News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by zaidf on Saturday November 24, 2012 @11:12AM (#4825561)
Few days ago:

Caller: I'm calling from blabla collections agency. May I speak with the owner of Acme.com

Me: Speaking...

Caller: Sir, are you the owner of Acme.com?

Me: Yes...

Caller: Can you confirm your name?

Me: What is this about?

Caller: I cannot reveal anything until I confirm I am speaking with the owner of Acme.com. May I have the last 4 of your social?

...

Me: (I relent) It's 4823

Caller: That does not match my record.

Me: That is my last four of social (truth)

Caller: Do you have your corp no?

Me: Listen, why did you ask me to confirm my social if what you really need is my corp no?

Caller: Blabla. I will have to hang up if you won't confirm.

Me: Good bye

---

Is this crap legal?

Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by Pinckney on Saturday November 24, 2012 @12:56PM (#4825870)
FYI, the last four digits of your SSN are the only ones that are difficult to guess. The first five digits can be guessed pretty accurately based on your date and location of birth.

http://www.heinz.cmu.edu/~acquisti/ssnstudy/

Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by joonix on Saturday November 24, 2012 @03:01PM (#4826278)
That was a really bad move on your part. Could be social engineering. Collections agencies don't need to confirm your social before making a collections call.
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by dhimes on Saturday November 24, 2012 @04:54PM (#4826555)
I actually make them tell me my ssn. I took a call like this from a collector once. There is another person with my name who skipped on his verizon cell bill. I've never had a verizon cell. I was polite; he was a bit aggressive, but I simply explained the fact that it couldn't have been me. I didn't reveal anything about my info.

I then called verizon and confirmed with them that they didn't have a record of me (but yes had someone with my name). They confirmed he had a different ssn.

I then wrote a letter to the agency telling them that a 2 minute call to verizon would confirm that I wasn't their man. I told them that I consider their failure to do so was negligent, and I would hold them entirely responsible for any damage to my credit rating.

My credit rating was not affected- but it may have had nothing to do with my letter.

Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by weinzierl on Saturday November 24, 2012 @11:38AM (#4825617)
Exactly, what's the point of a security check if they keep asking you until you pass.

I had a similar experience when I tried to redeem some Travelers Cheques. Clerk claimed signatures wouldn't not match, and wanted me to sign again at the back of the Cheques. She handed me slip of paper and asked me to practice before I tried again.

I was baffled but certainly preferred that over being arrested;-)

Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by tomjen3 on Saturday November 24, 2012 @11:50AM (#4825660)
My dad hadn't signed his credit card, so she handed it back to him, told him to signed it, took it back -- and _compared_ the two signatures.

The only reason this kind of behaviour makes any kind of sense is if she (and the clerk in your example) were just going through the motions and didn't actually care about the security.

Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by caw on Saturday November 24, 2012 @01:46PM (#4826045)
If a card is invalid (i.e. no signature), the cashier can ask for identification to verify your identity, and watch you sign. If the card is already signed, cashiers may not ask for ID as a condition of the sale, the transaction is considered valid if the signature on the card matches the signature of the receipt.

If your dad had simply signed the card prior to walking up to the counter, that's all the cashier would have been able to verify. So yes, card security is rather lax if it's not signed by the owner of the card immediately upon receipt.

I know this random information because I was a bit miffed that Walmart rejected my girlfriend's transaction because she did not produce ID with a signed card. The above applies to the Visa merchant agreement, I'm not sure about Mastercard or American Express.

Also -- "SEE ID" is not a valid signature, though you can write that over your signature and the card is valid. However, cashiers are not required to honor it.

Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by pyre on Saturday November 24, 2012 @02:31PM (#4826197)

  > the transaction is considered valid if the
  > signature on the card matches the signature
  > of the receipt
In the example above, both the receipt and the card were signed at the register. It would be extremely odd if they didn't match, even if the person paying was a fraudster, therefore it's odd for her to verify them.
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by im3w1l on Saturday November 24, 2012 @03:50PM (#4826413)
Maybe to avoid chargeback.
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by Evbn on Saturday November 24, 2012 @01:12PM (#4825940)
What else could she do? At least she prevented future variations of misuse of the card.
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by tomjen3 on Saturday November 24, 2012 @02:36PM (#4826207)
Sure, except that it makes no sense to then compare the two signatures.
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by jacquesm on Sunday November 25, 2012 @05:37AM (#4827840)
Why did you give out those 4 digits? Really, I would have never ever done that. If they want to confirm and they're calling you then they should authenticate themselves, not you!
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by aw3c2 on Saturday November 24, 2012 @11:30AM (#4825595)
Did you not even ask who was asking?
Re:Do not ask me personal details when calling me by zaidf on Saturday November 24, 2012 @11:51AM (#4825663)
She gave me the name of the collections' agency and her own first name.