News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GCC 4.8 Has Automatic Return Type Deduction by pjmlp on Monday December 10, 2012 @10:55AM (#4899543)
- Games

- Systems programming

- Compiler development

- Being able to deliver an application without depending on a VM

Re:GCC 4.8 Has Automatic Return Type Deduction by lmm on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:55AM (#4899963)
- Games

Maybe. I'm currently playing lots of Kerbal Space Program, and didn't even realise it was written in C# (well, I noticed how hot it makes my laptop).

I can see for something like an FPS engine you'd want as much performance as possible, but doesn't that mean C (and increasingly CUDA and friends)? Similarly big physics number-crunching tends to be in fortran, sometimes with python to glue it together.

- Systems programming

As in kernels? Linux famously uses pure C.

- Compiler development

Does that need to be C++? I believe most if not all of the Java compiler is written in Java.

- Being able to deliver an application without depending on a VM

Why would that ever be a requirement? What's the difference between a VM and a runtime library (which even C has)?

C++ might sometimes be the best choice, but I don't think it's the only option for any of these cases.

Re:GCC 4.8 Has Automatic Return Type Deduction by pjmlp on Monday December 10, 2012 @03:52PM (#4901427)
> well, I noticed how hot it makes my laptop

That says it all

> Does that need to be C++? I believe most if not all of the Java compiler is written in Java.

Depends which compiler you mean. Oracle's is a mix of C++ and Java.

> Why would that ever be a requirement? What's the difference between a VM and a runtime library (which even C has)?

They are not several megabytes in size.

You seem to like C, fine for you.

I won't touch C again unless one of my customers requests me to.

Clang, GCC already moved to C++.

Haiku, Symbian, z/OS, Mac OS X drivers and many parts of Windows kernel are written in C++.

Re:GCC 4.8 Has Automatic Return Type Deduction by greyfade on Thursday December 13, 2012 @07:07PM (#4918874)
Haiku is written in C++ because BeOS 5 was written in C++, using the GCC-2.95 compiler. BeOS used C++ because when it was written, C++ was the new trendy OOP language. They use GCC-2.95 because the GCC 2.96 compiler was badly broken and GCC 3.x changed the ABI. The dialect of C++ supported by GCC-2.95 is based on extensions to C++98 that were rather quite buggy. It's a bit of a mess, and I would hardly hold it up as a positive example of C++ in use.

Similarly, Windows was written primarily in C, as it predated C++. Their compiler was extremely buggy and had only partial support of features in C++98, so the vast majority of the code in Windows is C with Classes. (Unless there's been a lot of rewritten code in the last 15 years or so.) Again, not exactly a positive example.