Re:How Not to Die
by jsjenkins168 on Thursday August 30, 2007 @05:30PM
(#48455)
I've read all of his essays too, but I guess for me in particular this one strikes a chord because:
1) I just resigned from my day job this week to pursue startup ambitions and
2) I am definitely having "oh shit what am I doing" thoughts right now.
So given the timing for me, this kind of inspiration is very moving. As far as how it is written, I would argue that the phoned-in and impulsive nature is what makes this essay so elegant. It is clean and concise, stating the idea simply: dont give up. Anyway, this is all one mans opinion so you are certainly entitled to disagree.
I think that sometimes off-the cuff speeches/essays are more influential because they aren't heavily edited and flow more like how a normal person would speak. I thought this was a great essay.
"1) How can a just-now-released essay be influential at all?"
It can, obviously, be very influential to one reader...and instantly. Time is irrelevant once it reaches that one reader.
Re:How Not to Die
by mattmaroon on Friday August 31, 2007 @03:21AM
(#48627)
All of Paul's essays are better written. This wasn't an essay. It was a talk, and one written quickly.
"Hang in there. Stay plugged in. Oh, and in case you didn't get it the first time, don't give up."
The most influential, well-written paragraph I've ever read!
1) How can a just-now-released essay be influential at all?
2) At least half of pg's essays are better written than this, which to me seemed a little phoned-in. It's not really an essay anyway, but a peptalk. He didn't even have the usual cavalcade of proofreaders at the bottom.
3) The most influential essay I've ever read is the first essay of "Genealogy of Morals".