News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by NichoPaolucci on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @07:15PM (#48999661)
As I looked through the images I was unimpressed entirely, at first. But, then I started thinking, these look a little... "childish" to me.

Childish as in... A newish artist who is drawing a concept rather than light / forms (Which is something artists typically do as they understand drawing more and more).

The rose in the vase specifically - some models understood that there was supposed to be shading, reflections, the concept of refraction - others just drew "blue = glass" and "green = stem" and "red = rose".

Really odd to look at, considering if I saw any of these drawings from a human kid, I would say "good job buddy" and put it on the fridge. I'm expecting these to get better as models improve, and perhaps the artistic progression will be there along with it...

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by ralusek on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @07:23PM (#48999731)
What's interesting is that the way in which they're childish is actually extremely human. In fact, one of the ways that you're often taught to draw more realistically is to stop thinking of the concepts as icons you're drawing the outlines of, and instead sort of blur your eyes and see things as they are: hues and values. In other words, become a camera or a printer that has no idea what it's capturing or printing other than a grid of values. That is how you achieve realism.

The fact that it has clearly iconified these concepts in its mind and is tracing the outlines of the things it thinks/expects to go where is very human.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by cj on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @08:06PM (#49000094)
Parrots can also sound extremely human, but it’s only mimicry.

How do we know the difference?

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by elcritch on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @08:31PM (#49000284)
Yes, but Parrots don't mimic the stages of learning speech development like children do. They just memorize a phrase.

These SOTA LLMs aren't trying to mimic existing children's drawings, but interestingly they're following somewhat similar progression that human children do as they develop.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by diegof79 on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @10:03PM (#49000944)
They don’t develop. We should stop anthropomorphizing LLMs.

AI labs are improving the ML techniques used to build better models; it’s a big difference.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by ETH_start on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:23AM (#49002194)
Isn't LLM training, the development?
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by ipaddr on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:44AM (#49002312)
LLMs come complete they don't train on the fly based on interaction with the world. LLMs are wikipedia if they stopped allowing edits and all of the previous edits are training.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by saidnooneever on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @04:11AM (#49003332)
there is infact RL for LLMs and its unlikely the frontier labs do not use it in some ways
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by tadfisher on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:34AM (#49002254)
The LLMs themselves are not doing the developing or learning.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by ETH_start on Monday July 27, 2026 @02:48AM (#49065928)
Can you explain what you mean by this? Aren't the LLMs developing as they're trained?
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by perching_aix on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @06:54AM (#49004717)
That's very clearly what they're referring to also, or at least I certainly doubt this would be lost on them, or most anyone here, at this point.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by diegof79 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @11:37AM (#49008513)
I imagine that it should be clear to everyone here now, until I read threads like this comparing child development to the advances in LLM building.

It’s like saying that a new M-Apple chip developed like a child. There is a clear tendency to give human like attributes to LLMs, probably caused by the terms used in ML: training, learning, etc.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by perching_aix on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @03:10PM (#49011923)
I'm not sure about that.

For me, it was the same genre of comment as e.g. comments that call out how vision models tend to be structured surprisingly similarly to how the visual cortex is structured, even without specifically attempting to make that happen, and within the boundaries of our understanding of either things of course.

So not so much anthropomorphization, and more a recognition of the unintentional biomimicry.

Though to be honest, I'll be damned if any of the pictures in the post look anything like any child drawing I've ever seen, Grok's or any of the other models.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by elcritch on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @05:25PM (#49013667)
No, it's more like you're being overly literal. As a field the technology is developing. Just like people might say "in the 60's integrated circuits developed quickly".

The parent wasn't referring to individual LLMs developing, but that overall new SOTA LLMs models are increasing in capabilities in ways similar to how human children do.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by ben_w on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @06:58AM (#49004745)
Both statements are true without contradiction.

A specific model develops as it passes through training.

AI labs change the architecture between models to allow them to surpass the previous models' best scores.

It's also going to keep being a hard sell to say "stop anthropomorphizing LLMs" when the models anthropomorphise themselves.

But besides that: Yeah, sure, they're not human, they're a cargo-cult mimicry of by and of minds that popped out of evolution doing gradient decent on intergenerational survivability. So what? Still interesting when the result of such cargo-culting incidentally echoes what our natural-selection-not-engineered moist electrochemistry happens to do.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by richk449 on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @10:12PM (#49001006)
If you want to know if something is a human or a parrot, you could give it a paint brush and ask it to paint the Mona Lisa.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by saidnooneever on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @04:12AM (#49003340)
you can also use your eyes, hands or other senses :').

reminds me of those jokes?

what is difference between a parot and a human? silence rly? u cant tell the difference between a parot and a human? :')

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @10:41PM (#49001188)
What's your parrot's take on the Jacobian Conjecture?
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by cj on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:17AM (#49006292)
My parrot doesn't have a take, but it sure can repeat one it heard on Reddit.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @12:31PM (#49009441)
So, you're saying that it was somebody on Reddit who disproved the conjecture, and not a "stochastic parrot?"
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by cj on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:44PM (#49010584)
You asked for my parrot's take, not how to disprove a conjecture.

Edit: And not a great example to use to prove human-ness considering humans didn't disprove the conjecture?

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @04:33PM (#49013035)
Parrot analogies for frontier AI are so stupid that they prove human-ness by dint of being a mistake no thinking entity would make.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by cj on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @04:52PM (#49013266)
Perhaps you can answer this for me.

Why do some people get very defensive when you suggest AI isn’t comparable to humans?

Like, where is it coming from?

Why do people seem to want to ascribe human traits on the tech? It’s just technology. Why do we need to draw parallels to biology? Is it actually helpful? My position is “no” because the parallels only seem similar, but fundamentally aren’t.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @07:45PM (#49015040)
Why do some people get very defensive when you suggest AI isn’t comparable to humans?

But you didn't do that, did you? You rattled off a goofy cliché about parrots that we've all heard a hundred times before. If that's all you have to contribute to the conversation, go contribute it somewhere else.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by NichoPaolucci on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:05PM (#49009933)
Yes - precisely what I was getting at with the childish comment.

It felt a bit surreal to see a machines rendition of something that very closely maps to a younger human as they explore + understand more about the world. Scary, even (to me). This was the first time I’ve seen LLM output and thought “wow, maybe it is learning.”

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by userbinator on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @08:29PM (#49000270)
Really odd to look at, considering if I saw any of these drawings from a human kid, I would say "good job buddy" and put it on the fridge.

The Grok ones in particular gave me that thought. Most of them really look like what a kid would do when given the same tools, while the other models' output have distinctly more "AI-ness" to them (for lack of a better term.)

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by MarcScott on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @04:59AM (#49003723)
Grok consistently draws images that, if I were its parent, I would refuse to put on the fridge door.
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by jvanderbot on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:42AM (#49006693)
I call this "symbol drawing". Beginning artists do this. They think "This is a head, a head is round. This is where eyes go, eyes are shaped like this", and the whole thing ends up being a collage of symbols vs a representation of the space and experience of viewing a face. When I used to be OK at drawing, it was because I forced myself to use touch instead of sight to compose images. So weird to explain, but I'd feel the 3d to get the lighting and such better.

A lot of art that someone smarter than me told me to appreciate seems to follow the pattern of hitting the space and/or experience while minimizing the use of symbols. Impressionistic paintings esp avoid symbols IMHO, while bizzaro picassos abuse symbols outright and still hit the experience they are going for.

Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by danesparza on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @09:50AM (#49006824)
I took the same prompts to Gemini and was stunned by the results. The are completely different from the images shown in the article (and genuinely good art pieces that were generated).
Re:"Drawing" the Mona Lisa with GPT-5.6, Claude, Gemini, and... by jstanley on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @10:13AM (#49007176)
Were you using the Gemini image generator though? The article is about using LLMs to do drawing via tool calls.