News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by meritt on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:25PM (#4858847)
It's always been rumored that Adobe software, especially Photoshop, has been easy to pirate to encourage adoption with a user base that might otherwise seek alternatives. As those people hone their skills and eventually find jobs, Photoshop is the norm and what their employers purchase licensing for.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ender7 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:41PM (#4859103)
Well, I must admit that when I was a kid I taught myself how to use most of the Creative Suite via pirated copies (back then it was the Macromedia Suite plus whatever Adobe was calling its software at the time). I'm now employed because of those skills, and my employer has to purchase annual copies of said software for me to use.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ddorian43 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:07PM (#4859178)
Why annual? Do you really need the latest CS(n)? Or do you buy by subscription?
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by dbrian on Saturday December 01, 2012 @07:52PM (#4859620)
Compared to a designers salary, $50/mo to keep them on the latest software is money well spent. The Joel Test #9.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by lumberjack on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:40PM (#4858895)
Same with Windows and Office. It's better to have them pirate your program than run somebody's else.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by wting on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:43PM (#4858904)
"Although about 3 million computers get sold every year in China, people don't pay for the software. Someday they will, though. And as long as they're going to steal it, we want them to steal ours. They'll get sort of addicted, and then we'll somehow figure out how to collect sometime in the next decade."

-- Bill Gates during speech at University of Washington

http://articles.latimes.com/2006/apr/09/business/fi-micropir...

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by mappu on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:50PM (#4859301)
"Number two market share goes to Windows pirated, or unlicensed ... That's a competitor that's tough to beat, they've got a good price and a heck of a product, but we're working on it."

-- Steve Ballmer, 2009 http://www.osnews.com/story/21035

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ihaveajob on Sunday December 02, 2012 @05:04AM (#4860742)
Another quote by Ballmer, heard in person a couple of weeks ago: "In Russia, we have a great market share, but a bit of a problem collecting".
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:35PM (#4859266)
Sadly that didn't stop them from claiming that piracy was a $1.5B$ problem because the retail price of Office was $495. Even though even a child would tell you that no sane individual would spend more than 1/2 their annual salary to buy a copy of a buggy, but ubiquitous, set of tools. In fact they were willing to pay $2 for a pirated CD on the streets so the actual "loss to piracy" was $6M ($2 per each of those 3M machines) but that sounds so much less of an actual problem.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ciniglio on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:47PM (#4859297)
So, by this logic, BitTorrent piracy is a $0 problem? Doesn't sound right to me. Not that I'm really pushing the $495 figure either, mind you.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 01, 2012 @06:58PM (#4859489)
Actually yes, well actually approaching zero, and I realize it doesn't sound right. The cognitive dissonance comes from the economics of information, they work differently than the economics of goods.

Imagine this thought experiment. Imagine there was a 100% fool proof copy protection scheme in China, and the only way to acquire Microsoft Office would be to buy it. Try to imagine how many people, who make $1000 in a year would then cough up the $495 to buy it?

Its not hard to imagine because there is no manufactured good in China that commands a 'half annual salary' value proposition that is not critical to a person's survival. And Microsoft Office isn't that item.

There is an exemplar that there is a $6M value for Word based on the $2 CDs that sell, so its not 'valueless.' And there are benefits to owning a legitimate copy over a pirated copy. Further, the cost of producing a pirated product (box, CD, getting started guide, etc) is less than $2 so there actually a real-goods sort of economic value analysis possible as well.

So all we really know is that the number is >= $2 and < $495. And in information economics this poses an interesting challenge. How do you capture the maximum value for your information? Microsoft later introduced a plan where Office for this market was significantly less expensive than it was for the US and European markets [1]. That increased the value they extracted for office out of those markets tremendously. It was more than 10x that $1.50 price at $29/CD. And they captured a lot of value for it, millions and millions of dollars. But not billions of dollars.

Many have argued that much of NetFlix's streaming revenue has come from previous BitTorrent users [2]. Prior to NetFlix you could say BitTorrent was a "$xB" problem where $x is the money that has been re-captured by offering an alternative with an acceptable price.

But to understand how that works you have to think about what gives information value, its much more market driven that fiat driven. Sony can say "Its worth $X to own this movie" but if nobody buys it and it is heavily pirated they guessed wrong. Since the replication cost is nearly $0 they really are guessing at consumer value. Lots of DVDs sell for $9.99 or $4.99. At that price I won't even bother looking for a torrent, I'll just get the DVD. Its a market, it has different mechanisms that drive it.

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/09/23/microsoft-china-di...

[2] http://gigaom.com/2011/05/17/netflix-p2p-traffic/

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by pyre on Saturday December 01, 2012 @10:51PM (#4860005)

  > Since the replication cost is nearly $0
  > they really are guessing at consumer value.
There still is the fixed cost of creating the DVD content. Maybe not encoding the movie, but putting together the menus, extras, easter eggs, packaging, etc. Also, the fixed costs grow when considering things like 'remastering vault copies.'

The variable costs might be close to $0, but the decision to create the DVD still costs something.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by napoleond on Saturday December 01, 2012 @08:18PM (#4859689)
This is really interesting, thank you. Could you recommend any good books about the economics of information as you've described it here?
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ChuckMcM on Sunday December 02, 2012 @01:03AM (#4860291)
I don't know of any good books on the subject. I have been studying the ideas since 1995 when I joined a startup called GolfWeb which was publishing a magazine about Golf on the Web. And the question came up "What is this worth?" and "Would people subscribe?" That lead to some interesting investigations into the how people value things. Then in the late 90's I was talking with a friend who was getting an MBA at Berkeley. We invented the 'time valued coke machine' over lunch one day, its a coke machine where you can buy a soda for 25 cents if you are willing to wait an hour to have it come out. For $2 it will come out right away. Now this is a really really precise soda machine (has an atomic clock in it) so if you paid your 25 cents your ticket tells you exactly when a soda will fall out of it. Now you can sell that to someone for 50 cents, and if you're getting near the hour mark you might be able to sell it for $1 or maybe $1.50. So you have just created, and sold information for a profit of 100 - 500%. All when you thought you were buying a soda :-).

I started writing my experiences with this up but stopped when I went to work for Google on the advice of my lawyer. Its a discouraging thing to write/talk about because without context people think its crazy, so slowly over time, as context develops, and "real world" examples get played out, the notion that information can have its own set of economic principles becomes less foreign because it sure as heck isn't behaving like it "should" if it was bound by the old rules.

Anyway, three ways I've seen so far to add value to information is that its timely, its rare, or its distilled. An example of timely information would be stock trades, very valuable right at the time they happen to high frequency traders, less and less as it gets older until its basically worthless 15 minutes old. Continuing with the stock market 'rare' or 'precious' information might be insider information about a company, it has value because it creates context that others can't see, which gives it a value proportional to the advantage it conveys, and lastly distilled value. Remember our stock market trades? Well they were very valuable 20 milliseconds after they happened, worthless after 15 minutes, but when kept over the course of time new data can be distilled from that old information (like maybe a stock always rises in the third quarter). I discovered at a conference that the intelligence agencies call this last one the 'Mosaic effect' where any single piece of information is useless but together they allow new data to emerge.

Artistic creation however is always the "best" information in terms of value. It can create value greatly out of proportion to the cost to produce it.

Anyway, like I said, I've been thinking about this stuff for 15 years. :-)

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by napoleond on Sunday December 02, 2012 @03:42AM (#4860598)
It's a book that needs to be written; I hope you write it. (And then... how would you price it? ;) ) In the meantime, thanks for taking the time to dump this out--it's enormously appreciated and has given me lots to think about.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by huggah on Saturday December 01, 2012 @06:42PM (#4859447)
If people were selling copies on the street for $2, that suggests that $2 was roughly the right price point (in that area) to maximize profit, and Microsoft couldn't have made more money by selling it for more.

That argument ceases to hold in the case of BitTorrent, where the distributors aren't trying to maximize their profit (or make any at all).

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 01, 2012 @07:06PM (#4859512)
See previous response, Microsoft actually did change their pricing and captured a huge chunk of value. It was significantly higher than $2/CD. When selling information there is a tail, a few people will pay whatever you ask, a few more will pay less than that, Etc, until you get to all of the people who would obtain a copy if it were zero cost. That defines the "value curve" of the information. It is not a straight line. Because it is "hard" to justify large differences in price for the same product, one of two strategies are used a "steadily decreasing price" or a "fixed but relatively low price". Depending on the product different things make more sense. Games for example benefit from the 'expensive at first but cheaper later' model, reference works benefit by capturing as much market as possible quickly.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by jfoster on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:26PM (#4859249)
It's similar to many startups. Free initially to ensure growth, but always with eventual monetization in mind.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by reidrac on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:11PM (#4859010)
Definitely, but I think is just Microsoft investing in their ecosystem.

In schools students learn "Word" and not "a word processor". I've seen high schools getting software licences with special deals (way cheaper), and thanks to that other solutions are discouraged (ie. "Word" is the standard and it will be required by any future job offer)

Can all students afford a Word licence? (ie. practice at home) It really doesn't matter, piracy it's OK because it is an investment. Companies are the final target (won't run pirated software and all candidates are trained to use that software).

You can find that kind of strategy also in open source (ie. Red Hat benefits from CentOS).

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by sliverstorm on Saturday December 01, 2012 @06:28PM (#4859417)
There are avenues to acquire Office inexpensively.

* There was a $60 sale on 2007 for students.

* I was able to get a copy of 2010 for $1 for home use because I also use it at work

* You can always purchase a used copy of 2003 for cheap. It's dated, of course, but not really outdated yet.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by takeda64 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:27PM (#4859063)
I agree with you about the last thing somewhat, but not entirely. While RedHat benefits from people switching from CentOS to RHEL, it's not illegal to run CentOS, and the other direction is also available.

My company is currently using RedHat in a very large number (let say, we pay a lot to them...), but looks like we might end up switching to CentOS. Basically the price vs. amount of support we get from them does not seem to be worth it. And it is very close to what we would get from an Open Source community or by using Google.

But I do agree with the rest what you said.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by reidrac on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:36PM (#4859089)
I know it's not illegal, I didn't say that at all. I said it's the same strategy. Although a customer that can move from RHEL to CentOS can be seen as a problem, I think it's just an investment.

Look at the consequences of CentOS. There are mailing lists, forums, IRC channels, blog posts, lots of people providing support and training for free.

That rich ecosystem is translated into business for Red Hat.

EDIT: ate a word.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by eli on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:45PM (#4858910)
Though it'd be better still if they paid something. Microsoft offers special low-cost editions of their products for developing nations, don't they?
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by markokocic on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:05PM (#4859170)
No, they don't. I even remember that the prices for legal Microsoft software in one of those "developing nations" were higher than prices in the USA.

And it's not only Microsoft, some other companies (Audodesk, Adobe, Apple) also keep higher prices and worse quality in some of poor countries than in the USA. It's kinda like they try to punish people that want to buy their software legally.

For me, it's an easy decision, I just don't use their software at all, but some people have to use their software, and I totally understand why some of them decide to pirate it.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by jiggy2011 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @10:29PM (#4859968)
Wouldn't the issue be that if they sold Windows for say $10 in china that westerners could just import it for $10 + shipping and then install language packs once they had it?
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by galadriel on Sunday December 02, 2012 @02:59AM (#4860515)
There are usually region restricted DRM trying to stop this from happening. For example, a lot of digital distribution gaming companies (like Steam) have cheaper prices of games in Russia compared to US. So there are all kinds of websites that will sell a Russian key and Russian proxy service so that one can get game for cheap. OTOH, the distributors try to monitor and keep disabling accounts if they find that region restricted games are being played.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by kmfrk on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:48PM (#4858921)
I'm not sure about this with Windows, frankly. "Something else" is not as obvious and accessible the same way one movie or videogame is over the other.

I remember getting burnt badly trying to install ... Mandrake was it ... back in the days.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by shocks on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:52PM (#4858932)
iirc, Microsoft originally uploaded Office to places it could be easily pirated to help it spread and take over the market.

It worked.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by eli on Saturday December 01, 2012 @03:43PM (#4858903)
I've heard that too, but I have no idea if it's true. (Surely, Photoshop would be pirated regardless of how much DRM is added).

But it's definitely not only the goodness of their heart that leads many companies to offer free or cheap software to students. Microsoft BizSpark is all about giving startups free Microsoft software in the hope that they'll build on the MS stack.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by TheAmazingIdiot on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:02PM (#4858971)
For the longest time, cracking Photoshop was a 1 byte change. In effect, there was a conditional JMP. You patch the address of the good JMP to the bad conditional side.

Voila: enter a good or bad serial, and it works. A bunch of us under +Fravia came to an agreement that this simplicity was intentional. I think we all can come to the conclusion to why that is...

As to your supposition that no amount of 'junk' would stop pirates, I do beg to differ. Back around '98-2000, there was a CD burning program that was notorious to crack. I don't remember the name offhand. There were over a thousand verify checks built into the program at crazy locations. Many would also attempt to write corrupt CDs and ISOs. And the "best part": if you were using a 'naughty' code, it would silently take it and slowly corrupt everything that program touches.

Most pirates ignored it and went with NERO to crack/distribute. A few of the hardcore crackers took on that program. I knew of 2 successes.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by hannibalhorn on Saturday December 01, 2012 @06:59PM (#4859492)
The CD burning product must have been CDRWIN, I remember the frustration of searching for a working crack for that one (as a poor student, of course!)
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by meritt on Saturday December 01, 2012 @08:19PM (#4859692)
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/alt.cd-rom/IPpvC20j2cM...

CDRWIN's author's rant and viewpoints against piracy, from March 1998

  When all software distribution moves to the Internet (which it will   
  when high-speed fiberoptic connections because commonplace in the   
  future), the big developers like Microsoft and Sony are going to come 
  down hard on the pirates and WAREZ. These big companies are not going 
  to allow the Internet to become a "candy store" where software can be 
  stolen with the push of a button from the comfort of your home. If you
  think that all of these "bits" are free, then try developing a really 
  good software product yourself and see how much money and time you have
  to invest in it.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by TeMPOraL on Sunday December 02, 2012 @09:19AM (#4861235)
I wonder how "how much money and time you have to invest in" putting in so many arcane anti-crack measures into your software as GGP[0] described.

[0] - Great Grandparent Poster? :D.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by niyazpk on Saturday December 01, 2012 @08:50PM (#4859770)
I was under the [naive] impression that _every_ security check finally boils down to one JMP statement. Can you please explain what makes other programs more difficult to crack than flipping the one JMP location?
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by Strom on Saturday December 01, 2012 @11:36PM (#4860102)
Instead of a JMP, imagine that the serial key is used to calculate some variable in the program. The code runs with both a valid and an invalid serial, but some core algorithm of the program uses this variable, that was derived from the serial. If the serial was invalid, the core algorithm would not produce the desired result.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by TheAmazingIdiot on Sunday December 02, 2012 @02:57AM (#4860510)
Just read this:

http://71.6.196.237/fravia/progcor.htm

It's down in the rabbit hole for you :P

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by johnpowell on Sunday December 02, 2012 @06:08AM (#4860857)
It was that way for me. Back in 2001 I got a iMac G3 500 while I was in collage. I used a p2p program called http://www.carracho.com/ to get Photoshop and Dreamweaver. The next summer I got a job at the university doing web design. The university bought me legit copies of the software since I preferred to work on My iBook and not the POS they had on my desk.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by Tyrant505 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:18PM (#4859030)
What exactly is HARD to pirate? edit: More specifically, Crack. I remember x-force having sources in all the major places ready to dump it to their cracker division.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by angersock on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:26PM (#4859061)
Skype for a very long time had some absurd protection against things like attaching debuggers, adding code, and whatnot (as I recall). There was a great presentation about it, but I cannot for the life of me find it.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by agumonkey on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:45PM (#4859118)
To my very limited knowledge, the most difficult software to crack was Steinberg Cubase. Such a PITA the hackers decided not to do it ever again. They quoted a ridiculously large figure for the amount code devoted to detect cracking (~30%), and having a significant impact on performance.

I had links about about bypassing anti-debugging techniques, I'll see if I can get my hands on them again.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by majorlazer on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:53PM (#4859310)
Cubase was, by far, the hardest program to find a crack for. I remember a buddy of mine hooked me up with a cracked version that actually worked, but then I reinstalled and lost the files. Never found it again and stopped using Cubase. A year later I just purchased Ableton Live. I know so many people that use Live now because Cubase was too difficult to crack.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by sneak on Saturday December 01, 2012 @06:52PM (#4859477)
The current version of Live on the Macintosh itself took quite some time to crack.

Those guys at Ableton are serious business.

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by Kliment on Saturday December 01, 2012 @07:02PM (#4859500)
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by Tyrant505 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @04:28PM (#4859066)
Ok, but not exactly the type of standalone software we are speaking upon, yes? edit: as an aside, adobe's subscription based model could be seen as a way to curtail.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by JagMicker on Saturday December 01, 2012 @08:05PM (#4859656)
Many DAW's (Digital Audio Workstation) such as Cubase, and DSP "plug-ins" have special software protection schemes. Cubase uses something called eLicenser[1].

Another popular, niche product that has proven difficult to fully crack is a program called Pro Tools, created by DigiDesign, now owned by Avid. It uses a protection called PACE Anti-Piracy[2]. Many expensive pieces of software require unique hardware, either a security dongle or some other external device.

[1] eLicenser.net

[2] paceap.com

Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by ladzoppelin on Saturday December 01, 2012 @05:14PM (#4859198)
Things that use codemeter are impossible (At least right now).
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by yozmsn on Saturday December 01, 2012 @08:46PM (#4859757)
Adobe Software in no longer easy to pirate. From what I understand people have to go to great lengths to pirate CS6, same goes for Office 2010, a friend told me that to pirate it he had to call Microsoft and mess around with files, it's not just a keygen anymore.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by learc83 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @09:16PM (#4859828)
For Adobe Software it's easier than it has been in years. No need to install a patch. You just have to edit your host file to block all the domains CS uses to phone home.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by yozmsn on Saturday December 01, 2012 @09:50PM (#4859892)
Right, but finding a good Product Key is very difficult still.
Re:Editorial: "How piracy changed my life" by learc83 on Saturday December 01, 2012 @09:54PM (#4859900)
No it's not. The keys don't go bad. 1 Key can be used for a million installs b/c the software never contacts adobe.