News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by ericcholis on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @12:42PM (#4911389)
I completely agree, having co-located a few projects in my day as well as using dedicated HW through Rackspace.

One of your key points is what turns some people towards more managed services: "skills to support it". I'd add time to that factor as well.

If I had the support staff, I would co-locate in a second. Heck, one of our previous locations was next-door to a Level 3 co-location facility. It was pretty nice to be able to walk 10 feet and access your hardware.

Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by jeremyjh on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @12:49PM (#4911433)
Great point about the time factor. To be clear I'm not really recommending this to a startup - in a startup your time is probably too valuable for this. For myself the work is just as enjoyable as programming so it makes sense for my side-projects. I'm on-the-fence if I would actually use it in production. But its been pretty hands-free since I initially set it up. Its a pretty small sample size for time, so far it hasn't happened but I could easily have an issue that blows out a whole weekend.
Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by rhizome on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @01:32PM (#4911682)
Relatively none of the AWS/Heroku-type startups of the type most publicized on HN is spending money hiring those skills.
Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by Xylakant on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @02:23PM (#4911930)
There's a distinction to be made between AWS and Heroku. If you're hosting on AWS you still need to have someone who's able to maintain a server. With heroku, you don't. So the advantage of AWS over Colo is mainly scalability and the reduced need for expensive hardware. Depending on your apps load behavior, spikes can require that you keep 10 times as much HW than you'd need on the average, that's where AWS really shines. But in the end, the instances you buy at AWS are virtual servers that need a real admin.
Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by rhizome on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @02:36PM (#4911990)
It's a distinction without much of a difference when most are deploying via Rubber, Vagrant, Chef/Puppet/cfengine, etc. to maintain a policy of programmer-deployers. Of course this isn't a rule, but it's prevalent.
Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by Xylakant on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @03:55PM (#4912406)
No, not true. Server maintenance is a job that requires that you track what services are deployed on a server, which ones need security updates, knowledge about how to correctly configure a firewall and lots of other stuff. Deployment via Rubber/Puppet/Chef etc. only changes how you get the needed packages and configuration on the server. It doesn't tell you magically what configuration you need on a system.

Nitpick: Vagrant is not a deployment system. It's an awesome tool, but it falls back to puppet/chef for the actual configuration.

Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by rhizome on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @04:50PM (#4912671)
I know what server maintenance is.
Re:The cloud vs. dedicated servers by Xylakant on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @05:08PM (#4912746)
Then I don't get your point. One of the major advantages of heroku over raw AWS is that you don't need to do the server maintenance - it's all done for you. And yet you say that the distinction blurs when people use puppet - which is not true.