I don’t like that you have empathy for people who are right this second steering the government in a project of performative cruelty against me. I think you should withhold your empathy until they’ve been stopped and appropriately punished for their misdeeds.
But I have to believe that a sizable number of people exist out there: the ones who have not carpetbagged on the ragebait economy, but who have been the ones taken down an algorithmic video-feed rabbit hole primed because of the news channel playing at their workplace or words of hatred shared by a community leader... that this person has been taught to fear rather than understand, that that person still has the innate capacity to understand, and that a future can be built on that capacity.
... yeah I'd say punishing the people can make them vote for us, or at least not vote for not-us, which is basically equivalent.
Seems to me that people who have committed crimes should be punished for those crimes. Call it "LAW AND ORDER!!!!" or something
I'm quite sure the single most popular platform someone could run on today is simply "aggressively prosecute every single crime committed by the MAGA apparatus."
If you want to contrast with a real world example, Obama won as an unknown candidate running on “hope and change” despite racial bias.
But it’s probably better to lose if presenting a positive message would make you feel icky.
However, they do agree on how they don't want it to look.
The rampant corruption, state brutality, and criminality of MAGA is unpopular across the board.
See also: claims that Sanders was “too angry” (lmao), the “Dean scream” smear campaign, characterizing Clinton as a cackling witch, etc.
For example, Harris ran on a positivity campaign and lost.
There are just way, way too many dimensions to modern politics to resolve into something like this – with the exception of the anti-MAGA sentiment which is widespread, highly salient, and highly motivating. Obviously that's fleeting and so in 16 years it will probably be wrong to say "anti-MAGA candidates always win, just look at 2028!"
(FWIW the Dems had an internal report after ‘24 that mostly agreed with me.)
The Dems' 2024 report literally argues the opposite, over and over. It argues that Democrats did not engage in enough negative campaigning against Trump.
> LESSONS FROM THE STATE CAMPAIGNS 1. Going Negative Works (Especially if Voters Know You).
> The Trump campaign and supportive Super PACs went full throttle against Vice President Harris, but there was not sufficient or similar negative firepower directed at Trump by Democrats.
> Voting is a choice. And negative messaging needs to be a part of the story as choices are framed for voters.
> The Harris campaign appears to have relied on Trump being unacceptable rather than building an affirmative case for Harris. Base voters needed reasons to vote FOR Harris as well as against Trump. Without an effective contrast with a difficult (and unaffordable) status quo, the obvious contrast with Trump was not a sufficient motivator, especially since there was not sufficient negative messaging about how horrible Trump was (and still is) for and to most Americans.
> Define lanes for communications ecosystem. Who will carry contrast and negative messaging so candidates go high as other entities go low. This was a major failing in 2024, and it cannot be repeated. Set the lanes and hold organizations accountable.
I misremembered this and a quick search to remind myself wasn’t adequate. Given the disagreement around the report, I don’t think it serves as a good source either way.
Digging a little into it, the research seems to indicate that there’s not adequate evidence to draw any conclusions: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1057/s41253-019-00084-8. Although there’s some evidence that negativity demobilizes voters and degrades democracy, which you probably don’t want. But I don’t really care who wins anyway, I’m not sure why I’m even engaging here. I guess I just want the 2008 Democratic party back.
The democrats are so far from the 2008 version that you don't care if they lose? That Trump's activities are as bad as Biden's?
2008 Dems had a large “liberaltarian” presence, which isn’t perfectly aligned with my views, but it was close enough that I was often in favor of their policies. Current Dems just want the war machine to focus more on Russia while sticking it to red states at home.
Antiwar sentiment in the party died after the entry of “CIA Democrats” like Spanberger, who now have outsized influence within the party. I don’t see much good coming out of a Dem victory until they are expelled.
Maybe I'm just some war hungry lunatic, but I actually think that when the US tells a country it will defend its sovereignty in exchange for it not having nuclear weapons, it's very important that we honor those commitments.
That's probably because I prefer deterrence, and intermittent war required to assert deterrence, more than I like the idea of every nation in a race to build nuclear weapons and then every neighbor doing scrambling to prevent nuclearization. Basically a warmonger then ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
As I said, I’m not a fan of the current party, and I hope that the right continues to degrade state capacity until neither side has much left to work with.
I don't understand what my prior comment has to do with any party at all. It was a direct response to your implicit claim about the US's obligations to Ukraine, and therefore to the rest of its security umbrella.
As to how it has to do with the party, we were discussing the Democratic Party, Russia was a brief aside. But I do find that people’s position on the Russia/Ukraine conflict typically tends to say a lot about their other positions.
Are you referring to sanctuary policies which just say a locality won't expend local resources to enforce federal immigration law?
Not sure what you could possibly be referring to here.
You're aware that actual open borders is an extremely, extremely fringe position, right? The borders between US states are "open borders." Support for open international borders is unbelievably rare, across the entire political spectrum.
I don’t really feel like rehashing the open borders motte and bailey that always happens on the internet, yes most Dems don’t support actual open borders but the policies they push for are equivalent. If there’s one thing Americans can agree on, it’s that they like having an underpaid slave caste, even if Republicans do pretend that they are against it.
Another handful of states across the red/blue gamut, but actually still red-bent, are pushing for social media restrictions.
What on earth are you talking about? Concretely what are these blue state laws that are so pervasive that you can derive the "mainstream position" from them?
Also why would Berkeley, California have any obligation or interest in enforcing border controls when those are 1) federal laws and 2) the border is 600 miles away?
Yes, red states have their own age verification laws—I never said they didn’t. Hence why I’m not friendly towards either party.
Constant nitpicking and gaslighting also seem to be typical from modern Dems.
Sheesh, that's some goofy stuff haha.
I do have a lot of faith in democracy, so I'm optimistic that most people can be persuaded to accept his punishment if the argument is presented well. I'm sure some number of people who called for him to murder people will pretend they were never on his side, and that'll frustrate me to no end, but such is life.
(The exception is right wing politicians, who seem to be allowed to win elections while openly calling for punishment of their opponents. Call it a quirk of the US electorate, or a flaw in human nature, who knows. It is what it is.)
That ship has sailed. This administration is reinforcing that it is okay, even something to be celebrated, to be doing violence to those that they dislike, for whatever reasons. It is not mere parroting of propaganda that is the concern, but the consequences thereof. There is no "sustainable and balanced future" in that.
I have had arguments on this very site where I've been told that -I- and others like me are at fault. At fault for having exhausted tolerance for people peddling things like "after-birth abortions" (Did you know that in some Democrat states you can have an abortion up to 30 days after the baby is born?!?) and similar absolute garbage. Not even "differences of opinion or perspective". I've been told endlessly, "Maybe I need to put more effort into why they think or feel that way?" That won't work, because I'll be the only one. It's never "maybe they should think about why I think that's absolutely ridiculous". There's no effort on critical reasoning or discourse that will work there, because it's not grounded in reason in the first place. And when that comes up, crickets. But no, keep going high, keep working on empathy for people who actively celebrate LE shooting people, a President that will say from the Resolute Desk in the Oval Office, quote, "My kids are insider trading all the time".
That ship has sailed. I'm not sure where it goes from here, but my fear is somewhere even uglier.
How many ‘DUI’s are acceptable? How many innocents dying will be ignored?
Enabling an addict makes you (in my opinion) just as culpable in the outcomes as they are.
What I will decidedly not accept is when people steadfastly refuse to listen to their fellow citizens' criticisms of their chosen propaganda, but instead go on the offensive attacking anyone who deviates from it - even when people are trying to engage with them using their own stated preferences regarding morals, rights, economics, etc! This is the highly toxic dynamic underlying the actual division, and is exactly what enables the negative-sum con job based around vice signalling.
American voters exist in an environment of propaganda addiction, with every piece of their personal technology reinforcing and profiting from said addiction, that has never existed before. I have great empathy and understanding for those who are bombarded by voices that are actively manipulating them for engagement, and I believe this empathy is key to understanding if, and how, a landscape of echo chambers can nonetheless result in a sustainable and balanced future.