Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by thruway515 on Thursday July 23, 2026 @07:50PM
(#49029623)
No it's not like any other field. There's no such thing as a 10x doctor. A '10x' doctor is just as likely to kill you as any other especially when it comes to experimental never before done procedure. In fact a 10x doctor like Qiu is more likely to take risks. This is medicine not a software shop where we measure productivity by number of commits or number of surgeries per hour except by 10x you mean 10times more likely to be careful and ethical
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by itishappy on Thursday July 23, 2026 @08:13PM
(#49029786)
Yeah, I don't mean it literally, nor do I necessarily agree with the concept of 10x engineers in general, but it's a useful shorthand. I would bet doctors vary somewhat less than other fields, but my family has been surprised and burnt by the variance still there, and I'm the only non-doctor!
On the topic of 10x surgeries per hour, the 1800s were an interesting time! This guy in particular:
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by foco_tubi on Thursday July 23, 2026 @08:15PM
(#49029800)
The point is, there are excellent doctors, good doctors, bad doctors, and awful doctors who should probably have their licensure revoked; just like engineers, or any other profession, there is a spectrum to the quality of service/talent/care.
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by eaxregister on Thursday July 23, 2026 @09:07PM
(#49030149)
Yep, this.
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by nickff on Thursday July 23, 2026 @07:53PM
(#49029646)
What exactly do you mean by "10x doctor"?
Some surgeons have a 10x higher 'revision rate' than others, and from what I understand, that may be an understatement. Many of the statistics which would indicate the ones to avoid are not tracked, precisely because the doctors do not want them tracked.
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by thruway515 on Thursday July 23, 2026 @08:14PM
(#49029793)
You'll have to ask the OP what they meant by 10x. I assume they meant it in the programmer/hacker sense of producing more work in the same amount of time than their peers or being a 'rockstar'
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by solumunus on Thursday July 23, 2026 @10:13PM
(#49030516)
Obviously they simply mean highly talented compared to their peers.
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by red-iron-pine on Friday July 24, 2026 @09:49AM
(#49035617)
doctor stats are also misleading af, since the busiest times often require the best, most reliable docs, and they also have the highest rates of fatalities
7pm-2am on friday is when all of the nasty cases come in, and the best surgeon in the world ain't gonna save many of them.
Re:Couple pay >$800k for a gene-editing therapy for their da...
by exmadscientist on Thursday July 23, 2026 @08:41PM
(#49029992)
I think there absolutely are 10x doctors! When every doctor or specialist you meet in a field says "yeah, Dr X is a massive asshole and I kind of hate him personally but if I ever need [not-particularly-rare procedure Y], I want him to be the one to do it", I think Dr X counts.