* Yes OpenERP is easy to extend and modify and has a good modular architecture. However, the API is badly broken, have a look at an on_change event handler on the server side [2]. Think of modifying this in your extended module!
* Extending/Configuring without code is marketing speak. It sounds and looks great for a demo, but is impractical to be used in any business. For example, you modify how a product view looks like by changing it without code and it works, then next time you upgrade the product module, you will lose all the changes. It is also a quick recipe to making your ERP a 800lbs gorilla which cannot be maintained.
* They have a long list of modules. Most of the modules are crap uploaded by OpenERP partners who implemented some specific business case for a customer of theirs and is not generic. In most failed OpenERP implementations, the primary reason is almost always these extra modules which introduce dangerous bugs. I would not blame the developers alone, because OpenERP itself lacks a culture of testing and lacks sufficient tools to test the software. Be sure to evaluate every module with real world business cases. For example, purchasing in a different currency could be a feature on the "wishlist" [3]. And BTW.. they have a module which can order " sandwiches, pizzas, prepared meals, etc." for the 2500 employees :P (i am not joking [4])
* Postgresql - it's a great database, but badly misused in Open ERP [5] (it is from the core stock module which keeps track of your inventory). I will personally not trust any software which uses "distinct" [6] in a query as important as that. It also shows how OpenERP will not scale and how Open ERP developers lack the basic knowledge of SQL (not that they know better python).
* Open ERP is far from stable. Memory leaks are pretty common and add to that poorly written python. We have been maintaining production instances for a really long time and I would not find it a stable software.
* As for AGPL - it may not be the right license for an ERP. AGPL requires you to make the source of the software available as a downloadable link to all users of the software. Would you be willing to do that for all your employees ? And moving a bit more back - they switched overnight from GPL to AGPL claiming OpenERP SA owns all the copyright. Even if we assume they really do, you have an "open source" software which has no community contributions or you have a software which has a license which stands to be sued by any previous contributor some day.
* Success Stories: There may not be many actually. I personally know several of the companies in the openerp success cases page who do not use OpenERP anymore.
* Partners/Implementors of Open ERP: Here you will find the good, bad and the ugly. There are some great implementors who understand OpenERP well but may not necessarily be the partners in the spotlight. The gold, silver and ready partnership levels are just a matter of how much money you paid Open ERP SA (the company behind openerp). Chose your implementor very carefully. If they say, it has everything you want and works just like that - they are lying to you. I recommend reading a recent article a community member has written, it's pretty detailed and in french (but google translate seems to translate it well) [7].
And finally, the recent fuss about "sorry sap". It looks more like an ambitious plan to have a negative social campaign about SAP and hope that SAP would fork out a few million dollars to acquire them. Venture capitalists who invested in OpenERP surely have an exit plan ?
[1] http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~openerp/openobject-server/trunk...
[2] http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~openerp/openobject-addons/6.1/v...
[3] https://groups.google.com/d/msg/tryton/1kOND1_kGZ8/7MCU2V699...
[4] http://v6.openerp.com/node/1278
[5] http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~openerp/openobject-addons/trunk...
[6] http://www.thedwick.com/2005/11/how-distinct-hides-bad-sql/
By any mean, any communication coming from OpenERP (and partners) must be taken with a grain of salt. It's not that it's PR stunt level but it's often not very far.
That said, there's not better OpenSource alternative.
Also, don't be lured by the OpenSource term.
Also, disclaimer: Sharoon Thomas (if that's actually him) is involved in Tryton (http://www.tryton.org/en/) which is an OpenERP fork. Better in some ways, worse in other ways.
Anyway:
* I work for Openlabs (http://openlabs.co.in)
* I am a board member of the Tryton Software Foundation (http://foundation.tryton.org/) (The entity behind Tryton a fork of Open ERP)
* But, all the above views and opinions are personal.That said, I think your remarks are that of anybody who has expertise in OpenERP and who finally feel free to criticize the software. Me an several of my ex-coworkers share the same.
Completely normal, this is one of the common risks with software projects:
".... This is a fact that companies do their best to have revenue since the first days of their creation. This implies another fact that always a proper documentation is the last thing they provide to the users....." (http://www.drdacademy.com/?id=17)
SAP suffers from the same problem too. Of course, this could be a business objective for the software producer, since, training brings in income.
Also, there is a Montreal (EST time zone!) based consultancy company called Savoir-Faire Linux that are involved in the development of OpenERP, and can help you with any implementations.
- Internal inconsistencies w.r.t formatting -- sometimes there's newlines between functions, sometimes not.
- Docstrings are fairly haphazard. I remember seeing some somewhere, but can't find them anymore. I have no idea what the `ir` module does or what it's for.
- The custom ORM (`bin/osv/`) scares the daylights out of me. It only has 4 test cases that I can see (in `test/test_osv.py`). I don't see any test cases for the DSL that the `osv` module provides.
- It appears that the ORM uses raw SQL as an intermediate for composing queries, then uses regular expressions to extract data from these intermediates.
I've only spent 10 minutes thumbing through the code, haven't read the docs or anything, so the above is a very shallow analysis.
You can get an overview of the technical "core" in the Memento: http://doc.openerp.com/memento/OpenERP_Technical_Memento_v0....
Here's what I can find:
5000+ lines of ORM code: http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~openerp/openobject-server/trunk...
300 lines of tests: http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~openerp/openobject-server/trunk...
The ORM code is fairly shocking - really hard to follow, hundred line methods/functions and multiple one and two character variables.
That said, the addons I mentioned _are_ part of the core. OpenERP is an extremely modular system, where even some basic blocks are modules. But these modules come with the server, not with the "addons" set. See https://bazaar.launchpad.net/~openerp/openobject-server/trun...
Generally, I find the code to be well-organized and easy to find (it's just a set of python modules for the most part). I can't speak to the syntax formatting or functionality of the ORM yet...