Re:Programming Languages vs. Fat Fingers
by fox91 on Sunday December 09, 2012 @07:51AM
(#4894611)
I don't see any value or meaning in this "experiment". What should it demonstrate?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Programming Languages vs. Fat Fingers
by JulianMorrison on Sunday December 09, 2012 @08:57AM
(#4894748)
Features such as automatic creation of mentioned variables and dynamic typing allow a mistake in code to change a correct program into a syntactically valid program that does the wrong thing.
Re:Programming Languages vs. Fat Fingers
by fox91 on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @05:19AM
(#4909438)
It doesn't mean that if you write C you get less bugs. IMHO that's a not meaningful experitment that makes no sense in practice
Now show that this is a significant cause of costly errors in practice...
I know my evidence is just anecdotal, but I see it a lot. Man, do I miss my C++ and my Haskell when I have to use Python and javascript at work.
Most people seem to disagree with that happening "a lot", so maybe I'm working with bad codebases or just being unlucky. Indeed, a controlled study would yield more reliable information.
It is a comparison of several programming languages regarding how likely it is that a typo causes the program to still compile and run but produce wrong output. If a typo goes unnoticed you would really want the parser to notice or at least an obvious behaviour at runtime (e.g. a crash) instead of the code silently working and producing the wrong results.
Re:Programming Languages vs. Fat Fingers
by ExpiredLink on Sunday December 09, 2012 @09:48AM
(#4894858)
>> I think that the most significant outcome of our study is the demonstration of the potential of comparative language fuzz testing for evaluating programming language designs.
> What should it demonstrate
E.g. Java is better than Haskell.