News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jivatmanx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:09AM (#4904764)
The only saving grace of the patent system has been that when a legitimate company launches a patent lawsuit, it's possible to retaliate, so there is the possibility that the tech giants would realize that futility of the war, and settle/call truces.

That doesn't work with trolls.

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by knowtheory on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:29AM (#4905195)
But that's not even the case. If you look at the way things like Intellectual Ventures (This American Life had a nice show on the subject: http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/441/w... ), the modus operandi is to sell off, or even lease off a patent to a 3rd party that operates nominally at arms length, and use that shell or shadow organization to go after people.

With that as a recourse, it'd be easy for anyone to essentially create an army of privateers out there raiding your competitors (okay maybe a navy would have been a better metaphor).

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jcromartie on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:32AM (#4904873)
I never realized that before: since the trolls don't make anything, they could never infringe. Wow.

Shouldn't there be a requirement to have an actual stake (i.e. sales lost) in order to file a lawsuit?

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jivatmanx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:42AM (#4904932)
While (AverageReward > AverageLegalCosts) { Troll.FileLawsuit() }
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by amorphid on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:48AM (#4905299)
trolls = Attorney.where(is_troll: true)

trolls.each { disbar }

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jfc on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:45AM (#4904954)
There is the legal concept of standing, in which a plaintiff has to demonstrate sufficient harm to bring a lawsuit. Don't know what the "trolls" are doing to meet this requirement.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standing_%28law%29

*Not legal advice, or any type of advice.

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by btilly on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:15AM (#4905105)
If you own a patent, and someone is infringing on your patent without paying you licensing fees that you would normally require from them, this is legally a form of theft and you have standing to sue them.

Standing is not, therefore, a problem for this kind of lawsuit.

(I am not a lawyer, nor is this legal advice.)

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by dangrossman on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:16AM (#4905112)
The harm is straightforward -- the lost patent licensing fees the infringer would have had to pay to use the patented invention. An inventor who has no money to take his invention to market licensing it to someone that does is part of how the patent system is supposed to work, so the fact that trolls also don't take their own inventions to market isn't anomalous in that regard.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jivatmanx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:44AM (#4905279)
There can't lost sales unless you were also selling the patented item.

Not even if it occurred during the lag time of you bringing it to market. (If this ever actually happened without corporate spying and intentional infringement, than the patent was clearly too obvious)

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by smsm42 on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @01:03PM (#4905758)
Lost sales aren't the only form of harm. Imagine you bought patent rights for 9000 dollars from original inventor, counting on this patent be very useful and you benefitting greatly. Now everybody uses it, but you are not paid. You are obviously harmed - you're out of $9000 and got nothing in return. Roughly the same situation as you buying a rental apartment and people living there not paying the rent (at least within the current framework of treating patents as property rights). Clearly you have a standing here.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by dangrossman on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:46AM (#4905287)
Nobody suggested there were lost sales.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jivatmanx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @12:04PM (#4905392)
Than there was no harm, because a lost sale is the only harm there could be.

(Or more accurately, the value of the patent as a % of the cost of an item sold)

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by dangrossman on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @12:22PM (#4905484)
This is the comment thread of an article about how non-practicing entities now make up the majority of patent infringement cases in court. You're asserting that every single one of them is represented by a law firm which is making up a nonexistent class of damages, and every judge who has awarded damages to a non-praticing entity in the past made a mistake in doing so.

That's not right, obviously. Title 35 of the United States Code states that "the court shall award the claimant damages adequate to compensate for the infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty for the use made of the invention by the infringer". Thus the basis of the damages is unpaid royalties for licensing the patent, not lost sales. The court may award damages for lost sales or anything else it considers "adequate to compensate for the infringement", but the ONE statutory-defined harm is the one you're saying doesn't exist.

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jivatmanx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @01:16PM (#4905822)
>(The value of the patent as a % of the cost of an item sold) = Royalty

Lost Sale if the patent constitutes the entire value of the item, theoretically possible in something like software.

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by pdwetz on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:20AM (#4904809)
I wish I had a link handy, but the massive lawsuits firing back and forth between phone tech companies (apple, google, samsung, etc.) would argue against the Mutually Assured Destruction cold war theory for patents.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jivatmanx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:24AM (#4904829)
I think that Apple/Google/Samsung each still think that they can somehow "Win" the patent war. It should eventually become blindingly obvious to all of them that they can't.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by belorn on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:32AM (#4904875)
Once rolling, there is no stop to the war until there is a winner declared by media.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by ihsw on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:53AM (#4904989)
The article states that Samsung lost a lawsuit in the US against Apple, however it fails to mention other high-profile results of Apple v. Samsung legal rulings -- namely where Apple had to publicly apologize in the UK and issue a prominently-featured statement as such on their UK website.

Other nations have ruled in favor of Apple, and vice versa, which further adds to the confusion of who is a victor.

Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by jlgreco on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @11:22AM (#4905150)
The real problem here starts when the big guys realize they are all untouchable, and start fighting proxy patent wars with each other by brutalizing small defenseless companies.
Re:US patent lawsuits now dominated by 'trolls' by mtgx on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @10:30AM (#4904861)
And even that mainly works in big corporation vs big corporation battles. If a big corporation goes after a small company, the small one can only hope to win the lawsuit, and that's if they can even afford the lawsuit. Otherwise they'll just have to pay the full asking price of the "trollish" BigCo.