Not to be too snide, but if that's your reductionist view of the work of software development, I'm not surprised you're comfortable vibecoding without a human in the loop.
it’s a shame we automated that instead of the boring system design shit.
The other side considers shipping as a feature.
I can both sympathize and empathize with this conflict.
You mean typing the actual code into the editor is the fun part for you? For me, the fun part has always been "cause computer to do novel things", and actually typing/compiling/debugging the code is just a speed bump on the way to something fun.
the act of typing is trivial and second nature, like breathing. but going e2e from brain to keyboard to editor to working product..that’s the thrill. and it’s dead.
See also debates between high/low level languages.
You might as well say “real men/women only write Asm”.
It seems my definition of "vibe coding" was wrong after all, at least in this case, and that you're still doing design. My initial read was that this was fully AI-powered, and while that sounded interesting, it did leave me wondering what the humans did :)
I also responded below re: Vibe coding.
I think I missed where you posted what business you work at
- Yes, yes that's right.
- Well then I just have to ask why can't the customers take them directly to the vibe coding software people?
- Well, I'll tell you why... because... engineers are not good at dealing with customers...
- So you physically take the specs from the customer?
- Well... No. My secretary does that... or they're faxed.
- So then you must physically bring them to the software people?
- Well... No. ah sometimes.
- What would you say you do here?
- Look I already told you, I deal with the @#$% customers so the prompt engineers don't have to. I have people skills! I am good at dealing with people, can't you understand that? WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE?!
Tools are always made out to seem like the human could be replaced. We've seen that every time some new technology comes out that some people claim will replace humans once and for all! But this does not seem to be true.
What AI coding allows us to do is get rid of just 1 or 2 parts of the job: coding and debugging. The rest of our knowledge based job is still there. AI just speeds things up because I can now ask it to code something while I go help plan or design something with a colleague. Most of us at this workplace also have a very good eye for UI design and system design patterns, so when we prompt/query the AI, we can understand what is happening. That isn't a replacement, that's more like getting a team of engineers who can do different things all in service of a larger goal.
Our conclusion was that we should not be concerned what search or queuing algorithm or data structure is being used. And to be perfectly honest, and I know that this will rub some in the wrong way, a lot of development since the 90s have been around object and graph management. For the 1000th time, I just do not (and most engineers I work with) care how an object is serialized and deserialized. Just display it on a table for me, why are we spending weeks coding a list, adapter, transformer, JSON/XML/whatever, networking calls, networking nuances, etc. etc. when I just want to get our customers seeing that list and move on?
I don't know if I did a good job covering the nuance, AMA!