True enough, in theory; but what exactly are you imagining would be a useful-enough signal in the OpenRouter request+response stream, that any company would want their data as training material?
Even a single OpenRouter-API-key-identified subscriber's traffic, may consist of an mixture of traffic from multiple different sessions, under potentially multiple different end-users. (Where, if the subscriber is doing security correctly, then their OpenRouter key lives on a gateway rather than in a frontend app; and so the only IP address / UA / etc OpenRouter sees is that of the gateway itself.)
And the traffic stream may also invoke multiple models, and provide multiple different system prompts for those models; which, while marked in the traffic (i.e. conveyed as part of each request), makes the resulting data much less useful in aggregate, than if it were all training data for one model with one system prompt.
Plus, there are no RLHF signals in OpenRouter data. Even if OpenRouter wanted to build a general model-neutral framework for collecting RLHF-type data, it can't force subscriber apps to do the UI-level stuff necessary to collect it (i.e. the things ChatGPT/Claude do, with "thumbs-down" buttons, A/B tested responses, etc.) Analysis would have to rely on pure transcript-level user sentiment extraction.
https://x.com/OpenRouter/status/2041193329270878707
> Privacy:
>
> Private I/O logging and the 1% data sharing discount are separate settings. You control each independently.
>
> Input & Output Logging stores prompts and completions for your use only and makes them visible in your logs. OpenRouter does not access this data. You can configure it in your observability settings.
>
> As always, more in the docs!
https://openrouter.ai/docs/guides/features/input-output-logg...https://openrouter.ai/docs/guides/features/broadcast/overvie...
Isn't this a treasure trove for any model distillation effort?
The majority of RLHF data doesn't need this. The majority is software development and/or tool calling where the agent gets a signal back as to if it succeeded (eg compilation errors, test errors). It's true that end-of-trajectory signals (eg, did this task do what you wanted) are even more useful but even partial signals are great for RL training.
"We do not sell users’ data to third parties."
https://www.anthropic.com/news/updates-to-our-consumer-terms
I.e. nothing about this statement prevents Anthropic from running ads within Claude, as long as they run the ad-placement auctions themselves, and so aren't leaking any of the data they're using to decide which placements are relevant to which users+sessions. (This is the same thing Google does for SERP ad auctions.)
But actually, and perhaps more interestingly, nothing about this statement prevents Anthropic from building a Google AdSense competitor either. Other sites (or mobile apps, etc) could plop in an Anthropic ad iframe; and it'd be Anthropic's knowledge of your interactions with Claude that would drive what ads would show up in that iframe. The embedding site doesn't know what ads the users are seeing, so that's still not "selling users' data to third parties", per se.
Clearly, anyone who needs privacy should be using models with privacy protections. Some people build open source and the models will get the code anyway.
OpenRouter explicitly lets you filter by zero-data-retention providers: https://openrouter.ai/models?zdr=true
OpenRouter is also a good place to find free LLM access with a catch: You should expect that any inputs and outputs are going into someone's training database. Clearly anyone who can pay should be using paid models with privacy protections, but the free models have been great for learning and experimenting. Especially for younger people learning API programming and LLMs who may not have access to a credit card or funds.