News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:15PM (#4913056)
I cannot say much about how Alex would have used funds, but I can speak to his passion for this project: I have known Alex Peake for many years (not very well, mind you), and even had a meeting with him back while he was still living in Santa Barbara (late 2007, I believe), regarding initial funding for his project.

The main thing I could tell is that this is the thing he seemed most to want to accomplish in the world (even though I wasn't certain it would work, thought he hadn't thought through the complexities, and might not have enough experience to pull it off).

In the intervening years, I have run into him at various conferences, and his interest in Code Hero has never seemed to wane: he even was making credible progress on it, and supposedly the game actually got released (although I am currently unable to find it? I'm on an iPhone, though).

I also recently ran into him at Science Hack Day last year, and I was floored at how well he was interacting with the kids there, teaching them enough JavaScript and Unity3D to make a "game" (actually, just a model and some floating platforms that you could move through; I don't even think you could land on the platforms: no collision detection).

I thereby highly question the validity of a malfeasance claim against him. I can appreciate that "he didn't spend the money well and the stated improvement project failed", but honestly: welcome to KickStarter... it is your responsibility to decide whether your money will be used effectively, as the entire point of the site is speculative funding.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by mnicole on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:28PM (#4913110)
Regardless of if he is indebted to fulfill the Kickstarter project itself, he's still required to send out the rewards. Furthermore, his lack of transparency on the issue (while continuing to give the media attention) is really what people are pissed off about. There's no excuse for that. He may very well be an incredibly passionate guy, but he's lost the trust of those who were willing to support him even if things hit the fan simply due to the lack of communication.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by waterlesscloud on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:53PM (#4913232)
I think Kickstarter would be very well served by creating higher expectations in terms of project updates.

Set a standard. Say once a month for a minimum. If you don't have something to say to your backers once a month I have to wonder if you are placing the proper priority on the project.

If projects don't meet that standard, turn their page amber or something similar. A big visual sign that the project is not meeting the standard. If it goes 3 months with no update turn it red. Make it stand out. Make people feel some pressure to communicate.

In the end, it's best for Kickstarter to push projects to better relationships with the backers.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:36PM (#4913411)
Perhaps Kickstarter needs a project liaison for projects over a certain dollar threshold; people who ask "How is it going? What are you doing?". Kiva does this for the people I lend money to (even though I lend without the expectation of the money ever coming back, I want to know how the borrow is doing regardless of the outcome).

This can be built into the cost of the Kickstarter project, and for projects $100K and above, believe it to be completely reasonable.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by DannyBee on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:42AM (#4914427)
Kickstarter doesn't want this because it can bring possible liability. They want as little to do as possible with the actual projects success or failure while still seeming to be wanting them to win :)
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by toomuchtodo on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:11AM (#4914526)
This isn't copyright law, and turning their head isn't going to remove liability (a la Craigslist sex workers debacle). Good luck arguing financial safe harbor provisions ("we're just a marketplace! It's not our place to regulate!").
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by DannyBee on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:49AM (#4916538)
Craigslist was never actually found liable that i remember, they settled.

But yes, they are basically trying to present it as a marketplace they have no control over, to avoid liability and getting themselves regulated by the SEC/others.

Whether this is going to be effective, I actually tend to agree with you and think it won't, but it's almost certainly why they are doing it.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by mnicole on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:02PM (#4913267)
Totally agree. They state multiple times in the Accountability section of their FAQ that they understand that there are roadblocks and things that come up. Also that if the project can't be completed that it's in the owner's best interest to detail how the money was spent.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by cpeterso on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:00PM (#4913529)
I think Kickstarter should require projects to "level up", proving themselves with smaller milestones with smaller funding levels. For example, a project might need to fund a $10K project before a $100K or $500K project.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by protomyth on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @09:31PM (#4913838)
That wouldn't work well for manufacturing projects where the prototype is done and they need a certain threshold amount to start building.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:36PM (#4913158)
So, if he is required to send out the rewards (even if the project failed, which it sounds like it must have, if people feel the funds were misused; to be clear, my understanding is that the Kickstarter was for a better game than the original Code Hero I said was possibly released), then Kickstarter is no longer a crowd-funded donation system for speculative investing and is a way to avoid collecting sales tax for purchases of physical goods (or custom software, such as "a special version with X", which is also often subject to sales tax).
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by mnicole on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:58PM (#4913248)
I am unsure if rewards in this sense means the project itself or just the incentives. In any case, he's fulfilled neither. Here's the text from KS:

"Is a creator legally obligated to fulfill the promises of their project?

Yes. Kickstarter's Terms of Use require creators to fulfill all rewards of their project or refund any backer whose reward they do not or cannot fulfill. We crafted these terms to create a legal requirement for creators to follow through on their projects, and to give backers a recourse if they don't. We hope that backers will consider using this provision only in cases where they feel that a creator has not made a good faith effort to complete the project and fulfill."

It also cites this image: https://ksr-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/creator-responsibility.p... which I think describes this situation pretty well.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by mikenon on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @09:43PM (#4913874)
That's listed in the FAQ [1], but not the Terms of Service [2]. Also, the project guidelines shown to people starting a new project don't mention reward fulfillment [3].

That question in the FAQ is new. It wasn't present when this project was funded [4].

Does any of this make a difference? Legally?

[1] http://www.kickstarter.com/help/faq/kickstarter%20basics#IsA...

[2] http://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use

[3] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/guidelines?utf8=%E2%9C%9...

[4] http://web.archive.org/web/20110522104147/http://www.kicksta...

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:03PM (#4913269)
Interesting! I am thereby highly confused as to how Kickstarter is legal (in addition to how it satisfies the requirements of credit card companies, which state that you cannot capture funds until you ship the product someone ordered).
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by Karunamon on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:56PM (#4913715)
For one, a pledge to a Kickstarter project is absolutely not an "order" for a product. It is an investment in a future which may or may not come to fruition. What happens if you put down $60 at the local Gamestop on a game that later gets cancelled? You get your money back, yes, but in the meantime, Gamestop gets to keep your cash.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by bigiain on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @09:38PM (#4913860)
I'm 100% with you on this.

_BUT_… It's clear from this same situation playing out every week or so, that at least some project owners and certainly Kickstarter themselves are not doing nearly enough to make that clear up front. There are clearly _many_ people who, in spite of words like "Pledge" and "project" and "funding" and "reward", still have expectations that the transaction is a sale - and they then post using language like " I 'paid' for my 'order' and my 'product' hasnt arrived!"

I love the idea of "crowdfunding", but I think it needs to be much better understood as closer to a "donation" or "speculative investment" than a "sale".

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by dragonwriter on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:31AM (#4916069)
Maybe its because the people involved are actual reading the Kickstarter terms of service -- unlike the project creators who are treating the funding like a donation -- which require the project creator to provide the promised rewards or a refund to every backer who doesn't get the reward, and, by doing so, make the transaction more like a sale than a donation or speculative investment.

The problem is with project creators who offer rewards that they aren't able to provide when the project funds, usually because they are promising rewards that include the output of the project when they are funding development rather than production.

Given KS's terms of service, creators risk substantial liability to backers when they do that; the better model would either be to offer rewards that don't depend on project success for development, or use Kickstarter to fund up-front production costs after development is complete and offer rewards that include the project output; there's no reason the same project couldn't do both, using two different Kickstarters, starting with one for development and followed -- once development is complete -- with one for production.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:30AM (#4914384)
There are two issues here, and I believe you have comingled them.

1) legality with respect to sales tax law: If Kickstarter actually requires that a good is shipped when money is given (the statement I was responding to with this comment), then this difference is barely even academic: it is just a way to do an end run around sales tax law, and I don't think it is one that most places would tolerate well (although enforcement on that sort of thing is slow and spotty).

2) terms of service on credit cards regarding pre-ordering: No, if you are giving Gamestop $60 to hold on to until a product is shipped, and you do this with a credit card, this is in violation of their agreements with companies like Visa. These requirements (obviously) flow through if you use third-party payment networks that, themselves, are based on the usage of credit cards by the end customer.

In fact, this is sufficiently true, that your example is actually wrong to begin with... Gamestop doesn't even do that, because (as I said) if they did they would be in violation. They have a page in the help section of their website where they go over this topic in specific.

http://www.gamestop.com/gs/help/Pre-orders.aspx

"""Your credit card will be charged only when your order is processed. In some cases, we will process your order and authorize your credit card up to 10 days before the release of the product. This allows us to get the product to you faster."""

In essence, they are taking your credit card number ahead of time, but they are not actually billing you; it is only when the product is actually pretty much available that they do the authorization on the card. Even then, I bet they are doing only an "authorization", and performing the "capture" when they ship: they do the authorization ahead of time to make certain there is time to deal with delays, mistakes, or simply a long queue, and then can do the capture quickly when they go to ship.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by Karunamon on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:30PM (#4916838)
>No, if you are giving Gamestop $60 to hold on to until a product is shipped, and you do this with a credit card, this is in violation of their agreements with companies like Visa.

Then these agreements are utterly meaningless. Preordering via credit card is hardly a new concept.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Thursday December 13, 2012 @05:17PM (#4918445)
Again: if you "preordered by a credit card", and were charged before the shipment (not just an authorization that your bank shows as "pending", but an honest-to-goodness capture), then you can and should report them. You will note that no large company is doing this, not even GameStop.

As another cool example: if you were lucky enough to go to Google I/O this year, they were taking "per-orders" of Google Glass; however, as they are not allowed to take money via credit cards in advance of shipment (and as you can't delay a capture for more than a month or something after the authorization), they were forced to just take name and email addresses down at the event.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by Karunamon on Thursday December 13, 2012 @07:46PM (#4918993)
Something stinks, then. I put down a preorder for Halo 4 at the local Gamestop and picked it up on launch day.

This cost me $60 about 3 months ago.

I've got the statement open, literally, right in front of me, and it shows a $60 charge from that store. I had to walk in and cough up the sales tax on launch day. I've got that charge right in front of me too.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by sliverstorm on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:08PM (#4913290)
I wouldn't be surprised if it was legal in the same way AirBnB is legal.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by Firehed on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:04PM (#4913542)
So after a period, you're required to issue a refund.

The issue is that you cannot always issue a refund after $period, where $period ranges anywhere from 60-180+ days depending on dozens of different factors (three or four different banks, your payment gateway, various data retention policies, card expiration, and more).

Unlike raising a seed round, for example, it's rather impractical to give (remaining?) money back if you realize the project is not going anywhere after six months or a year.

Suffice to say, there's a reason that Kickstarter has started to clamp down on projects with a higher likelihood of failures and is outright blocking certain categories.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by FireBeyond on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:31PM (#4913628)
Each of the pledges has an "Estimated Delivery". While those have passed, I don't think there's anyone here who doesn't understand that there can be a sometimes tenuous relationship between "estimate" and "realistic" when dealing with a "prototype".

The communication issue is, agreed, his own worst enemy.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by Heliosmaster on Thursday December 13, 2012 @04:54AM (#4915105)
Especially when most of them set really unrealistic dates. Hey, why don't we make a game, and ship it IN TWO MONTHS?

Yeah sure, I'm definitely believing that in two months (just for an example) you are going to address every problem that has arisen.

http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/11/28/the-kickstarter-s...

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by veemjeem on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:33PM (#4913144)
Maybe he's not ready to fulfill the rewards yet. I don't see that as a reason to file a lawsuit. I backed the kickstarter PID espresso machine project almost a year ago and have yet to see my reward. They reached their funding goal before this CodeHero fellow, so should we also file a lawsuit too?
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by mnicole on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:44PM (#4913193)
The t-shirts in particular could have been made, or he could have apologized and tried to save face by offering a more tangible reward to hold people over. Having the rewards solely hinge on the release of the product seems counterintuitive on Kickstarter's behalf, but it's still bad etiquette to take people's money and literally give them nothing for it, even if you can't give them what they originally wanted.

People really want to support Alex and this endeavor. They're willing to make sacrifices. They just want clarity, and I don't think that's asking too much.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by wiwillia on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:15PM (#4913318)
This is a great example of why Kickstarter should automate the production/fulfillment of these basic, common rewards. Too many organizers of Kickstarter projects list t-shirts, stickers, etc. in the rewards without even bothering to price the production out (or think about the amount of logistics required to fulfill hundreds to thousands of individual items).

Disclaimer: I work for Teespring, and pretty much all we do is automate this sort of thing (so I may be biased).

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by veemjeem on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:56PM (#4913242)
Most of the backers for the espresso machine project (http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/zpmespresso/pid-controll...) haven't received their rewards either, but we aren't up in arms ready to file a lawsuit either. I honestly don't see people making sacrifices -- the backers put in a few hundred dollars with the full knowledge that it takes a lot of work to make it happen.

Kickstarter is not a rewards preordering system. You're not giving money expecting to see your reward show up on your doorstep "soon".

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by mnicole on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:11PM (#4913305)
In creating this project, he agreed to the Terms of Use and it's within the folks' rights to request refunds at this point. http://www.kickstarter.com/help/faq/kickstarter%20basics#Acc...

I'm not a backer, just sympathetic to the situation on both sides, but an obligation is just that.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by veemjeem on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:17PM (#4913592)
He only has an obligation to refund if he decides to cancel the project. As far as we know, the project is still continuing so he has no obligation to fulfill the refunds.

In the faq you linked, here's a choice quote:

>It's not uncommon for things to take longer than expected. Sometimes the execution of the project proves more difficult than the creator had anticipated. If a creator is making a good faith effort to complete their project and is transparent about it, backers should do their best to be patient and understanding while demanding continued accountability from the creator.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by bigiain on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @09:31PM (#4913839)
"As far as we know, the project is still continuing so he has no obligation to fulfill the refunds."

While I agree with that completely, there's two different sorts of deliverables promised as rewards - the actual project output, which as you point out may only be delayed and not cancelled, but also the "trinkets". If he's really run out of money without having already paid for the tshirts and usb keys (and if it were me, probably also the "special packaging" promised for some rewards), then I think he's done something _very_ foolish.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by dragonwriter on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:40AM (#4916123)
It is incorrect to state that he is only obligated to refund if he DECIDES to cancel the project. By the terms of service, he is obligated to refund if he is either unable or unwilling to provide the rewards. Legally, unwilling loosely corresponds to deciding to cancel the project (or, at least, deciding not provide the rewards), but inability would be judged by looking at capacity, not intent.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by dbecker on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @09:13PM (#4913788)
That quote is relevant if he is still making progress on the project. But I haven't heard any evidence of that. Unless he at least announces that he's still working on it, I think it's reasonable to treat it as canceled.
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by veemjeem on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @09:53PM (#4913900)
You probably didn't see the update, but Primer Labs announced that development is still continuing: http://primerlabs.com/developmentcontinues

So backers should be patient and not threaten lawsuits because the project is taking too long.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by jacalata on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:33AM (#4914597)
Or backers should go ahead and threaten a lawsuit because that appears to be the only way to force the developer to meet the 'being transparent' requirement in the terms quoted above?
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by progrium on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:31PM (#4913125)
Alex participates in our SuperHappyDevHouse offshoot for kids called Hack the Future, and I also have to mention how passionate Alex is and how well intentioned he had to have been. I was just as impressed by his interaction with the kids, and from what I recall his activity station is usually one of the most popular.

But I definitely share the opinion the project was (and still is) more ambitious than he (or anyone) could pull off on time or on budget.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by veemjeem on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:30PM (#4913120)
I know that he'll also be present at the next Hack the Future event on January 13 where mentors get kids interested in tech. I just feel like people haven't seen an update in 2 months and are getting antsy enough to file a lawsuit, which is in bad taste honestly.

http://primerlabs.com/hackthefuture

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by jdietrich on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @10:53PM (#4914043)
His passion is at best irrelevant and at worst an indictment of his suitability as a candidate for investment.

Personally, I would have much more confidence in a totally dispassionate individual, who raised funds for a project because they saw it as a rational use of their time and other people's money, not because they had a deep emotional investment in a particular idea. I would certainly expect a dispassionate individual to make far more accurate predictions of the necessary budget and timescale of a project, and the likelihood of it failing.

Peake has no clear track record of delivering large software projects and interviews suggest that he has no clear constraints on project scope. To a developer, those are glaring warnings that a project is at risk of being vaporware, but I wouldn't expect anyone outside of the software industry to recognise that. I think Kickstarter need to think long and hard about whether they're doing everything they can to educate "backers" of the serious risks involved in certain classes of project. The lonely-hearts section in my local newspaper gives advice on how to avoid dangerous situations; The motoring section gives advice on how to spot a stolen or misrepresented vehicle. I don't see any equivalent on Kickstarter on how to spot high-risk projects.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:20AM (#4914358)
> His passion is at best irrelevant...

If you read the linked comments, people seem to believe that he got bored and dropped the project: I thereby believe that his passion is actually the specific thing in question, dead center to the discussion.

> ...and at worst an indictment of his suitability as a candidate for investment.

FWIW, I chose to not invest anything in CodeHero at the time in 2007, and when I saw the Kickstarter go by (I believe I noticed it on my Facebook feed) I again made the decision to not invest in his project.

> ...[discussion of whether or not you would invest in Alex Peake to build a project]...

Actually, I believe that that is off-topic: you would not invest in him, nor would I have invested in him, nor did I invest in him; you are preaching to the choir on not investing in him ;P. (I can, however, understand why many people would: more on that later.)

However, if you were to have invested in him (as the people complaining about him obviously did), I will contend that it is then unfair to request a refund from him if he fails: you simply shouldn't have invested in the first place if you didn't understand that risk.

To put it differently: when you buy tons of shares in a stock of a company because they say "we've decided to build the next mobile operating system and have purchased one of the leaders in this space" (HP), and then just months later they realize that the hardware didn't work, the operating system was too far out to compete with the two major players, that the deals they had were with the wrong carrier, and thereby they make the painful decision to scrap the entire division, sell off the remaining hardware at a loss, and open-source the software seemingly only to not lose face with the wider development community, you might call for the CEO's job, but I don't see how you can demand a refund: that was just a stupid investment you should not have made in the first place... some might call it a "life lesson" ;P.

Of course, sometimes it crosses a line; that line is largely related to what he does with the money: if he hires too many people, gets a bad deal on an office, and misses his window, that sucks, but he tried.

If, in contrast, he spends it on a trip to Vegas and a new car, and never had any intention of building the product, that is something entirely different, and you would be right in calling it a scam.

In this case, though, I don't see any evidence of that being the case, so I am putting forward the only thing anyone here can offer: a character reference as to what likely happened on Alex Peake's side of this. (edit: After writing this, I noticed Alex Peake actually responded himself elsewhere on the thread, so that's much more useful.)

I thereby contend, with my more-informed-than-a-random-person's (but possibly not as informed as one would really want ;P) opinion, is that he may have used the funds inefficiently on a project that was barely achievable in the first place (and it isn't even yet clear that this is true), but I can't imagine his intent was a scam.

In fact, I have a difficult time imagining Alex Peake doing much else, for the rest of his life, other than working on Code Hero (or, furthest out, things that support his addiction to working on Code Hero). He has a really addictive vision, he actually makes progress occasionally, and he really does seem to understand how to interact and deal with young kids.

Even so, I wouldn't invest money in this project (hell, were I building this project myself, I wouldn't even go about it the same way: I'd start with machines, not source code, as that's what has worked best for me when I teach classes on computers to non-computer people), but I can easily understand why someone else would... they should just have low expectations of the result; if nothing else: "it's just a Kickstarter".

> I think Kickstarter need to think long and hard about whether they're doing everything they can to educate "backers" of the serious risks involved in certain classes of project.

Yes, they should; the fact that people do not realize this, however, is, in the end, their fault. I really do agree, however, that Kickstarter is going to eventually run into serious liability problems by attempting to paint a rosy picture that looks a lot like "pre-order a product" rather than "kick a quarter to your favorite street-performer".

It was somewhat nice that they backed away from this a little in recent months (including making it clear in September with some rule changes that "Kickstarter Is Not a Store", such as requiring creators to talk about "Risks and Challenges"), but they are walking a fine line, and seem to be doing it somewhat sloppily.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by dragonwriter on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:52AM (#4916194)
Its fair to request a refund if you invested through a vehicle with terms that require either fulfillment of the offered reward or a refund.

The terms of service at Kickstarter require a refund if the project creator is unable or unwilling to provide the offered rewards, not only if he didn't really try.

Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by saurik on Thursday December 13, 2012 @05:23PM (#4918477)
I maintain that if Kickstarter is "pay money now for gifts later" then they are not in compliance with either Visa's terms of service (no delayed renumeration for payments, a policy explicitly there to avoid "I have money ten months ago, and am now angry"), as well as laws regarding collecting sales tax (which are quite clearly written in a way that keeps you from just claiming "oh yeah, this thing where people give me money and I give them products? trust me: that's not a purchase... don't tax me, bro").
Re:Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Co... by dragonwriter on Thursday December 13, 2012 @06:26PM (#4918724)
That's quite possibly true, but doesn't affect the fact that there ToS has a pay money now for stuff later model, and that people who have paid money have a legitimate expectation to get their stuff or a refund.