News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by mtgx on Thursday November 29, 2012 @03:43PM (#4850147)
Google is basically telling Amazon: "You do not want to play this price-cutting game with us".

It's a great strategy from Google especially if they think they can match any move from Amazon in this way, and if they can sustain it for a long period of time.

It's basically game theory, and at this point, Amazon would be smart to stop cutting prices just for the sake of out-competing Google on price. And if they do that, Google might also stop doing it, because as in game theory, they know continuing an aggressive price war in this manner is only going to hurt both of them, because they are both very resilient and they won't take each other out in this way anyway.

Amazon, the market leader, trying to beat Google on price, would be like Coca-Cola trying to beat Pepsi on price, and racing to the bottom. Coca-Cola has learned a long time ago that it's okay if Pepsi is slightly cheaper. Same goes for Verizon and AT&T.

I think they will both still continue to cut their prices at a regular time period, as hardware prices fall, but only for the sake of expanding the market and getting new classes of customers that otherwise wouldn't use their services, and not just to try and steal from each other.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by mlinsey on Thursday November 29, 2012 @04:01PM (#4850252)
Amazon is much more accustomed to operating a low-margin business than Google or Microsoft. Google's overall profitability can allow it to take bigger losses and subsidize its cloud services division if it wants to, but at some point, executives have to wonder if that's the most strategic use of those resources.

It's also not always the case that the leader competes on quality while the followers compete on price. In many industries, being the leader means you have infrastructure advantages and nobody can touch you on price, whereas others must serve smaller markets based on quality. Retail (both online and offline) is a good example. You'd be foolish to suggest that Amazon (the retail side) or Wal-Mart give up competing on price and let their smaller competitors take that mantle.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by spdy on Thursday November 29, 2012 @04:24PM (#4850359)
Noone on this planet can compete with Google on storage prices. I dont want to know how many petabytes of space they have laying around "just in case" another planet comes around and they have to index/mirror all the information.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by mlinsey on Thursday November 29, 2012 @05:41PM (#4850728)
Extraterrestrial planets aside, it's a fair point. Google's fleet undoubtedly has more machines than Amazon's in total, and that might give Google better economies of scale even though it isn't the leader in the utility computing space. However, there are several other considerations. We don't know if the main google.com fleet is made up of the same types of machines as the ones used for Google Compute Engine; for example Google can much more easily tolerate a high failure rate for a single machine than a startup renting a couple of instances. There are also more costs to consider than just the hardware, customer support being a big example.

Overall, I'd say that Google can certainly undercut Amazon on price, but at the cost of reducing the margins that its executives and shareholders are used to seeing. They might see this as a worthwhile tradeoff if they see utility computing as a strategically important space; but personally I don't see that space as a long-term threat to Google in the same way social networks or mobile phones were. But I'm certainly happy to see Google compete here; I benefit as much as any other startup from a price war.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by jaytaylor on Thursday November 29, 2012 @08:08PM (#4851328)
> .. Google's fleet undoubtedly has more machines than Amazon's in total ..

Given that this assertion is mandatory for your argument to hold water, actual numbers to support your claims are required here. And since Google and Amazon don't publicly share this data, where does that leave us?

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by spade on Thursday November 29, 2012 @11:52PM (#4851904)
From 2009 to 2011, Google spent ~$8B on capital expenditures (buildings, property,& equipment) while Amazon spent ~$3B on capital expenditures. Given Google's scale, they probably have better economics than Amazon.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by mlinsey on Friday November 30, 2012 @01:19AM (#4852109)
Technically, this argument is mandatory for an argument against me to hold water (that I was simply trying to say was a fair point against my original claim, even though many people were unfairly downvoting spdy for it). Feel free to discard the post if you'd like, which would leave us with the argument in my original post. I'm pretty confident in what I wrote, though.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by michaelt on Friday November 30, 2012 @06:57AM (#4852847)

  Amazon is much more accustomed to operating a low-margin 
  business than Google or Microsoft.
I'd have thought Amazon's core business, shipping physical goods in exchange for cash, would be more profitable than Google's core business, providing search and e-mail funded by adverts.

I'm not an expert on ad-supported websites, but they aren't exactly notoriously profitable.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by hcarvalhoalves on Thursday November 29, 2012 @04:04PM (#4850266)
I doubt people choose Google's Cloud Platform over Amazon based on price.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by nivla on Thursday November 29, 2012 @05:07PM (#4850551)
One of the main reasons I personally wouldn't choose Google over Amazon no matter how much they lower the price is due to the lack of a solid customer support. God forbid if something goes wrong, not only will I risk losing the Cloud account but also everything else linked to them including Adsense.

Also, Google has a history shutting down unviable services and as these competitive price cuts continues, it gets more risky to keep betting on Google.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by JulianMorrison on Thursday November 29, 2012 @05:58PM (#4850805)
A history shutting down unviable services is a glass half full. On the upside, it means they won't permit a service to limp on, viewing its customers as burdens and providing terrible service in the hopes they go away.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by jlgreco on Friday November 30, 2012 @01:31AM (#4852133)
In either of those scenarios, migration off their services would become necessary. But if they keep it limping instead of cutting it off, that I think facilitates safer more cautious migration (if for no other reason, because it would give you more time to do so). In that respect, keeping the service limping would probably present the superior customer service experience.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by Evbn on Thursday November 29, 2012 @11:39PM (#4851866)
I don't think anyone is worried about scenarios where Google customer service might get worse than it is now.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by wilfra on Thursday November 29, 2012 @09:09PM (#4851485)
This is a very good point and enough for me to know I will not be using Google for cloud hosting...ever.

They shut down AdSense and AdWords accounts constantly with no recourse or explanation and customer support is completely non-existant. Giving them control over my hosting as well is far more power than they've proven worthy of having over my business.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by r00fus on Thursday November 29, 2012 @04:29PM (#4850380)
People do choose their tablet over price - and the race-to-the-bottom is inhabited by two big players - Amazon and Google.

Both of their lowest-end devices are limited to 8GB physical (6GB or less after OS) memory, so cloud storage is a key pricing issue for folks comparing a Kindle Fire vs. Nexus 7 (or Nexus 4).

The battle for the non-iPad tablet space looks like it's heating up fast... what's amusing is that pure hardware manufacturers like Samsung or Acer are nowhere to be found because iPad-style tablets require an ecosystem and a) adequate on-board storage and/or b) cloud storage.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by hcarvalhoalves on Thursday November 29, 2012 @05:53PM (#4850782)
I don't get why you're comparing consumer devices with platforms with pricing?

It shouldn't matter the company providing the PaaS also happens to sell cheap tablets with their logo on it.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by chaz on Thursday November 29, 2012 @07:35PM (#4851212)
I agree, but it's an easy thing for Google to do, and takes away a distraction when comparing the two solutions.
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by jpdoctor on Thursday November 29, 2012 @04:09PM (#4850286)
> Google is basically telling Amazon: "You do not want to play this price-cutting game with us".

I hope both players go ahead and play. Let's see who wins.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by saurik on Thursday November 29, 2012 @04:28PM (#4850376)
There are secondary effects you have to pay attention to... the R&D budget on products like this is paid for by service costs... when you see a system become price constrained down to "virtually no margin" you lose a lot of that; meanwhile, the winner (assuming this is important enough to even bother with, which it seems it is; although, whether this space is actually useful for Google or nothing more than a way to screw with Amazon is not clear) is predictable: Google makes a lot more money than Amazon (>10x normally, and in recent quarters "infinitely more", as Amazon has dipped into the red) and has almost no serious competition in its actual space (advertising)... almost everything else they do is just ad-subsidized (and frankly should be examined for anti-trust... giving away everything from phones to email hosting at cost or even for free in the hope of retaining more advertising revenue is a lot more damaging to the overall ecosystem than giving away one product--a web browser--in the hope of retaining more operating system sales... I'd even go so far as to say it is less justifiable from a technical standpoint: these divisions of Google are almost entirely unrelated).
Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by fkdjs on Thursday November 29, 2012 @11:12PM (#4851801)
Unfortunately for you, anti-trust doesn't work like that. You have to prove concrete harm to customers.

And that's how it should be, before Google, your only option for a smartphone was to pay one company way too much money. Customers directly benefit, and are more productive, so it's basically impossible in the US to prove antitrust against google.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by saurik on Saturday December 01, 2012 @06:56AM (#4857425)
Before Google and after Google there were other competitors to Apple, such as Windows Mobile and WebOS. Also, to be very clear: you seem to be talking about Android, when I was talking about actual physical phones and tablets; right now there are a bunch of people angry that Google is pretty much giving away Nexus devices in an entirely unsustainable fashion. This is a fairly recent development (and would probably be getting more complaints if they didn't immediately run out ;P).

http://www.engadget.com/2012/11/03/editorial-amazon-and-goog...

Regardless, your same argument could easily be said about web browsers, and somehow that case happened, so obviously anti-trust actually does work like that, at least in the eyes of the US prosecutors: just like with Internet Explorer, Google has managed to squelch numerous markets where there could have been competitors by being the only player willing to do it good enough for free; for some less obvious examples, think of cases like Google Code, or Google Charts, or even Google Groups (which is still around, but whose only competitor was another free offering from Yahoo! which is largely a laughing stock at this point).

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by fkdjs on Saturday December 01, 2012 @11:28PM (#4860087)
Here's what a bunch of smart people think:

http://www.c-span.org/Events/Law-and-Economics-Experts-Discu...

synposis: the antitrust case is at this point ridiculous.

As a formerly poor person who could only afford a G1 and not an iphone, allowing me to rise out of poverty, I'm not angry. The only angry people I know are Apple execs. Consumers are pretty happy about this. Which means the antitrust case is going nowhere.

The Microsoft case was different, Microsoft was found guilty for EOM shenanigans, and Bork, who authored modern antitrust law and thought microsoft was guilty, now thinks there is no antitrust case against Google.

When the FTC is done, they'll be a laughing stock.

If you want to really find a problem, you'll have to look at amazon who is not only selling at cost, they make no profit and have a high P/E since investors think they'll eliminate competition then raise prices.

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by kvb on Friday November 30, 2012 @12:17AM (#4851965)
I don't believe that's accurate (at least, as I would interpret "concrete harm to customers"). It may be enough in the US for the predator to intend to reduce competition and to have a reasonable chance of success (and of maintaining higher prices one competition is reduced)[1][2].

[1] - http://www-student.unl.edu/cis/econ321b03/online_course/unit...

[2] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing

Re:Google cuts Cloud Storage prices another 10% after Amazon... by fkdjs on Friday November 30, 2012 @12:32AM (#4852006)
You'll notice in that second link:

> However, because the antitrust laws are ultimately intended to benefit consumers, and discounting results in at least short-term net benefit to consumers, the U.S. Supreme Court has set high hurdles to antitrust claims based on a predatory pricing theory.

So yeah, good luck MS et al. You'll have better luck in the socialist paradise known as the EU.