News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by TomAnthony on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:55AM (#4899967)
I wonder if they will also go after Google which hosts everything that ThePirateBay does:

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:eAYXcZa...

If you don't use torrents, then you must understand TPB don't use 'torrent files' any more. They use 'magnet links' which are just hyperlinks with the seed info embedded, so when Google caches their pages they cache this info too.

You can initiate torrent downloads from that page exactly as you can from ThePirateBay.

Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by zanny on Monday December 10, 2012 @12:28PM (#4900317)
Tthey are effectively saying distributing a 160 bit number is effectively illegal. Magnets are just SHA1 hashes of a torrent file.

Then again, you could argue any media or program stored is just a really long many-bit number, so I guess we have been making numbers illegal for decades.

Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by jlgreco on Monday December 10, 2012 @01:13PM (#4900589)
The magnet link is basically a hash of a bunch of hashes of copyrighted content.

If distributing that is wrong, is it okay to distribute a hash of many hashes that are all each hashes of hashes of copyrighted content? (The magnet link to a list of magnet links) Suppose I merely mention the name that you can google to find the hash of many hashes of hashes of copyrighted content? I wonder how many layers do we have to add before everyone admits that the situation is absurd?

Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by lindenr on Monday December 10, 2012 @12:36PM (#4900364)
Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by sp332 on Monday December 10, 2012 @01:08PM (#4900556)
It's not clear that the proxy is being sued for copyright infringement. It might be for "aiding and abetting". After all, driving a car is not illegal, but driving a getaway car for a bank robber is. Or it might even be a civil case in which they claim damages.
Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by Dylan16807 on Monday December 10, 2012 @01:54PM (#4900828)
So reword 'number' as 'ID'. Sure, you can't get around content being content by reframing it as a number. But this number is not content. It is solely an identifier. They are trying to make it illegal to mention the ID code of files.
Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by jlgreco on Monday December 10, 2012 @12:22PM (#4900261)
You can also get a text file filled with a scrap of all the magnet links from TPB. What this effectively means is that with a single 1USD flash drive, you can "infringe" on the copyright (to the same extent that TPB does) of an absolutely unprecedented amount of content, merely by handing that flashdrive to somebody else. Millions of magnet links, at how many million dollars a pop? Insane.
Re:Music Industry Threatens to Sue UK Pirate Party over Pira... by 178 on Monday December 10, 2012 @03:18PM (#4901287)