News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:41AM (#49144028)
Yes, since we complained about them violating copyright so much, it does not violate copyright if they destroy the original, so they are now destroying the original. We got our demands met.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by lookingdesk on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:45AM (#49144063)
That's not how copyright works, at all.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:47AM (#49144088)
Yes, actually it is
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:03AM (#49144257)
Destroying your copy of a copyrighted work does not violate copyright.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:44AM (#49144655)
Format shifting is allowed. Making copies isn't. By destroying the original, it's format shifting.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:54AM (#49144733)
Right. But destroying a book even without making a copy is also allowed. It's very very common, in fact; something approaching a billion books are destroyed each year in the US.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by netsharc on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:53AM (#49144152)
I'm going to buy a Taylor Swift CD, rip it as MP3s, destroy the CD, and put the MP3s online...

Will I get sued?

Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:58AM (#49144201)
The "putting it online" part is where you are f-ing up.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by themaninthedark on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:14AM (#49144391)
But it's transformed now!

Edit(seriously): >Transformativeness is a characteristic of such derivative works that makes them transcend, or place in a new light, the underlying works on which they are based. In computer- and Internet-related works, the transformative characteristic of the later work is often that it provides the public with a benefit not previously available to it, which would otherwise remain unavailable.(Wikipedia)

I am sure Napster or the like argued that what they were doing was transformative.

Not sure how AI companies are arguing about PUBLIC benefit if you have to pay...

Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:55AM (#49144746)
It has to be sufficiently transformed. Simply scanning it doesn't qualify. The legal system by contrast is leaning toward training of AI as being sufficiently transformative.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by madaxe_again on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:49AM (#49144115)
It absolutely is. By destroying the original they retain the one copy they were licensed. It explicitly discusses that this was judged fair use in a court of law, because of the destruction of the original, as this becomes a transformation of the original work rather than a duplication.

Don’t hate the player, hate the game.

Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by themaninthedark on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:17AM (#49144417)
So what are they doing about the online data they ingested?
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by ninkendo on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:43AM (#49144640)
Copying it. Because they clearly believe that they’re allowed to do so.

For physical books, they believe they’re not allowed to, hence the destruction.

It’s abhorrent, I agree… maybe if your world domination plan involves destroying rare books, you should change the plan rather than saying “well our hands our tied, the law says we have to”

Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:49AM (#49144694)
I mean they used to have a different plan, which involved not destroying the books, and then they got sued for not destroying the books, by us, so now they are destroying the books. What did you think would happen?
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by ninkendo on Sunday August 02, 2026 @11:27AM (#49145481)
They got sued for violating copyright in general, not for “not destroying books” in particular. Destroying the books was a legal trick they used to continue scanning them without breaking the law.

If I were running the AI company and my lawyers came back with “teeeechnically we can still scan them if we burn them after”, I would reply with “I guess we’re not scanning them”, but I lack the sociopathic instincts required to be a tech CEO I guess.

Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @03:20PM (#49147448)
The sociopathy here is describing a perfectly acceptable activity as somehow evil.

You should be ashamed of yourself.

Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ... by ninkendo on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:26PM (#49149821)
Indeed, won’t someone please think of the poor AI company CEO’s, we should be ashamed of ourselves for criticizing their perfectly acceptable destruction of our creative works. Thank god you’re here to swoop in and defend them at every turn.