Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:47AM
(#49144088)
Yes, actually it is
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:03AM
(#49144257)
Destroying your copy of a copyrighted work does not violate copyright.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:44AM
(#49144655)
Format shifting is allowed. Making copies isn't. By destroying the original, it's format shifting.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:54AM
(#49144733)
Right. But destroying a book even without making a copy is also allowed. It's very very common, in fact; something approaching a billion books are destroyed each year in the US.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by netsharc on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:53AM
(#49144152)
I'm going to buy a Taylor Swift CD, rip it as MP3s, destroy the CD, and put the MP3s online...
Will I get sued?
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by pfdietz on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:58AM
(#49144201)
The "putting it online" part is where you are f-ing up.
Re:The Vanishing Page: AI Firms Scan Then Destroy Rare Book ...
by themaninthedark on Sunday August 02, 2026 @09:14AM
(#49144391)
But it's transformed now!
Edit(seriously): >Transformativeness is a characteristic of such derivative works that makes them transcend, or place in a new light, the underlying works on which they are based. In computer- and Internet-related works, the transformative characteristic of the later work is often that it provides the public with a benefit not previously available to it, which would otherwise remain unavailable.(Wikipedia)
I am sure Napster or the like argued that what they were doing was transformative.
Not sure how AI companies are arguing about PUBLIC benefit if you have to pay...