If we assume that people can hold about 7 +/- 2 items in short term memory, you can see why the decision process becomes mentally tiring after 3 or at most 4 items.
1. http://www.freakonomics.com/2009/12/02/is-the-paradox-of-cho...
>It is of course important to make a distinction between choice and complexity. One reason behind the smart nudge of having new employees at a company be automatically enrolled in a 401(k) plan is that the stack of paperwork and the large, complex set of options will turn some employees off from joining if left to their own devices. But asking someone who knows nothing about investing to suddenly think about asset allocation, to choose between fixed-income and equity products, between value and growth funds, etc., is a lot more complex than asking her to choose between strawberry jam and marmalade. So even if jam studies of the future prove inconclusive, it still seems wise to streamline choices whose complexity might otherwise hamper a good outcome.
http://www.americanscientist.org/issues/id.3268,y.0,no.,cont...
Base 3, on the other hand, does have a genuine mathematical distinction in its favor. By one plausible measure, it is the most efficient of all integer bases; it offers the most economical way of representing numbers.
(Culturally, I think any reduction to 2 choices calls to mind simplistic patterns of 'only 2 directions'/1-axis/1-line, or 'good'/'evil'. You expect one option to dominate. As soon as you reach 3 choices, people recognize that evaluation may require 2 or more dimensions of balancing, using curved preference functions and more thought.)
That's funny. As soon as I saw this, I knew I was going to ask about the Jam study... which after reading further was already mentioned.
Three seems to the magic number. For a project where users are presented with several options (unrelated to price) I had already made the decision to use three. But is there any objective reason three works better than say four? All I have is a gut feeling right now.