Re:Apple Said to Fire Maps Manager After Flaws Hurt iPhone 5
by schiffern on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @03:39PM
(#4838846)
>Tim Cook is the CEO. It's ultimately his responsibility--and his apology shows him taking that responsibility
My understanding is that Scott Forstall was forced to resign because he wouldn't put his name on the bottom of that letter.
http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57542297-37/apples-scott-f...
Re:Apple Said to Fire Maps Manager After Flaws Hurt iPhone 5
by taligent on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @05:09PM
(#4839435)
No Forstall was forced to resign because of a lot of mistakes under his watch and a lot of bad blood between him and key people like Ive and Mansfield. With Samsung emphasising the design aspect in the Samsung S3/Note it is critical that Apple have a cohesive end to end experience. And that requires communication.
I think the letter was just the tip of a planet sized iceberg.
His real responsibility is to hire people who can make solid decisions on his behalf, and to fire or move them if they can't do so.
When you reach a certain level, you have to stop passing the buck. Hell, if you want to reach that level, you have to stop passing the buck. Maps was Forstall's responsibility--to ship well or sound the alarm. Unless you have evidence that he was overruled, he's the right person to take the fall.
(This is setting aside all the personality politics, which likely played a bigger role in Forstall's exit. But that aside, Maps was still Forstall's job.)