I wonder why nobody has tried to optimize for actual code size or complexity metric, or at least why I haven’t seen more benchmarks that display this. GPT5.5 just keeps pushing more and more pointless indirection into every function it writes in my main project, it’s borderline negative productivity.
P.S. I’d be curious to see Cursor’s composer models in there, they seem to be among the best performing low cost models: https://artificialanalysis.ai/articles/cursor-composer-2-5-c...
For my usage, I would very much prefer if those $/task were being spent in thinking and experimenting, and the actual output would be as short and maintainable as possible. “maintainability” is a vague target of course, but it’s at least somewhat correlated with code size.
I have not broken down the comment/code ratio, but that's actually a really interesting idea for a metric.
I would also like to test Cursor, but our policy is to only test models available on public routers for now.
Agentic coding data: https://gertlabs.com/rankings?mode=agentic_coding
Fable's main advantage is that its average solution size is smaller. However, GPT 5.6 Sol is a substantial improvement from GPT 5.4/5.5 which would write verbose, defensive code. 31KB for GPT 5.4/5.5 down to 26KB for GPT 5.6 Sol, with better performance for Sol.
Fable scores slightly lower, but with an average solution size of 12.2 KB.
Data at https://gertlabs.com/rankings?mode=oneshot_coding