> Computer models will only get you so far when COMPLEX (read: disguised) financial instruments rely on past history, not future performance.
Actually, their gains come from providing an exit for folks who did all the things that you value.
How do you propose to let the people who do things that you like make money without letting them sell out to someone who won't do a damn thing?
Re:Wall Street’s Brain Drain Defense
by mindslight on Sunday February 22, 2009 @09:36PM
(#491167)
erm, you quoted someone else, and aren't really addressing what I said.
I certainly don't have a problem with someone making a lot of money doing very little. However, I do think the idea that someone can "invest" without ongoing in-depth research is a scam.
The financial industry exists to make money by allocating resources to where they are most effective. If you aren't adding to market intelligence but just investing based on already-known financial data, you're essentially gambling.
No, you are putting more money into the pool --- for the people who do the data-finding to investigate and earn a share of.
Re:Wall Street’s Brain Drain Defense
by mindslight on Monday February 23, 2009 @05:27PM
(#492341)
I wasn't aware that amateur investing is done out of benevolence.
Precisely.
Spending a half hour reading machine-prepared brokerage statements isn't adding value to the process. Said investor has little knowledge of the actual operations of the mines, restaurants, mills, and insurance companies. Their gains have come from general market trends, hidden risk, and luck.
Basically, over-abstraction has encouraged investing based on market conditions rather than company fundamentals.