News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by hoytschermerhrn on Sunday June 21, 2026 @11:41PM (#48625374)
I’m a US citizen and absolutely will not be uploading additional information just to use a company’s models. This effectively kills my usage of anthropic for anything beyond their 4.8 models.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:37AM (#48625723)
> I’m a US citizen and absolutely will not be uploading additional information just to use a company’s models.

I can't speak to your specific use of Anthropic's models, but I find it interesting that people will identify themselves (to set up and pay for an account) and provide all sorts of personal (and often sensitive if not confidential) information to these models on a daily basis, but balk at a 5-minute identity verification.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by -Fu on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:22AM (#48626007)
It’s not the five minutes that I balk at, it’s entrusting a third party with all they need to steal my identity. But of course, they’ll never get hacked…
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by mcv on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:15AM (#48626816)
And to me, it's specifically that that third party is Peter Thiel. Not the guy I want to trust with my data.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:31AM (#48626070)
It's not like Anthropic is the only company in the world that would have the basic details contained on a driver's license or passport. Odds are all of the PII required for someone to steal your identity is already in criminal hands.

The National Public Data breach alone exposed the social security numbers of potentially upwards of 100 million Americans. Numerous companies have literally "all" of your personal data and you never did business with them/gave it to them directly.

It's not right but the identity theft cat is out of the bag, which is why precautions like credit freezes, are recommended for all Americans.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by lobocinza on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:39PM (#48632526)
But they have all other data as well and this concentration is dangerous.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by joxdosba on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:25AM (#48626891)
How can someone steal your identity? What does that even mean?
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by interloxia on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:47AM (#48627054)
Where possible, I believe it's our duty to educate those who know or care little about how their devices work. Unfortunately stats aren't persuasive for my family, but they might be for some as a starting point.

https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/victims-identity-th...

Victims of Identity Theft, 2021

October 2023, NCJ 306474

https://bjs.ojp.gov/document/vit21.pdf

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by joxdosba on Monday June 22, 2026 @05:44AM (#48627964)
These links claim that identities are stolen, but do not explain how.

What happens to the victims, who are now presumably left unidentifiable? How are they tracked if they can’t be identified? Do their families recognise them? How does that work if they were married, had children or something? Does the identity thief just take over their whole life?

As far as I know, “identity theft” is a boogeyman invented by the banks. Traditionally, when someone would go to a bank and get a loan by pretending to be another person, we just called it “fraud”.

The banks realised that it would be nice to get you to feel some responsibility when they get defrauded, so after a bunch of focus grouping they came up with this new term to imply that you are somehow also a victim when the bank gets defrauded by someone else.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by yurishimo on Monday June 22, 2026 @07:11AM (#48628607)
I would maybe reframe it as fraud being a natural downstream effect of identity theft. I don't need to steal anyone's identity to forge a check but that's also categorized as fraud.

Identity theft also paints a clearer picture of what is required to remedy the situation. If your details have been pwnd hard enough, you might need to get new government documents entirely in order to protect yourself long term.

If a contractor takes my money to install a pool and then disappears, I don't need to reset my entire financial identity. I think it's worth having a separate idea to describe the situation as a whole and not just the specific vector in which a crime might have been committed.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by joxdosba on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:49AM (#48629472)
> Identity theft also paints a clearer picture of what is required to remedy the situation. If your details have been pwnd hard enough, you might need to get new government documents entirely in order to protect yourself long term

Okay, but in the US (for example) you simply can’t do that, and your details are already available to everyone for a dollar or two.

I’ll concede that “identity theft” could conceivably have a reasonable meaning in the context of e.g. Estonian digital identities where you could in a sense steal someone’s private key.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by yencabulator on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @05:33PM (#48651774)
> I’ll concede that “identity theft” could conceivably have a reasonable meaning in the context of e.g. Estonian digital identities where you could in a sense steal someone’s private key.

Stealing someone's private key still wouldn't be "identity theft", they'd just need to bootstrap a new key the same way they got the government to trust the previous one (and revoke the old one).

It's just victim-blaming and PR attempting to make companies not liable for their bad decisions.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by abenga on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:03AM (#48628105)
It is a legal fiction invented by corporations to pass the blame onto you when criminals convinces the companies to give them money in your name.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by joe_the_user on Monday June 22, 2026 @02:37AM (#48626549)
Well, if all the data people uploaded to these models provided ironclad personal identification, would Anthropic need to have these identity verification processes? They could have directed Claude to disconnect all non-citizens when the order came, for example. Perhaps they don't to frighten people with that ability. But most likely all the inputs together only add to a rough identity hash.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:36AM (#48626986)
> Well, if all the data people uploaded to these models provided ironclad personal identification, would Anthropic need to have these identity verification processes?

> But most likely all the inputs together only add to a rough identity hash.

You literally provide your name, email address, address and credit card number when you create an account and subscribe.

The identity verification they're doing is for legal purposes. Even if they have a way to take your name and IP address and figure out who you are with near-absolute certainty (including through the use of third-party databases), they're doing this so they have a legally-defensible process by which identities were established.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Monday June 22, 2026 @05:26AM (#48627838)
> You literally provide your name...

Not if you are using through your employer.

> they're doing for legal purposes

The USA is becoming a Banana Repulic. Having grown up in one, you end up learning that "the law" is never meant to be used for the benefit of the people but only to give the veneer of legitimacy for the authoritarian abuse by those in power.

“To my friends, anything; to my enemies, the law”: https://www.undp.org/latin-america/blog/graph-for-thought/%E...

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:10AM (#48628162)
Differential application of the law has been a part of American society for a very long time. I suppose you could argue that it's more brazen and accepted (or even celebrated in some cases) these days, but that could also be a function of people just being more willing to see it because America's reputation/standing in the world is in decline.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:16AM (#48628203)
Right, but do you agree then this explains why people are not willing to give their identity details to a company, even if the company is able to deduct/obtain these details through other means if it wanted?
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:08AM (#48629058)
No. I really don't see the connection in this instance.

Many companies are required by law to verify the identities of their customers (for money laundering, sanctions compliance, etc.) and to do so in a certain way they can document.

Thinking that the US is a Banana Republic in which laws are applied differentially doesn't inherently mean that every rule that requires you to go through a process you don't like is unfair/unjust.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:13AM (#48629094)
It's not a matter of being "unfair", it's a matter of people not trusting the institutions.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:50AM (#48629482)
And? Yes, people have good reason to not trust institutions these days. But does not trusting institutions mean that you no longer have to comply with the rules, or that every rule is not based on a legitimate concern?
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Monday June 22, 2026 @09:02AM (#48629611)
> not trusting institutions mean that you no longer have to comply with the rules

Not if you can avoid it, no.

> every rule is not based on a legitimate concern?

This particular rule is not based on a legitimate concern.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:00PM (#48638277)
> This particular rule is not based on a legitimate concern.

Well, there are multiple legitimate reasons for Anthropic to ask some customers to do identity verification:

1. To comply with export controls.

2. To prevent abuse.

3. To process requests for increased usage or spend limits.

4. To defend against payment fraud.

This really isn't uncommon. I've been asked to do identity verification for something as innocuous as registering a domain name, setting up an account to bid on collectibles, etc.

If you've ever worked in ecommerce, payments or a related sector, you know how many bad actors are trying to game systems every single day and what the consequences are to the business if they succeed. Even when you're not dealing with non-negotiable compliance requirements (like KYC, export controls, etc.), there are lots of situations in which you'd have a reasonable need to establish that the people you're serving are who they say they are.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @04:39AM (#48642087)
Yeah, we can come up with all sorts of reasons to justify their new policy, but at the end of the day it's clear that this policy only came after Fable got blocked. You keep trying to find a way to rationalize their action, when it is clear that the adopted this policy for one simple reason: it's an attempt to appease the US government.

Why is that? Why is so hard for you to see that Anthropic by pushing the "our models are so good that regular people should not have access to it" narrative, they ended up shooting themselves in the foot?

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @05:39AM (#48642508)
> You keep trying to find a way to rationalize their action, when it is clear that the adopted this policy for one simple reason: it's an attempt to appease the US government.

Your position seems to be based on lack of knowledge of the fact that the US government has broad authority to regulate AI services under existing national security and export control powers.

You can argue that those powers are wrong, but these powers are well-established and perfectly legal.

Anthropic could challenge these in court but, from what I've read, most attorneys specializing in this area of law believe it would face an uphill battle in courts because the related powers are so broad and well-established.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @05:56AM (#48642643)
> seems to be based on lack of knowledge of the fact that the US government has broad authority to regulate AI services

I understand they have the authority. The point that you keep evading to answer is "Why Anthropic only? Why now?".

More than that: why do you keep arguing that people should just accept it? Why do you think that we should just roll over and accept these rules?

I am not asking you "what the courts would say", I am asking you personally: you really don't see a problem in normalizing a world where people can only conduct business if they subject themselves to give away personal data? Do you think that Surveillance Capitalism is just something that people need to accept as some natural state of affairs?

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @08:19AM (#48643842)
> I am not asking you "what the courts would say", I am asking you personally: you really don't see a problem in normalizing a world where people can only conduct business if they subject themselves to give away personal data?

Companies like Meta and Google collude with media/publishers/online service providers to track you across the web and use your data to target you for advertising even when you aren't registered or logged into their services. Data brokers whose names nobody knows gather and sell information about every single American. Credit bureaus track some of your most sensitive financial data whether you like or not, and sell it to companies who use it to make some of the most important decisions that affect you financially.

Anthropic asking customers who voluntarily choose to do business with Anthropic for ID so that they can comply with sanctions laws is not the same thing.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @10:10AM (#48645249)
> Companies like Meta and Google

This is some weird whataboutism, and it doesn't answer my question.

> Anthropic asking customers who voluntarily choose to do business

Anthropic is changing the terms. It used to be until last week that ID is not required. Now it is. Some of these customers are now reconsidering their relationship, and it seems you are here saying they should just accept it without a second thought, because "this is what other companies do it anyway". This is the part I am struggling to understand.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:34PM (#48654780)
> Anthropic is changing the terms. It used to be until last week that ID is not required. Now it is.

The Anthropic page related to ID verification is not new. It existed in April and had some minor changes made last week.

https://www.diffchecker.com/HuY8QMOX/

We can disagree, but please don't misrepresent the facts: new customers are not being required to verify their ID by default, nor are existing customers being contacted en masse to do so. ID verification is being used with some customers and it appears this is primarily related to account suspensions that are typically due to usage patterns, fraud concerns, etc.

> Some of these customers are now reconsidering their relationship, and it seems you are here saying they should just accept it without a second thought, because "this is what other companies do it anyway".

I'm not saying anything of the sort. What I am saying is that I find it odd to base a decision to close a Claude account on the basis that asking for ID verification represents an assault against privacy.

Even though Anthropic says that its ID verification is not related to Mythos/Fable, in our discussion, I have pointed out that as a US company, Anthropic could be required to comply with various export controls that are implemented under well-established and perfectly-legal export control regulations.

It is also perfectly normal for companies to require ID verification for some customers under certain circumstances to address legitimate usage and fraud concerns.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @04:21AM (#48656802)
> new customers are not being required to verify their ID by default

If they want to use Mythos, they need to provide the ID. It has become a two-class service.

> I find it odd to base a decision to close a Claude account on the basis that asking for ID verification represents an assault against privacy.

The decision does not have one specific reason. For example, I closed my account when they stopped allowing usage of OpenCode with a regular subscription. Some other people are now asking if the service they are getting is really worth it and if they should support a company which actively working towards this two-class system.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @11:30AM (#48661448)
> If they want to use Mythos, they need to provide the ID. It has become a two-class service.

You have no inherent, God-given legal right to access Mythos. Once again, the US government (and in particular the executive branch) has a broad and well-established legal authority to regulate advanced technologies under national security and export control regulations.

If you want to buy, say, the most advanced NVIDIA chips, you can be subject to verifications as well because these are subject to export controls.

> The decision does not have one specific reason. For example, I closed my account when they stopped allowing usage of OpenCode with a regular subscription. Some other people are now asking if the service they are getting is really worth it and if they should support a company which actively working towards this two-class system.

Anthropic is a private company. It is allowed to decide how to provision its service, and make changes to its service. This has absolutely nothing to do with "Surveillance Capitalism".

You have the right to vote with your wallet, which you have done. If enough people make the same decision, Anthropic will likely have to reconsider its decisions. That's capitalism, is it not?

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @02:05PM (#48663546)
These are a lot of rationalizations for you to justify the actions of a company whose CEO talks a lot about ethics, but when push comes to shove acts like any other corporate drone.

Also, you are talking a lot about what Anthropic can do but completely evading to actually say what you think they should do. It tells me that you know how reprehensible their ethics are, but for some reason you refuse to reject them.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @11:21PM (#48668426)
We've had an interesting back-and-forth about identity verification but it seems that you don't really care about that issue.

It seems that you just don't like the way Anthropic is run, and a focal point of that is that you're unhappy you can't access Fable and Mythos.

To be clear: the US government issued an order that required Anthropic to suspend access to Fable and Mythos by any foreign national. The company had to comply or it could face significant penalties. According to the company, the only way it could comply with the government order was to suspend access to everyone.

The ID verification page being discussed here has been around since before this order was issued. Like many companies, Anthropic may ask some customers for ID verification, primarily to prevent fraud and abuse. ID verification is not required to sign up, and existing customers are not all being asked to perform it.

Frankly, I think a lot of these companies are ethically-challenged, but not making the latest and greatest models available to everyone who wants them and complying with legal government orders are not the strongest arguments about their ethical shortcomings.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by rglullis on Thursday June 25, 2026 @03:46AM (#48670245)
> it seems that you don't really care about that issue.

Not in the particular. What I care about is the concentration of power and this slide into any single corporation can control it all.

> you're unhappy you can't access Fable and Mythos.

Not at all. I don't personally care. You can find me on record saying that I'd rather work with local models that are "dumber" but can simply assist me through a process, instead of outsourcing all my thinking to a huge LLM.

> Frankly, I think a lot of these companies are ethically-challenged

But you are still sticking by them, aren't you? Why?

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by BeetleB on Monday June 22, 2026 @09:41AM (#48630004)
> You literally provide your name, email address, address and credit card number when you create an account and subscribe.

I don't recall Anthropic's payment systems, but I use Paypal wherever supported. I don't think Paypal sends my address, but am not sure. I'm pretty sure they don't send the CC information.

And often, not even the name (e.g. have often had people use my CC to buy stuff (with my permission)).

Also, I still routinely buy stuff from one service that thinks I'm in a state I haven't lived in for over 20 years, because that's the address I provided back then.

So no, generally, sending your payment info doesn't equate to sending them my address.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by gck1 on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:52PM (#48633500)
PayPal sends everything you listed to the merchant except for CC number.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by ElProlactin on Monday June 22, 2026 @10:30PM (#48639449)
https://www.paypal.com/us/privacy-center/privacy-practices

> When you check out with PayPal, the merchant will receive info that is necessary to process the transaction and prevent fraud. This may include:

> Your name, email address, amount received

> Your shipping address and phone number

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by teliosix on Monday June 22, 2026 @07:13AM (#48628625)
It is just the standard performative outrage over and over. The same person will be uploading their ID a few days after it is introduced.

So many people have internalized an anonymous audience that they are performing to in terms of what they think the anonymous audience wants to hear that they can't tell what is their own actual thoughts and motivations.

That is why the motivation changes two weeks later and the ID gets uploaded.

Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by mapt on Monday June 22, 2026 @07:43AM (#48628852)
Some of us hold grudges on account of performative outrage. Ubisoft made invasive DRM the norm in gaming ~20 years ago. While other companies now do the same thing, I'm still boycotting. Fuck'em.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by skocznymroczny on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:07AM (#48629050)
I'd say before Ubisoft, Valve was the one to really spearhead DRM by introducing online verification to play Half-Life 2. Before HL2, it was almost unthinkable for a game to require Internet access to be played and most copy protection relied on serial numbers and/or presence of the original game CD. HL2 was high profile enough to make people accept the restriction.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by pbgcp2026 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @06:08PM (#48652150)
+1. You are not alone and please keep boycotting them. I personally do this and never use any websites or services requiring "ID check". If Gov agency wants my face and prints - Ok, I will give them on the border crossing and immigration services to get a passport. Everyone else goes to hell.
Re:Anthropic to Require ID Verification for Certain Capabili... by asdfsa32 on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:39AM (#48629355)
It is because you think the contention is about being identifiable, while that is hardly the case.

Most people understand or at least accept that in order to facilitate payments and a company to follow various laws that are generally understood as "good for all" (like AML and tax avoidance), but require ID to access is not the same.

It is identical to accepting to paying for National Parks car pass or camp ground fees but protesting access fees. Not the same thing.