News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by fn-mote on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:54PM (#49217570)
> The problem isn't the price. No matter how much you pay, you can't take delivery of a chip that doesn't exist

I’m confused because this reads like a denial of basic economics. If the price is high enough, the chip will be produced for you.

Do you mean because of the production lead time, higher prices won’t result in increased production? Commodities like corn have been managing this for a long time… what’s special about chips?

What is your actual argument?

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by JoeAltmaier on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:59PM (#49217605)
It takes a billion dollars and years to produce a new chip fab line. So no, it cannot just be produced for you on a dime.
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by XorNot on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:51PM (#49217863)
Also supply contracts exist which is what started all this: OpenAI signed huge orders for most of the market all at once. No one had any chance to properly include that information in their pricing or bidding.
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by DannyBee on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:31PM (#49217766)
Corn is heavily subsidized,also has (in the US) federally prvided insurance programs against plunging prices, has paid uselessness(ethanol). Despite all of this corn has caused massive agriculture bankruptcy/takeover when it has failed anyway.

So it's more "what's special about corn". It is also fairly hilarious to claim the parent is denying basic economics and then bring up corn as an example of having successfully managed economics. If the scales were not being thumbed, and "basic economics" were in play, corn would be in very very bad shape.

In the case of DRAM, there is an incredibly long history of these gloom/glut cycles, and they have stayed roughly the same timeframes (~3 years) since the 1990's.

Almost all the ones who have survived this long are either in the same kind of boat as corn - protected in various forms from the downside - or don't increase production and get caught out until they are absoultely forced.

The very temporarily increased profit is not worth going bankrupt for - they make more money long term by being very cautious and know this.

There are a near infinite number of economic studies you could look at (and several sibling comments cite some) - DRAM manufactuers don't chase the price and probably couldn't anymore if they want to.

None of this denies basic economic theory, of course, since economic theory is not exactly "rigorous", even to the degree it could be (IE even the parts that are pure analysis of data rarely reproduce!).

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by SR2Z on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:27PM (#49218395)
I don't think that anything you said is wrong but I also don't think that memory consumption is going back to the old baseline... well, ever.

Memory is just too useful now that you can use it to drive cars and write code.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by crote on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:11AM (#49218836)
People are happy to play with AI when the tech companies are burning hundreds of billions of dollars to subsidize it. It remains to be seen who is actually willing to pay for it at the prices required to recoup those insane investments.

Which directly leads to the next big development: all the big players are investing in silicon with "baked-in" models, like [0,1]. Turns out you don't need an expensive general-purpose GPU with heaps of RAM to contain a model when you can make a custom ASIC around one specific model! Why spend a fortune on DRAM / HBM when all you need is some finetuning parameters which are easily stored in on-die SRAM?

[0]: https://www.theregister.com/systems/2026/08/06/amd-acquires-...

[1]: https://thenextweb.com/news/google-frozen-chip-gemini-silico...

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by re-thc on Saturday August 08, 2026 @03:27AM (#49219624)
> It remains to be seen who is actually willing to pay for it at the prices required to recoup those insane investments.

Everyone. Open models are going to keep prices down. A lot of current models are more than usable. Self-hosting would have been an option if hardware prices get back to sane values.

The insane investments have to do with insane over-valuations, VCs involved and hence media spam on it. Chinese labs for example make do with 1% of the valuation and 1% of the resources.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by pmontra on Saturday August 08, 2026 @05:57AM (#49220308)
Prices must raise a lot to make self hosting mainstream or at least fairly popular.

Yesterday a coworker posted on a customer's Slack the specs of a box he is planning to buy to run local models. It's about 5k Euro. I am paying 18 Euro per month for Claude Pro and I'm going through a migration (almost a total rewrite) of a web app from Vue 2 / Vuetify 2 / Vuex to Vue 3 / Vuetify 4 / Pinia. I never hit the 6 hours limit. I could consider running an equivalent model on a 500 Euro machine (about 2 years of Claude Pro) but 5k is 20 years and that box will be obsolete or will have failed beyond repair (no spares) much earlier than that.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by nemothekid on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:52PM (#49218500)
The problem is that is speculation and the market barriers are currently too high for losing business to be a threat. The two outcomes are (1) you overbuild, you end being wrong, you go bankrupt and lose everything or (2) you are right, but since you didn't overbuild, you lost out on some revenue, but demand still exists 3 years later and you didn't lose everything.

In any other business choosing (2) would mean someone else swoops in and steals all your business. It doesn't look like this is at all possible for memory fabs.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by leoc on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:06PM (#49218566)
Well, the Chinese manufacturers are certainly coming, though CXMT seems to be being careful not to rock the boat, at least yet https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/dram/chinese-cxmt... .
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by thelastgallon on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:26PM (#49218644)
It makes sense, CXMT takes as much profit as possible, then use that money to build more capacity, ultimately becoming one of the biggest competitor (only?) to the cartel.
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by crote on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:53PM (#49218759)
As of Q1 2026: 90% market share for the Big Three, 8% CXMT, 2% everyone else. And CXMT was only 3% Q1 2025.
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by DannyBee on Saturday August 08, 2026 @08:40AM (#49221292)
"In any other business choosing (2) would mean someone else swoops in and steals all your business. It doesn't look like this is at all possible for memory fabs."

FWIW - Lots of people seem to believe the "in any other business", but it turns out there are tons and tons of places it is equally untrue, even where there is near zero time or cost barrier to entry.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by 1718627440 on Saturday August 08, 2026 @07:53AM (#49220940)
> Memory is just too useful now that you can use it to drive cars and write code.

You can use the state of the art from 20 years ago for that.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by initramfs on Saturday August 08, 2026 @11:02AM (#49222494)
Though I am sure with enough time, someone can find a reason to need ECC.
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by SR2Z on Saturday August 08, 2026 @11:48AM (#49222941)
You can't, the bandwidth is too low (unless you mean hiring a human, in which case it's quite expensive)
Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by p1necone on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:59PM (#49217913)
The capital investment needed to bring new chip fabs online and to staff them is likely orders of magnitude higher than that needed to buy land to grow corn on. And then the ratio of investment to sell price on that land + infrastructure is probably significantly worse for chip fabs that potentially aren't needed to satisfy demand anymore a few years from now.

"If the price is high enough" is of course technically true, but the scale of what high means in this context is important.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by crote on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:51PM (#49218753)
Nontrivial markets don't behave like Economics 101 textbook examples.

Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron have a combined market share of 90% - with most of the rest being a very new-to-the-market CXMT. It is a cutthroat market which behaves like a stereotypical "pork cycle". Semiconductor fabs cost billions to build and take years to complete, so you better be damn sure you have buyers before you start constructing one. You and your competition overestimated the demand? You have to pay back the construction cost, so you're now in a race to the bottom and one of you is going bankrupt.

Ever wondered where Intel came from? They started out as a DRAM manufacturer, which dominated their revenue well after the introduction of their first microprocessors. But in the early 1980s the glut of supply from new Japanese manufacturers made it so unprofitable that they had to ditch the memory market altogether. The stories of Texas Instruments and Motorola aren't much different. And that's not even mentioning the likes of Mostek, which once held a 85% market share and was dead less than 5 years later! Oh, and those Japanese manufacturers? All gone, pivoted like Intel or died like Mostek.

So no, the three remaining DRAM manufacturers aren't going behave like headless chickens and start ordering new fabs just because there's a bubble causing a temporary demand peak. Unless those AI companies are going to pay in advance, in cash, for an entire fab, they'll just have to wait and deal with the price increase.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by vannevar on Saturday August 08, 2026 @02:08AM (#49219283)
>Commodities like corn have been managing this for a long time… what’s special about chips?

Chips aren't grown, for starters. They require very expensive facilities that take a long time to plan, build and start up. And ag firms are not seeing their stock price skyrocket based on the assumption that they will show exponential revenue growth every quarter, so there's no incentive for them to overbook their capacity and hope for the best. Maybe if the population was doubling every six months, you'd see something similar in corn. Prices in the real world are not perfectly elastic, and big deals are often locked in long before actual production.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by inigyou on Saturday August 08, 2026 @05:48AM (#49220247)
How much would you produce a RAM chip for me for? Not buy - produce.

It's a frictionless market in a vacuum right? No barriers to entry. You could make one right now if you wanted.

Re:All memory manufactured in 2027 has been sold out by 1718627440 on Saturday August 08, 2026 @07:52AM (#49220933)
> I’m confused because this reads like a denial of basic economics. If the price is high enough, the chip will be produced for you.

That's a classic stereotype of what an economic "expert" is going to say, while completely ignoring reality. Just because someone is willing to pay for it, does not mean, that goods just materialize. Sure, a lot of the time someone finds a way, but that is still limited by physical constraints: lack of expertise, lack of needed resources or as in this case simply lack of time.