It's really unfortunate that people see things this way.
Somehow, the fact that I can -- in seconds -- convert money I earned at my job into a stake in one of thousands of businesses, many of them operating in multiple countries and offering multiple product lines (and the fact that the cost of converting my dollars into this stake costs less than, well, a good steak) is incredible. It's jaw-dropping.
It's stunning that someone in Florida can live off of the profits of mines in Madagascar, fast-food restaurants in California, steel mills in South Korea, and insurance companies in Connecticut, all without spending more than half an hour a week reading brokerage statements.
It's astounding that an entrepreneur can take a business whose future profits can't be estimated to within an order of magnitude, and sell a portion of that business for a specific amount.
Finance is an incredibly valuable industry. Getting even some of this stuff slightly right creates a lot of wealth, and helps other industries create a lot more wealth. There have been excesses and there has been incompetence, but that doesn't change the fact that finance, in the aggregate, has been very beneficial.
It's also quite unfortunate that the wave of anti-banker populism seems quite lively on HN too. I thought we were better than that.
Whenever you generalise something to a large number of people, you commit some sort of anti-? ?ism. "Bankers" are not a singular entity that can have a "mentality".
- http://www.imaa-institute.org/docs/m&a/kpmg_01_Unlocking...
Yes, this is related to how well my investments do. Except that it isn't. I invest in companies that actually make things.
What I personally object to is people who confuse the word "bonus" with the word "entitlement". Bonuses should be awarded for people making things better for everyone.
But we all know the problems with measurements affecting processes. Perhaps the WSTs need to learn that lesson.
Precisely.
Spending a half hour reading machine-prepared brokerage statements isn't adding value to the process. Said investor has little knowledge of the actual operations of the mines, restaurants, mills, and insurance companies. Their gains have come from general market trends, hidden risk, and luck.
Basically, over-abstraction has encouraged investing based on market conditions rather than company fundamentals.
Actually, their gains come from providing an exit for folks who did all the things that you value.
How do you propose to let the people who do things that you like make money without letting them sell out to someone who won't do a damn thing?
I certainly don't have a problem with someone making a lot of money doing very little. However, I do think the idea that someone can "invest" without ongoing in-depth research is a scam.
The financial industry exists to make money by allocating resources to where they are most effective. If you aren't adding to market intelligence but just investing based on already-known financial data, you're essentially gambling.
Really, now, is that all it takes? Well, then, we all know what to do from here on out.
Don't get me wrong: It is also terrible that for the last two decades a lot of our best engineers have gone into finance, rather than building cool stuff, but it sure looks like that is unwinding on its own.
You also need to understand that these policies are set based on factors beyond pure economics. The various financial sector bailouts are hugely unpopular among US citizens. If ordinary people don't see bankers sharing some of the pain then we could actually see riots in the streets at some point. Look at what has already happened in some parts of Europe.
An interesting comparison about various industry contributions to the economy: the highly-debated $20 billion bailout for auto companies versus the quickly-resolved $800 billion bailout for financial companies.
> Up and down Wall Street, financial types are grumbling that their industry’s highest highflyers are getting their pay capped. Many Wall Streeters say this would be disastrous. The sharpest financial minds will up and quit, the argument goes, and take their smarts with them at the very moment they’re needed to re-engineer their companies and restart the economy.
If they're really good, and they go into industry, won't that actually be better for the economy? It's hard to see what Wall St types actually contribute to the economy.