News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by Cowen on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:41AM (#4899872)
I have a bias here. I love video games and I've never truly believed they have serious detrimental effects on mental health. I'm also not an expert of psychology, but I know of at least two psychologists that are studying this and coming to the conclusion that video games have positive results.

http://www.ted.com/talks/daphne_bavelier_your_brain_on_video...

http://psych.utoronto.ca/users/spence/Research_Games.html

Anyways, I tried to approach this study as objectively as I could. But I have some gripes with their methods and more importantly, their conclusions.

> Students in the study then participated in a competitive reaction time task, which is used to measure aggression. Each student was told that he or she would compete against an unseen opponent in a 25-trial computer game in which the object was to be the first to respond to a visual cue on the computer screen.

The loser of each trial would receive a blast of unpleasant noise through headphones, and the winner would decide how loud and long the blast would be. The noise blasts were a mixture of several sounds that most people find unpleasant (such as fingernails on a chalk board, dentist drills, and sirens). In actuality, there was no opponent and the participants were told they won about half the trials.)

So this study took people playing competitive, violent video games, and then measured their aggression by giving them another competitive, violent game? After three days, they say the students were choosing to deliver harsher and harsher sounds to their "opponents." But after three days, certainly these students had also been given their fair share of harsh sounds, and at that point it's not crazy to think that they were just "playing the game."

Another method they used to measure aggression:

> They were given the beginning of a story, and then asked to list 20 things that the main character will do or say as the story unfolds. For example, in one story another driver crashes into the back of the main character’s car, causing significant damage. The researchers counted how many times the participants listed violent or aggressive actions and words that might occur.

So after they played a violent yet fake video game that they likely found to be fun, you give them a fake story and they pick violent outcomes? They were likely still in the mindset of playing the game that they found fun.

None of this conclusively shows anything about their long term aggression in the real world. It seems to be using fake scenarios (with poor timing) to try and make real-world conclusions.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by B-Con on Monday December 10, 2012 @12:33PM (#4900349)
> So after they played a violent yet fake video game that they likely found to be fun, you give them a fake story and they pick violent outcomes? They were likely still in the mindset of playing the game that they found fun.

Yeah, that just sounded like basic priming; the act of participating in something causes it and related things to be at the forefront of your mind for a little while. I'm sure they could have been primed to favor cute kitty-related outcomes if desired. That didn't sound specific to violence.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by fushi on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:47AM (#4899901)
The tests to measure violence mean nothing by themselves. It is by comparing the results that you can draw conclusions. In this case, they compared people who played violent video games with people who played non-violent games.

The study shows a difference in both cases. However, if they didn't test with people who did not play either violent or non-violent games, they lack a control group and they cannot say if violent games make you more violent or if non-violent games make you less violent.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by andybak on Monday December 10, 2012 @02:00PM (#4900870)
Precisely. I'm not sure how you could design an experiment to do so but you'd need further proof that these tests do correlate with 'aggression' (however you choose to define THAT). It wouldn't be hard to come up with alternative explanations of what those tests measured.

So they've just proved a correlation between video games and two specific tests of... something...

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by Permit on Monday December 10, 2012 @12:29PM (#4900325)
Since you've mentioned you're biased against the findings, what do you think it would take to convince you of their findings? What would they have to demonstrate for you that their conclusions were valid?
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by Finster on Monday December 10, 2012 @01:19PM (#4900622)
As a similarly biased person, I'd also like to see a real control group instead of just "violent" vs. "non-violent" games. Also, 70 people doesn't seem like a very large sample size.

If anything, this study seems purposely built to gain headlines and media attention.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by hvs on Monday December 10, 2012 @01:33PM (#4900704)
I don't disagree with you, but 70 is a pretty large study for something like this. Many drug studies use fewer people.
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by saraid216 on Monday December 10, 2012 @12:48PM (#4900441)
I would like to know what the lag time between end of play and test for aggression was, and how much of a factor it is.
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by bmuon on Monday December 10, 2012 @01:28PM (#4900675)
Those details are probably in the paper. This seems to be it: http://www.scopus.com/record/display.url?eid=2-s2.0-33947714.... It'd be nice to get access to it.
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by milliams on Tuesday December 11, 2012 @05:30AM (#4903952)
I went to download it (I work at a University so I have access) but it gave me this message:

"Java is required to run Document Download Manager and it is either not installed on your computer or out of date."

Java is installed and I'm not going to mess around trying to get their "Document Download Manager" working just to download a single PDF so screw them. Another reason to hate Elsevier.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by otakucode on Monday December 10, 2012 @02:17PM (#4900973)
It is really amazing how many psychology studies that try to address the effects of media end up making the mistake that they equate fiction and reality as the same thing. They show people violent videos, and immediately start talking about "witnessing violence" in order to convince people that the difference between real violence and violent imagery is irrelevant. In this study, they equate presenting violent concepts for inclusion in fiction as being indistinguishable from actual aggressive action.

A great deal of the social discussion surrounding violent media is poisoned by people who insist on denying that there is a difference between fiction and reality, or, more often, using words with two radically different meanings. They say something like "children have sex with hookers and then run over them, murdering them" in their description of a videogame. They are not claiming, of course, that the players physically did have sex or murder anyone, but they realy ENTIRELY upon you assigning the same negative connotations to the actions as you would to the real physical actions. If you stop and ask why murder is wrong when it involves two fictional characters, you either quickly find out that it simply isn't, or that the person speaking has no capacity to define WHY murder is wrong in the first place and so bases their entire worldview on seeing words like "murder" as a quasi-mystical totem portending danger.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by JabavuAdams on Monday December 10, 2012 @02:00PM (#4900868)
> But after three days, certainly these students had also been given their fair share of harsh sounds, and at that point it's not crazy to think that they were just "playing the game."

"In actuality, there was no opponent and the participants were told they won about half the trials.)"

I.e. no one received harsh sounds.

Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by Tipzntrix on Monday December 10, 2012 @02:21PM (#4901004)
They also said that the participant won half the trials. How could the experimenters fool the subjects about the game if they didn't get any harsh sounds back?
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by JabavuAdams on Monday December 10, 2012 @03:19PM (#4901292)
Read the study?
Re:Violent Video Games: More Playing Time Equals More Aggres... by Tipzntrix on Monday December 10, 2012 @04:36PM (#4901643)
The actual study seems to be behind a paywall. The article claims that "participants were told they won about half the trials", which I assume would be by blasting them with noise ("fingernails on a chalk board, dentist drills, and sirens"). Why would they need to explain which noise was used if they never used it (the player had no opponent)?