Re:Computation as a Universal and Fundamental Concept
by Robotbeat on Saturday July 11, 2026 @09:57AM
(#48872122)
The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle and the Laws of Thermodynamics are pretty d*mn fundamental.
Re:Computation as a Universal and Fundamental Concept
by pegasus on Sunday July 12, 2026 @01:29AM
(#48878561)
The Church-Turing thesis (the fact that all models of computation we've been able to come up with are equivalent) gives the necessary weight to that claim.
Re:Computation as a Universal and Fundamental Concept
by Diogenesian on Sunday July 12, 2026 @10:43AM
(#48881576)
The Church-Turing thesis is a statement about symoblic processes, and symbolism is simply not fundamental to the universe. It is fundamental to how humans understand the universe. That's the distinction.
But “computation is a fundamental aspect of the universe”, in the way it's being understood in this thread (as opposed to the article) does not remain within any of those frameworks. It makes a claim about reality as a whole.
Once you make that kind of universal claim, all the assumptions built into “computation” - about identity, distinct states, lawful transitions, causation, logic, etc. - become part of the claim. You cannot use those assumptions silently and then present the conclusion as framework-independent.
And those frameworks come with consequences. Using the language of computation, they come with "lossiness" wrt modelling "reality".
(see Aristotle Metaphysics -> Kant CoPR -> later Wittgenstein)