News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:31PM (#487791)
Why was it wrong ?

He shouldn't have been able to do it anyway. Compare it to a kid kicking against a fence and finding out that it swings open.

Simply explain that if you have no business in a system that you should not try to gain access, that should be plenty.

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:46PM (#487812)
Up/down up/down, if you disagree say so.

Do you take offense at my suggestion this kid did nothing wrong ? Why is that ? Enlighten me, for all I have read above the sysadmin is the person in the wrong, if a 13 year old can walk all over your system you ought to be looking for a job (and one that does not include system administration).

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by kajecounterhack on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:50PM (#487824)
He didn't do any major damage

What do you mean he didn't do anything wrong? If all he did was find a way into their systems and report his findings of insecurity or something, certainly there would be nothing wrong with that (as long as he's following his terms of use for the school computers, also -- he's held to the rules of the school as a student). But it appears as if he's done something, maybe he didn't report what he discovered, that is indeed wrong.

And I agree, the sysadmin must be pretty incompetent, but that is still no reason to be doing that. It's like saying "the lock on this safe is weak and easily broken, so I will go ahead and break it to access the contents inside." It's still a safe, you're still not supposed to break it. If you do, you should immediately recommend to the owner that they get a stronger lock.

He's a typical (in a sense) 13 year old. This hardly warrants punishment. But he should indeed put his talents to better use, and that's what the author of this thread is asking. What would we recommend?

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:54PM (#487832)
If the kid was properly instructed beforehand on what was acceptable and what was not then you have a point, but the story does not relate that, hence my question.

I'm assuming that this kid is just as curious as any other kid at that age, and the systems should be set up accordingly.

This is trying to close the gate after the horse has bolted, ok, so he looked, big deal. Now catch up on the educational bit about privacy and minding your own business, case closed.

No need to make an issue out of it. The overreaction in these cases does more damage than the event itself.

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @04:53PM (#487921)
addendum: the last thing you should do these days if you accidentally walk in to someones system is alert them to that fact, in schools it's a surefire way to get in to a lot of trouble, even if your intentions are noble.
Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by bmj on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:52PM (#487828)
So does this mean that if I accidentally forget to lock my front door that it is legal for you to walk around inside my house?
Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:57PM (#487837)
That argument has been beaten to death so many times it really loses it's shine.

So, no that does not make it legal.

BUT We're talking about a kid that is according to the OP 13 years old, at that age you are not considered to be able to make these judgement calls.

Forbidden fruit and all that...

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by bmj on Thursday February 19, 2009 @04:21PM (#487880)
But it strikes me in your original comment, you do state that what he did was wrong.

Certainly, I don't advocate anything more than the OP does. This strikes me as one of those "teachable moments" that will help the kid make these sorts of judgment calls in the future.

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @04:29PM (#487889)
Hm, ok I see what you mean. Let me try to rephrase what I meant: He did something that could have been considered wrong, had he been in the possession of enough common sense to figure that out by himself. As it was I think he probably just thought it was an exciting puzzle to figure out, which in and of itself is not wrong.

It's up to the adults to help kids make the right judgement calls, so in this case I see it as failed parenting / eduction, not a failure on the part of the kid.

Fully agree with you on the 'teachable moment' thing, opportunities like that come by too little anyway.

The fact that an extended family member is asking about this on a public message board already makes me worried this has gotten way too big in comparison to the infraction.

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by bmj on Thursday February 19, 2009 @04:34PM (#487895)
I concur with your last point.

As far as failed parenting...hmmm...I wouldn't go that far. Kids will make poor choices, no matter how great the parenting. I think we need to abstain from judging that without more details.

Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by jacquesm on Thursday February 19, 2009 @04:35PM (#487899)
true enough, I take that back.
Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by xenophanes on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:48PM (#487819)
You defended a child against an adult. Of course some people will irrationally downmod you. Don't worry about it.