless of if you ever have a statue made after you.
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by augment_me on Sunday August 09, 2026 @11:59AM (#49232613)
If the article writer had this perspective it would perhaps be more rounded and grounded instead of calling people who follow the incentives losers, dummys and schmucks.
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by seles on Sunday August 09, 2026 @01:17PM (#49233367)
Agreed, it is a flaw of the article, but I think their point is still correct (that we should all stand for something beyond what is easiest for us and not use incentives as a free pass for everything).
Re:Incentives Are for Losers by rozumem on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:35AM (#49231827)
> the acting part requires you to have capital/social safety net

Not really. If you go back in history, many figures did not have the capital / social safety net to follow their principles. Diogenes comes to mind. Buddha shunned his princely life. Epicurus. The OP did not say it would be easy.

Re:Incentives Are for Losers by augment_me on Sunday August 09, 2026 @11:55AM (#49232575)
Buddha was as you say a prince, renouncing wealth is a move only available to someone who has wealth, and he could have gone back.

Epicurus owned a garden and the leisure to sit in it.

Diogenes I can kind of buy about but he still lived off a slave-owning city that had surplus to spare.

Also none of them had kids or other dependents to take care of.

Re:Incentives Are for Losers by rozumem on Sunday August 09, 2026 @12:21PM (#49232809)
We have more food surplus now than ever before. But we also have more distractions than ever before.

Buddha: he survived without a safety net, that's my point.

Having kids and dependents makes it harder, but not impossible. You may have to leave them. Again, OP never said it would be easy.