News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Invalidate this startup idea - 500 dollar prototype by Mz on Wednesday December 05, 2012 @08:58PM (#4879840)
He asked to be invalidated. I was giving him the feedback he requested. I am someone who routinely either gets useless pats on the head or hatred from people. I can't fucking get anyone to engage me in meaty discussion of the issues. And that fact is helping to ensure that my thingamawhop will be stillborn or miscarried entirely.

Perhaps he doesn't appreciate being given what he asked for. Perhaps like everyone else on planet earth, he will not take my feedback seriously and will merely be defensive like it is a personal attack and not a well meaning, honest critique. And, gee, that's on him what he does with it. But he did ask for people to try to poke holes in his idea, presumably on the theory that it would help him uncover weaknesses and thereby improve the darn thing. But maybe it was just pc bs, like most of the blather on the face of the planet.

Re:Invalidate this startup idea - 500 dollar prototype by padseeker on Wednesday December 05, 2012 @09:06PM (#4879863)
If you think it is invalid that is a perfectly acceptable response. You made a point and I countered. No need to get hostile Mz. I'm just glad you took the time to respond. You're feedback is appreciated, even if the answer is "your idea isn't worth building".

I want to hear what your thingamawop is - please share. Maybe this is the start of doitfor500, and you get the first version for free. Or at least we put you on the right path if you do it yourself. I'm really curious now what it is.

Re:Invalidate this startup idea - 500 dollar prototype by Mz on Wednesday December 05, 2012 @09:16PM (#4879905)
You seem to have missed my point entirely. I gave you the feedback you requested. That doesn't mean "it isn't worth building". That means I respect you enough to help you try to find the weaknesses before you build the damn thing, in hopes that it will hurt less should you actually launch. And if you can't come to terms with that, life will get really painful when you do go public with it.

My thingamawhop: I nearly died just about twelve years ago. Then I was diagnosed with "atypical cystic fibrosis". I have spent the last twelvish years getting well when the entire world thinks that is impossible. I would like to write a simulation -- aka "game" -- to more effectively share my mental model. But it might never happen. I get accused of having Munchhausen Syndrome rather than cf. Most people with cf have made it abundantly clear that they would rather die a slow torturous death than speak to me at all. And I have been lovingly called a "troll" by the good people of hn for trying to get feedback to resolve my problems.

Sorry if I am a tad raw over the whole thing. This kind of bullshit has gone on for years. It likely won't end. Ever.

Best of luck with your idea.

Re:Invalidate this startup idea - 500 dollar prototype by bradleysmith on Saturday December 08, 2012 @10:54AM (#4891827)
Well, I would hate to be accused of handing out pats on the head.

I was compelled by padseeker's idea, and honestly my similarity to your non-techie, want-to-learn-to-build position. I just wanted to point out that want-to-learn or not, it's on you to post a project to a public forum like that.

I appreciate your comment, just another POV.

Re:Invalidate this startup idea - 500 dollar prototype by Mz on Saturday December 08, 2012 @02:09PM (#4892384)
No hard feelings. In the interest of not digging my grave deeper, I will leave it at that.
Re:Invalidate this startup idea - 500 dollar prototype by bradleysmith on Saturday December 08, 2012 @10:09PM (#4893631)
None taken. I'm just thankful for the term 'thingamawhop'.