News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by ScotterC on Tuesday July 28, 2026 @12:55PM (#49086746)
Right on. In my experience across different art fields, I’d say the only generalizable facet of ‘good’ art/music/etc is the “it sits just outside of what we expect”.

These days I liken it more to the idea of ‘surprise’ in information entropy which denotes an informative signal then to revealing any sort of objective truth.

Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by klik99 on Tuesday July 28, 2026 @01:38PM (#49087328)
You might like the book Emotion and Meaning in Music - it starts from some outdated psychological ideas (that emotions are only intensity and that we assign positive/negative valence post-hoc) but ties that to early information theory and makes a really compelling theory of music that's all about the interplay between expectation and surprise, across both the physical harmonic ratio stuff this paper talks about and the cultural associations too.
Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by ScotterC on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @09:24AM (#49168638)
Fantastic! I think you've read me right in terms of interests. I'll check it out. Thank you!
Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by rebolek on Tuesday July 28, 2026 @05:00PM (#49089837)
While I agree that "good" art "sits just outside of what we expect", I must play devil's advocate here and say that the uncanny valley of CGI/AI/... also "sits just outside of what we expect".

So there must be more to it.

Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by BoingBoomTschak on Tuesday July 28, 2026 @05:30PM (#49090184)
Eh, turning that uncanny valley to 11 can be an artform in itself: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGIvO4eh190
Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by rebolek on Tuesday July 28, 2026 @06:54PM (#49091086)
By human? I don't doubt that.
Re:Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory o... by ScotterC on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @09:26AM (#49168667)
Yes, there's certainly more to it. Just to jump on the uncanny valley vector, I'd argue that the artist having a coherent message they're trying to get across and the viewer having some affordance primed for receiving that message is critical.