News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by inigyou on Friday July 17, 2026 @12:14PM (#48949060)
There isn't any open-source AI. There is Open AI (not to be confused with the closed company called OpenAI, which was unable to trademark its name). There's no open source AI both because the open source community doesn't have the resources to train a useful AI and because AI doesn't have source code.
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by ses1984 on Friday July 17, 2026 @12:15PM (#48949075)
Is training code and dataset not source?
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by inigyou on Friday July 17, 2026 @12:30PM (#48949244)
Are they open?
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by ses1984 on Friday July 17, 2026 @04:18PM (#48951839)
I’m just challenging your point that ai doesn’t have source.
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by Catloafdev on Friday July 17, 2026 @12:16PM (#48949085)
This is just wrong on multiple levels, the open source model ecosystem is very much a thing.
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by GuB-42 on Friday July 17, 2026 @01:05PM (#48949642)
I don't know of any useful model that would match the usual definition of "open source". That is, where everything needed to build the thing is provided, such as the training data and code. Not that it would be tremendously useful anyways considering how expensive training a model is.

I much prefer the "open weights" term. It is not open source in the sense that you only get the finished product, not the actual source, but it is still open in the sense that it is not only accessible as a service.

For an analogy, take Quake for instance. When it was launched, its game server was available as an executable, so you could run it your machine, but that didn't make it open source. Only much later it was released as true open source software.

Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by Catloafdev on Friday July 17, 2026 @02:15PM (#48950441)
There are fully open models, it's just not as common because that's basically giving away the sauce, which is non-viable for many.

eg: https://allenai.org

Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by yetanotherjosh on Friday July 17, 2026 @06:56PM (#48953094)
Olmo 3? K2 V2? There are definitely LLMs with very compelling capabilities where the dataset, training process, and final weights are all open. There are also initiatives in the EU and various national government levels (e.g. Switzerland) to develop LLMs in an open and transparent way, not just "open weights."
Re:Mozilla: The state of open source AI by yetanotherjosh on Friday July 17, 2026 @07:02PM (#48953150)
I'm not sure what kind of point you're trying to make. There are projects to train competent modern LLMs in which the entire pipeline (data, training process, final weights) is all completely transparent, shared, and reproducible by anyone with the compute to try it out.

Or is your definition of "open source" mean that a small indie dev should be able to reproduce the entire pipeline? Because that would disqualify more than just LLMs, but also hardware platforms like Arduino where you need to pay for manufacturing to get the underlying stuff built... is Arduino "open source?"