Why do I care if AI is integrated into my OS when I can choose my preferred AI and it can use the OS directly?
The other day I wrote up some notes for a presentation. Opened Google Slides, clicked the gemini button, pasted the notes in and asked it to make the slides. Nope; gemini can only modify a single slide at a time in Google Slides.
Pasted the same notes into claude, it wrote a pptx file, I imported that into Slides, job done.
Being integrated into the product doesn't always mean a better result.
Not being integrated can be an advantage because it gives you the freedom to think outside the box.
Meanwhile an AI engineer embedded into an incumbent slide app team has to ask permission and get cross functional alignment for every little feature. And deal with neckbeard tech leads lecturing them on what the right architecture is
Open AI can match it but at what price?
Well, it can mean a lot of things, which is why Apple outlined plenty of specific use-cases and details of what they meant by "integrating into the OS" here.
Judging by the announcements today about its integration into the OSes? They are offering useful things ChatGPT cannot offer unless they write an "everything app".
One can (maybe should) make the argument that this is the browser monopoly again, but given that the USA has seemingly no intention of ever litigating that question again even if the EU does, there are clearly features here that OpenAI is effectively locked out of offering.