News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by pixl97 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @08:38PM (#49015413)
Because it makes the product mostly useless for all kinds of things?
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by windexh8er on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @08:53PM (#49015505)
Care to enlighten us? Because you seem to imply you want to have a conversation about your day every time you fire up a shell.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by 4b11b4 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:01PM (#49015547)
What world are you living in, I don't want to go there
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by mmooss on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @08:42PM (#49015434)
What things? Again, I don't see any but manipulation and fraud, but I certainly could be missing some.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by all2 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:02PM (#49015553)
Role play, which is a huge consumer of tokens. You can glance at openrouter's usage stats and see what apps tokens are going to and what the inference content was classified as. It's quite revealing.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by estearum on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:44PM (#49015798)
Yeah, the costs of that use case far outweigh the benefits.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by selectodude on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @10:32PM (#49016133)
Like online gambling, some things cause more harm than good.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by mmooss on Thursday July 23, 2026 @12:39AM (#49017016)
How would that regulation interfere with role play? Role play is 'play'; people know what it is.

It shouldn't interfere with immersion: People suspend disbelief in movie theaters or reading books, despite knowing it's a film or novel. The risk with AI is that people don't understand what an LLM is.

Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by ericol on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:02PM (#49015554)
I don't need a computer to mimic a human. AT ALL

As a matter of fact, for the line of work I do (programming, devops, the works) being conscious about the fact that I am just getting an algorithm outputting text that is probabilistically related to the input I gave it would actually be healthy for me and my mental state.

I HATE having to say "you" when working with an LLM.

Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:24PM (#49015686)
I have the same urge - third-person the LLM is an it, for sure, but I'm not aware of a suitable second-person construction for talking to things. Maybe we need to invent one.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by wpm on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @11:31PM (#49016582)
When yelling at the other appliances I own, "you" usually turns into "you fucker" or "you useless piece of shit", so I stick with what I know.

"Claude, you useless piece of shit, I already told you..."

Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by marcus_holmes on Thursday July 23, 2026 @03:10AM (#49017924)
Always loved the tweet: "I don't know what machine they were raging against, but I'm pretty sure it was a printer" [paraphrased]. We could definitely update that.

I'm Australian, so "oi cunt" works about as well as "you" for most things, though I'm not suggesting we adopt that formally.

Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by ericol on Thursday July 23, 2026 @10:56AM (#49022689)
ok that cracked me. Could be worth of an update:

    I don't know what machine they were raging against, but I'm pretty sure it was an LLM
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by mmooss on Thursday July 23, 2026 @12:43AM (#49017032)
Don't say 'you'?

One solution is to use commands (imperatives), as you've always done with computers. For example, instead of 'you are an expert in Lisp', say 'function as an expert in Lisp.'

Are there use cases where that isn't applicable.

Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by ericol on Friday July 24, 2026 @11:45AM (#49037369)
I don't think that works at all times; actually I think it only works when starting a conversation. In the middle, "Why ~did you~ while action as an export in Lisp <this happened>?" needs a certain level of mind gynmastics that is not worth it. I'd rather curse at it.
Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by mmooss on Saturday July 25, 2026 @01:13PM (#49049446)
I do wonder if there are circumstances where it doesn't work. But it's hard to believe I'm addressing basic syntax for computer commands on HN:

'Display the cause of the <this prior output>'.

> needs a certain level of mind gynmastics that is not worth it. I'd rather curse at it.

I guess I knew an LLM's natural language interface made it easier to use for non-technical users. But wow, it's been normalized so quickly. Now the universal old way, needed for every line of code and command line and more, is "mind gynmastics"?

Inputting curses seems just odd to me, beyond the initial novelty. It's a distraction, completely unproductive, and sending emotion into a void.

Anthropomorphisizing it seems dangerous personally and society-wide.

Re:Anthropomorphism in Children's Interactions with LLM Chat... by BrenBarn on Thursday July 23, 2026 @05:52AM (#49019121)
I'd say making LLMs useless would be a net positive for humanity.